By Tim Rohr
As far as I know, this is the first public disciplining of a layperson by a bishop in our diocese. I've redacted the person's name so as not to cause him/her any more grief.
Jimenez's letter to this poor layperson reminded me of Apuron's public trashing of Fr. Paul and Msgr. Benavente back in the day. But this is an attack on a layperson.
Jimenez calls for charity. Really? Charity would have been to keep whatever the issue is between him and the layperson.
Can you ever imagine Jimenez writing a similar letter to one of the Neocat elite in this diocese, who routinely flaunt his authority?
No. Because he's afraid of them.

When bishops feel morally helpless or insecure in exercising their pastoral ministry in accordance with justice, truth, and charity, perhaps owing to a lack of moral integrity and authenticity in their own conduct, and when they are unable to resist pressure from those in positions of power, they risk resorting to public shaming rather than genuine pastoral engagement.
ReplyDeleteFrom the above post, it appears that a private letter from the parish priest would have been entirely sufficient to communicate the same concern to the person concerned. By choosing instead to make the matter public through a letter issued by the Bishop, the Diocese creates the impression that it is either unable or unwilling to address the issue through ordinary pastoral dialogue and appropriate canonical, legal, or administrative channels.
The very essence of pastoral leadership is to correct with compassion, guide with wisdom, and reconcile with charity. Episcopal authority is not a privilege to intimidate, expose, or publicly humiliate others; it is a sacred responsibility entrusted to bishops to serve God's people with humility, justice, and truth. As Christ Himself taught, authority in the Church must be exercised through service, not domination.
If the purpose of pastoral intervention is to restore rather than alienate, then the manner in which it is exercised is just as important as the matter being addressed. Public humiliation can never be a substitute for pastoral correction, nor can the exercise of ecclesiastical authority be detached from the moral obligations that give that authority its legitimacy.
Ultimately, the credibility of episcopal leadership rests not merely on the authority to correct others, but on the moral courage, personal integrity, authenticity, and Christian charity with which that authority is exercised. A bishop is called to be a shepherd of the flock, not an instrument of intimidation or public condemnation.
"Morally helpless" describes the majority of bishops today, especially the last few in Guam.
DeletePoor Lay person has been helping the church for a decade. AB Ryan just trash her like that “SHAME ON YOU” hope you can sleep well for what you did to this person.
DeleteWow. Thats quite a letter. What could she have possibly done that was so serious as to make it know to the world?
ReplyDeleteAnd yet, we have many things that do need to be made known to the world.
To name just a few:
1) a priest found guilty of sex abuse participating in a mass without permission and the bishop remains silent
2) the NCW blatantly disregards the moratorium and the bishop does nothing.
The list can go on and on but we all have many questions the bishop refuses to address, so we don’t need to list them all.
Archbishop Ryan: please address the problems in the church the people find important, and refrain from attacks against lay volunteers!
Not to mention another priest accused of sex abuse who died while in the AB's custody.
DeleteYes. I almost forgot. I guess that is the hope of our bishop, ignore until people forget!
ReplyDeleteAnd wasn’t he another neo-priest?
I seem to remember hearing at a recent mass the teaching of Jesus in Mt 18:15 that roughly says: if a brother sins against you then go alone and talk to him directly. If that doesn’t work, bring 2-3 others as witnesses. And if still doesn’t work, then bring it to the church community and treat them as an outsider.
ReplyDeleteThe letter from Christ’s representative on Guam states the problem arose from the funeral mass in October 30. And his letter to the offender is also dated 10/30. That means our shepherd forgot the first two steps of what Jesus is teaching, and skipped directly to step three, the nuclear option.
Archbishop, you have a doctorate in divine ministry, did you not remember what Jesus taught when you smeared this poor volunteer in front of all the people?
SHAME ON YOU!
Dear Archbishop Ryan:
ReplyDeleteRespectfully, I have a suggestion. A similar letter should be issued to the entire Catholic world that faculties for Fr Luis Camacho have been suspended because he has been found guilty of sex abuse of a minor. His ministry will be frozen until a decision has been reached on his second appeal, pending from Rome. If that appeal upholds the previous guilty verdicts he will be laicized. If the appeal finds him not guilty, we will determine at that time whether to restore his faculties or not.
Based on his previous disobedience restoral is not guaranteed. He previous acted as a priest in other dioceses even though his faculties were removed by his ordinary in Guam, a serious offense. Plus he also participated illicitly in the Easter Vigil Mass in 2026.
As soon as Rome renders its decision on the appeal we will publish the results and make a determination on his future status as a priest.
If anyone, in the entire Catholic world, is aware of any activities of Fr Luis acting in any way as a priest you are requested to contact the Archbishop’s office immediately so we may investigate his activities.
Please continue to pray for his victim, and pray also for the soul of Fr Luis.
Archbishop Ryan- do you even know where Fr Luis is at this time? Is he on Guam? Or is he being sheltered by a NCW community elsewhere in the world?