Showing posts with label Unborn Victims of Violence Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Unborn Victims of Violence Act. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 24, 2024

GUAM'S UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE ACT PUT TO USE

By Tim Rohr


Yesterday's Guam Daily Post ran a story about a woman reportedly striking another woman who was six months pregnant with a pipe and then dragging her by the hair until she fell on the ground and onto her stomach.

The last line of the story reads:

Nick was charged with aggravated assault as a third-degree felony and assault of an unborn child as a misdemeanor.

To my knowledge, this is the first time someone has been charged with an "assault of an unborn child." The law is P.L. 33-132 and the relevant part is set out in the Guam Code as follows:

§ 17.08. Assault of an Unborn Child.

    (a) A person commits assault of an unborn child if he or she, without legal justification and by any means, commits assault on a pregnant woman as defined in § 19.30 of Chapter 19, Title 9, Guam Code Annotated.

    (b) It is not a defense that no injury was caused to the unborn child as a result of the assault.

    (c) Assault of an unborn child is punishable to the same extent and manner as the offense of assault defined in Chapter 19 of Title 9, Guam Code Annotated. 

The law, the Unborn Victims of Violence Act, began as Bill 231-33 and was introduced by Sen. Frank Blas, Jr. IN 2016 with the support of The Esperansa Project. It was one of eight bills in six years that The Esperansa Project either initiated or supported and which were enacted into law despite a strong pro-abortion element in the Legislature. 

It was and is an important law because it enshrines the term "unborn child" into Guam Law and treats the unborn child as a distinct human being with a right to be protected in the womb. 

Saturday, June 3, 2023

UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE...LACI AND CONNOR'S LAW


I subscribe to History.com and get daily "on this day" stuff. Yesterday, June 1, there was this entry which piqued my interest:

"2004: Opening statements begin in Scott Peterson murder trial."

From the story: 

"On Christmas Eve 2002, the pregnant Laci had disappeared from Modesto, California...The bodies of Laci and her baby were found washed up on shore near the marina where Scott Peterson kept his boat on April 13 and 14, 2003. Within a week, Scott Peterson was charged with two counts of first-degree murder, with the special circumstance of double homicide..."

(Note: The story doesn't give detail, but since it says "the bodies" and gives two separate dates, one can presume that the unborn child had been separated from his mother and "washed up" separately and on a different day than his mother. Did Scott Peterson carve out his unborn son from his mother's womb and kill him separately? I'll need to further read the case - or you can do it yourself.)

Since people kill people all the time in California, and crimes of passion are common (Scott Peterson was in an extramarital affair at the time), the story might have quickly been buried but for a debate that was then raging in the U.S. Congress over what was ultimately named UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE ACT OF 2004 ("the Act") at the time the Peterson case went to trial. 

Congress passed the Act and President George W. Bush signed it into law. In short, the law states:

Whoever engages in conduct that...causes the death of, or bodily injury...to, a child, who is in utero at the time the conduct takes place, is guilty...the punishment...is the same as the punishment provided under Federal law for that conduct had that injury or death occurred to the unborn child’s mother. 
(The full act can be read here.)

The Peterson case factored heavily into the debate as evidenced by the fact that the new law was nicknamed "Laci and Connor's Law." 

Laci Peterson was Scott Peterson's murdered wife and Connor was their "murdered son."

"Murdered son" is in quotes because at the time, pursuant to Roe, a "fetus" was not defined as a human or a person, but only as "potential life." 

As you might imagine, pro-abortion groups, including then-Catholic-presidential candidate John Kerry, vehemently opposed the Act since, of course, it opened the door for legal personhood of "the thing" that was inside "the thing's" mother. 

Kerry and his pro-abortion gang were right about the danger of such a law. They knew that once legal personhood of an unborn "thing" was codified into law, it would ultimately lead to the unraveling of Roe, which it ultimately did (Dobbs 2022). 

The federal law not only criminalized the harming or the death of "the thing," the law codified "the thing" as a "child...in utero." And, in fact, said "child in utero" even had a name: "CONNOR." 

GUAM

In 2012, Sen. Frank Blas Jr. introduced similar legislation:

Bill No. 409-31 (COR) - F.F. Blas, Jr. An act to add Chapter 16 of Title 19 of the Guam Code Annotated relative to Acts of Violence against an unborn child. Received: 1/9/12 - 10:13 a.m.

The bill failed. Here is the voting sheet:


Four years later, in January 2016, Sen. Frank Blas Jr. reintroduced the legislation as BILL NO. 231-33 UNBORN VICTIM'S OF VIOLENCE ACT. 

This time, The Esperansa Project, after a string of other anti-abortion legislative successes, was aggressively involved. The bill passed and was signed into law by Governor Eddie Calvo on Mar. 4, 2016 as P.L. 33-132.

GUAM LAW: "UNBORN CHILD"


As of Mar. 4, 2016, the following is enshrined in Guam Law:
...unborn child shall mean a child in utero, and the term “child in utero” or “child, who is in utero” means a member of the species homo sapiens, at any stage of development, who is carried in the womb. - 9 G.C.A. § 17.03 (b)
While the subject law does not criminalize abortion in Guam, it does in fact preclude the pro-abort argument: "my body my choice." 

Guam's UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE ACT clearly identifies the "child in utero" as a human being, a separate human being who can be murdered, and for whose murder the murderer can and shall be punished:
The penalty for murder of an unborn child shall be the same as the penalty for murder defined in Chapter 16 of Title 9, Guam Code Annotated. - 9 G.C.A. § 17.05 (b)

Pursuant to Guam law, the pro-aborts can still murder their own children, but they are doing just that: murdering their own children. 

So instead of "my body, my choice," their mantra must needs be: HIS LIFE, MY CHOICE or HER LIFE MY CHOICE. In fact, why not give him or her a name? Like "Connor" or "Connie." The U.S. Congress did. 

BACK TO PETERSON

Scott Peterson was found guilty of murdering both Laci and Connor. 

In the murder of Connor, Scott Peterson's unborn son, Peterson was convicted and found guilty under California's Penal Code section 187, subdivision (a) [which] defines murder as “the unlawful killing of a human being, or a fetus, with malice aforethought.” 

What is quite interesting is that the subject section of California's penal code was expanded to include "the unlawful killing of...a fetus" in or about 1970. 

California is known to be one of the most liberal states in the nation. Yet, already in or about 1970, even California recognized the "malice" of "killing a fetus" and by implication, that said "fetus" was in fact a human being and a legal person - otherwise "it" could not be "killed." 

It would take "Catholic" Guam nearly half a century and two tries to do the same. 

And had it not been for The Esperansa Project and its supporters, the second bill would have probably suffered the same fate as the first. 

BTW. Here's the Voting Sheet on the bill that became Guam's UNBORN VICTIM'S OF VIOLENCE ACT.


FR. STAN FORTUNA
UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE


I was at the airport-
Opened up the paper-
I was shocked at what I saw-
Talk about a new law could it be a new rule
Or was it just another fool
I had to read it again-
Thought there was somethin I was missin-
Could it be it was the truth-
Comin from a politician-
Or was it just wishful thinking what I was readin
Or was it just an attempt to stop our national bleedin
A new kinda law-

To overturn Roe v Wade
To get the nation back on track-
With how we use financial aid-
All the hotsy-totsy people getting worked up in a tirade
Republicans and Democrats
Under-worked and overpaid
The next time in the court-
Death presented opposition-
The demon started screamin-
About the truth of our position-
They saw their end comin destined for the grave
Ain't this the land of the free
And the home of the brave

CHORUS:
Thou shall not kill
But not on Capital Hill
Ya let us do it with the doctor
Or we do it with the pill
Mommies ain't safe in the streets
But if a thug come and beats
Mommy over the head
And leaves the baby for dead
Ya say it's fine but it's tragic
We can't stop it with magic
It's politically bleak
It's cause we're spiritually weak
Y'all try to cover up the scam
With illegitimate silence
Check it "I'm here to defend
Unborn victims of violence"

Let's let freedom ring-
Bring it to the Senate-
These are the dogs-
Who gonna try to prevent it-
They will never admit it-

The government's the culprit-
There is silence in the clergy-
Some won't preach it from the pulpit-
Congress is afraid to speak-
They livin like a puppet-
You gotta watch ya never know
Who got their hand on a string
We'll never really find out
What happened to Kennedy and King
Too many educated lawyers-
Could the situation worsen-
Is it really true they don't believe-
It ain't a fetus but a person-
Governmental desecration
Multi-million lives been spent
What will it take for them to learn
The right to life is self-evident
Legislation makin bad laws-
Year to year case to case-
Destroying the culture-
Poisonin the market place-
This is the land of the free-
This is the home of the brave-
As we movin on we steppin back we livin like a slave
Livin in denial sleepin in a grave
The embryos are frozen the suicide's assisted
You call this freedom "wake up" this is seriously twisted

CHORUS:
Thou shall not kill
But not on Capital Hill
Ya let us do it with the doctor
Or we do it with the pill
Mommies ain't safe in the streets
But if a thug come and beats
Mommy over the head
And leaves the baby for dead
Ya say it's fine but it's tragic
We can't stop it with magic
It's politically bleak
It's cause we're spiritually weak
Y'all try to cover up the scam
With illegitimate silence
Check it "I'm here to defend
Unborn victims of violence"

CHORUS:
Thou shall not kill
But not on Capital Hill
Ya let us do it with the doctor
Or we do it with the pill
Mommies ain't safe in the streets
But if a thug come and beats
Mommy over the head
And leaves the baby for dead
Ya say it's fine but it's tragic
We can't stop it with magic
It's politically bleak
It's cause we're spiritually weak
Y'all try to cover up the scam
With illegitimate silence
Check it "I'm here to defend
Unborn victims of violence"

https://www.letssingit.com/fr.-stan-fortuna-lyrics-unborn-victims-of-violence-c47zphs
LetsSingIt - The Internet Lyrics Database

Wednesday, May 3, 2023

SENATOR TOM FISHER ON THE RAY GIBSON SHOW - MAY 1, 2023

By Tim Rohr


On this past Monday's Ray Gibson show, Ray invited Sen. Tom Fisher into the studio to discuss Fisher's Bill 106-37 which calls for a referendum on new abortion legislation - also written by Fisher - "to allow health care providers to provide abortion services without limitations..." 

Ray's interview with Fisher begins at about 1:49:00 into the show and a few things caught my attention to which I shall respond.

+++++

FISHER: "I understand the abortion question….but that is not the question here today. We are going to fulfill our responsibility under Dobbs."

MY COMMENTS:

What "responsibility" is that?

Abortion is already fully legal in Guam save for a very few limitations: no partial-birth abortion, parental consent for minors, informed consent for women seeking to abort, and a reporting requirement. 

Fisher's bill seeks to remove these limitations, all of which were constitutionally compliant under Roe and Casey, and had nothing to do with Dobbs. 

Since Fisher laments Dobbs and celebrates Roe and Casey, then that's what we already have in Guam: the freedom to abort pursuant to Roe and Casey. There is no further "responsibility" under Dobbs, unless of course Fisher and Barnes (sponsors) want to drive a final death stake through a still beating heart. 

By the way, if Fisher doesn't like the current limitations on abortion, then his issue is with Casey, not Dobbs. It was Casey which opened the door for common sense limitations on abortion like parental and informed consent and abortion reporting:

Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pa. v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833 (1992)

Re parental consent for minors:

This conclusion is in no way inconsistent with our decisions upholding parental notification or consent requirements. ... Those enactments, and our judgment that they are constitutional, are based on the quite reasonable assumption that minors will benefit from consultation with their parents and that children will often not realize that their parents have their best interests at heart. 

Re Informed Consent for the woman seeking to abort:

We are left with the argument that the various aspects of the informed consent requirement are unconstitutional because they place barriers in the way of abortion on demand. Even the broadest reading of Roe, however, has not suggested that there is a constitutional right to abortion on demand. ... Rather, the right protected by Roe is a right to decide to terminate a pregnancy free of undue interference by the State. Because the informed consent requirement facilitates the wise exercise of that right, it cannot be classified as an interference with the right Roe protects. The informed consent requirement is not an undue burden on that right.

Re abortion reporting:

The collection of information with respect to actual patients is a vital element of medical research, and so it cannot be said that the requirements serve no purpose other than to make abortions more difficult. Nor do we find that the requirements impose a substantial obstacle to a woman's choice. At most they might increase the cost of some abortions by a slight amount. While at some point increased cost could become a substantial obstacle, there is no such showing on the record before us.


FISHER: "… this submission is not an unlimited right to an abortion. It’s up to fetal viability, of course it’s up to fetal viability because the state then has an obvious interest in that." 

MY COMMENTS:

Fisher, in an apparent effort to sound reasonable and credible, is using the language of Roe which emphasized the state's interest in protecting what Roe called "potential life" after the first trimester:

(b) For the stage subsequent to approximately the end of the first trimester, the State, in promoting its interest in the health of the mother, may, if it chooses, regulate the abortion procedure in ways that are reasonably related to maternal health.

(c) For the stage subsequent to viability, the State in promoting its interest in the potentiality of human life may, if it chooses, regulate, and even proscribe, abortion except where it is necessary, in appropriate medical judgment, for the preservation of the life or health of the mother.

Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973) at XI

However, Fisher misleads. Fisher makes no mention of the state's "obvious interest in that" in his bill. In fact, Fisher leaves the decision to abort the child "after viability" completely up to the "health care provider" who is being paid to deliver a dead child, not a live one:

91B] 04. Permitted Services.

(a) General Rule. A health care provider has a statutory right under this Actto provide abortion services, and may provide abortion services, and that provider's patient has a  corresponding right to receive such services, without any of the following limitations or requirements:

(9) A prohibition on abortion after fetal viability when, in the good-faith medical judgment of the treating health care provider, continuation of the pregnancy would pose a risk to the pregnant patient's life or health.

 

GUAM'S UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE ACT 

At about 1:53:00 Ray asks:  

"How would it be handled in a criminal case if somebody attacked a pregnant woman at which point in a situation like that would it be considered an attack on the woman and the baby?"

FISHER: "Unclear. Most jurisdictions that have faced the issue have actually addressed it. If a mother for example is quickening and she is killed and the fetus dies then some states have actual statutes that provide for an additional charge of murder manslaughter whatever that is." 

RAY: "We do here." 

FISHER: "We do? Well, okay, well that answers your question then, right?"

RAY: "I don’t know when the viability kicks in on that, it might be just a blanket she’s pregnant and you took two lives and that’s all there is to it." 

Ray may be excused for not knowing the particulars of Guam's UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE ACT, but at least he knew the ACT exists. 

Apparently Senator Fisher did not. 

For the education of us all, said ACT does not address the moving target of viability. The ACT simply criminalizes any attack on the mother which harms or kills the "unborn child," who, according to the ACT is legally NOT a "fetus," as Fisher insists on calling the unborn child:

9 G.C.A. § 17.03. Definitions.

For the purposes of this Chapter, the following terms are defined to mean:

(b) unborn child shall mean a child in utero, and the term “child in utero” or “child, who is in utero” means a member of the species homo sapiens, at any stage of development, who is carried in the womb.

 

A PERSONAL NOTE

I don't know Senator Fisher. I never met him or interacted with him directly in any way. As a candidate, he presented himself as reasonable, knowledgeable, and credible. So I voted for him. Senator Fisher has every right to introduce whatever legislation he wants and to take any position he wants. I am tempted to advise him, though, not to mislead or lie. However, following such advice could be political suicide. Misleading and lying has worked so well for so many of his colleagues for so very long. In fact, even when they get caught and get voted out, they get voted in again the next time around. So carry on Mr. Fisher. Meanwhile, this referendum, if it becomes a referendum, will not be a referendum on abortion, it will be a referendum on the hearts and minds of the voters of Guam.