Showing posts with label Marriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Marriage. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 8, 2025

MODERN FATHERHOOD IS A THANKLESS JOB

This is a post that is different from the usual. However, it is worth posting because, as many are now realizing, the derogation of men and belittling of fatherhood is at the root of so many social ills. The post is copied from a Facebook post. The original is here.


Modern Fatherhood Is a Thankless Job

If you want to know what true silent suffering looks like—watch a father in 2025.

Fathers don’t just provide anymore. They sacrifice their lives, peace, and identity… and still get disrespected.

Because modern fatherhood isn’t about love. It’s about service. Duty. Disposability.

Let’s break it down:

1. The Legacy Trap

Every man’s deepest fear isn’t death—it’s raising children who don’t carry his name, his values, or his blood.

Legacy is everything. That’s why men build. That’s why men protect. That’s why men die working.

But guess what?

30% of DNA tests come back negative. And that’s just among those bold enough to check.

Do the math. If you have three kids, chances are one might not be yours.

So you’re telling me a man can work 35 years, sacrifice dreams, deny himself joy… and end up investing in another man’s sperm?

No refund. No apology. Just “thanks, Dad.”

2. Divorce Means Automatic Disconnection

Even if the children are yours, there’s still a 50% chance you’ll lose them after divorce.

The court hands her the house, the kids, the sympathy—and hands you bills, depression, and supervised weekend visits.

You become an outsider in the very family you built.

They call another man “Daddy.”

And you get Father’s Day texts… if you’re lucky.

3. Mothers Get the Spotlight, Fathers Get the Stress

The media worships motherhood.

Social platforms turn moms into superheroes for posting lunchbox ideas.

They get celebrated about 30 times around the year.

Meanwhile, the father who left the house at 5am, fought the traffic, paid the rent, almost got stabbed, survived hypertension, and came back home to loud silence? 

Zero praise.

She gets flowers for childbirth. You get bills for being the man.

4. If You’re Broke, You’re Trash.

Forget morals. Forget effort. Forget presence.

If you’re a man without money, you’re just an inconvenience—even to your kids.

The modern world respects deadbeat millionaires more than present, struggling fathers.

And when your kids grow up, guess who they take abroad?

Not the man who paid school fees.

Not even the one who bought them their first car.

It’s always the mom. She’s all deserving!

5. The Government Is Raising Your Children

Even if you stay. Even if you fight. Even if you provide. 

(Even if your wife aligns with you. 😏)

Modern fatherhood still loses.

Why?

Because the school is telling your son he might be a girl.

The media is teaching your daughter that men are predators.

TikTok is feeding them gender confusion, identity crisis, and a full menu of rebellion.

And you? You’re not allowed to say “No.”

You don’t raise your kids anymore. You sponsor them.

6. You Can’t Discipline. You Can’t Lead. You Can’t Even Speak

Try correcting your child, and you’re “toxic.”

Try setting rules, and you’re “controlling.”

Try raising your voice, and CPS might knock on your door.

So now, fathers are quiet.

Not because they’re weak—but because they’ve been silenced.

7. Society Protects Her, Not You

She cheats? It’s because you were emotionally unavailable.

She withholds sex? It’s self-care.

She takes your kids and vanishes? It’s “protecting them from trauma.”

You cheat? You’re a monster.

You complain? You’re weak.

You fight for custody? You’re unstable.

Welcome to modern fatherhood.

Conclusion: Why Do Men Still Do It?

Because men are wired to protect—even if they get destroyed doing it.

Because deep down, every real man still hopes he’ll be the exception.

But in this world?

Fatherhood is no longer a position of honor.

It’s a battlefield where you fight for children who might not be yours, in a house that’s not yours, with a woman who might not respect you—and a system that’s praying for your failure.

And yet… we still show up.

Because even in a thankless job, real fathers don’t quit.

But that doesn’t mean we don’t bleed.

Let the comment war begin.

I would love to hear the motherhood apologists spot where I am wrong this time.

Thursday, February 13, 2025

BE FRUITFUL AND MULTIPLY



LINK to online version

Unlike Christmas, Thanksgiving, New Year, and the Fourth of July, all of which have identifiable origins, Valentine’s Day (like Halloween) is a holiday for no apparent reason.

Sure, there is evidence that St. Valentine was a real person who was martyred near the end of the 3rd Century. However, the Catholic Church has many saints and, but for St. Patrick, there is no secular holiday for them like there is for St. Valentine.

There is speculation that Valentine became associated with love and marriage because he was executed for secretly marrying Christian couples. And the phrase “from your Valentine” is said to have come from a note Valentine had written on the day of his execution to his jailer’s blind daughter whom he had healed.

No matter the origin of the holiday or the legend, February 14, which in 496, is the day Pope Gelasius declared as the day Valentine was martyred, has become the day we particularly celebrate “love and marriage.”

Today we take for granted that love and marriage go together, and in that order. But history doesn’t reflect this. Historically, marriage and children went together and love came later, if at all.

I am reminded of the lovely song in Fiddler on the Roof where Tevye asks Golde: “Do you love me?” Over the following verses, Golde avoids answering, saying (singing) that for 25 years “I washed your clothes, cooked your meals, cleaned your house, given you children, milked your cow…”

But Tevye insists: “But do you love me?” Finally Golde relents and responds “After 25 years…I suppose I do.” Then the two end in a sweet duet singing: “It doesn't change a thing, but even so. After twenty-five years…it’s nice to know.”

For most of history (and still in some parts of the world), marriage was about the survival of our species, not love. Our laws still reflect this reality.

A few years ago when Guam’s marriage laws were being challenged on the basis of “love is love” and we should be able to marry whomever we love, I did a study of the marriage laws in every U.S. state and territory, and the word “love” did not appear.

Here’s the relevant part of Guam’s law:

10 GCA § 3101. What Constitutes Marriage. Marriage is a personal relation arising out of a civil contract, to which the consent of parties capable of making that contract is necessary. Consent alone will not constitute marriage; it must be followed by a solemnization authorized by this Title.

10 GCA § 3206. Particular Form Not Necessary. No particular form for the ceremony of marriage is required, but the parties must declare in the presence of the person solemnizing the marriage that they take each other as husband and wife, or as spouses.

The phrase “or as spouses” was added after the 2015 U.S. Supreme Court decision legalizing same-sex marriage, but still no mention of “love.” So much for the argument “love is love.”

Even the famous case, Loving v Virginia, which formed much of the basis for the argument for same-sex marriage, never mentions “love.” (The plaintiffs’ name notwithstanding.)

The Lovings were a biracial couple who were denied married status in Virginia in 1967. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that marriage between two people of different races could not be denied because marriage “is a basic civil right of man fundamental to our existence and survival.”

The Court did not spell out what “survival” meant because it was referencing a precedent case, Skinner v Oklahoma, wherein the Court spelled it out: “We are dealing here with legislation which involves one of the basic civil rights of man. Marriage and procreation are fundamental to the very existence and survival of the race.”

Of course this is a reflection of what God himself says to Adam and Eve in Genesis 1: 28. Upon creating them “male and female,” God doesn’t say “go and love each other.” Instead he orders them to “be fruitful and multiply.”

So where does love come in?

It really didn't enter marriage until the advent of Christianity. Prior to Paul telling men to love their wives “as Christ loves the Church” (Eph. 5:25), a wife was nothing more than a man’s property.

So it is fitting that a day dedicated to “love and marriage” is founded on a Christian martyr, a Catholic saint, who lost his head for marrying Christian couples, even if it's only a legend.

Happy Valentine's Day. Be fruitful and multiply. 

Tim Rohr has resided in Guam since 1987. He has raised a family of 11 children, owned several businesses, and is active in local issues via his blog, JungleWatch.info, letters to local publications, and occasional public appearances. He may be contacted at timrohr.guam@gmail.com     

Monday, January 20, 2025

YOU GOTTA STAY AT THE PARTY

By Tim Rohr


This will be a little different post than the JW usual. In fact, I should post it over at my other "Catholic" blog. Nevertheless, I'll post it here since this blog has a higher readership and this view may help someone that isn't necessarily looking for a "religious" perspective.

This past Sunday's gospel reading was the familiar "Wedding at Cana" whereat Jesus performs his first miracle. I'll copy the reading in full before sharing my thoughts:

Gospel. John 2:1-11

There was a wedding at Cana in Galilee,
and the mother of Jesus was there.
Jesus and his disciples were also invited to the wedding.
When the wine ran short,
the mother of Jesus said to him,
“They have no wine.”
And Jesus said to her,
“Woman, how does your concern affect me?
My hour has not yet come.”
His mother said to the servers,
“Do whatever he tells you.”
Now there were six stone water jars there for Jewish ceremonial washings,
each holding twenty to thirty gallons.
Jesus told them,
“Fill the jars with water.”
So they filled them to the brim.
Then he told them,
“Draw some out now and take it to the headwaiter.”
So they took it. 
And when the headwaiter tasted the water that had become wine,
without knowing where it came from
— although the servers who had drawn the water knew —,
the headwaiter called the bridegroom and said to him,
“Everyone serves good wine first,
and then when people have drunk freely, an inferior one;
but you have kept the good wine until now.”
Jesus did this as the beginning of his signs at Cana in Galilee
and so revealed his glory,
and his disciples began to believe in him. 

The usual sermon following this Gospel usually revolves around the unique roll of the Blessed Mother - even getting God the Son to do something he didn't want to do. In fact, it could be said she got him to do something that he wasn't supposed to do: "My hour has not yet come." 

Much can be said about this Gospel passage and much usually is. I particularly like this Gospel because it says so much about who the Blessed Mother is and what she can do for us poor creatures.

It was a few years ago when I suppose I finally matured enough to see something in this story that I've never heard before, and it's sort of a shame that we don't hear something said about this.

The key verse is when the headwaiter says to the groom: “Everyone serves good wine first, and then when people have drunk freely, an inferior one; but you have kept the good wine until now.”

Of course, neither the headwaiter nor the groom knew at first what really happened, though I suppose later everyone found out because the gospel goes on to say "and so revealed his glory, and his disciples began to believe in him."

As is usually the case, a single scripture passage or an account like this one can hold many meanings, and the great meaning for me is "you gotta stay at the party." 

When the wine ran out, probably some people left. There was obviously a disturbance in the party because the Blessed Mother was troubled enough to go to Jesus to fix the problem. And for those who stayed at the party, well, they got the best wine.

So, in short, and this is nothing new, God saves the best for last - for those who "endure to the end" as St. Paul tells us. And since this miracle occurs at a wedding, I believe it is a special message about marriage: endure to the end because God saves the best for last - for those who endure to the end. 

Stay at the party - even after the wine runs out. 

Thursday, December 21, 2023

FIDUCIA SUPPLICANS

By Tim Rohr


As many now know, Pope Francis has authorized priestly blessings for couples in "irregular unions," including same-sex unions. Most of what is in the news is filtered one way or another so you are encouraged to read the source document as posted on the Vatican website.

Friday, June 9, 2023

CAVEMAN MARRIAGE

By Tim Rohr


Warning: The following is long and kind of wandering. 

+++++

In this recent post, I said that Senator B.J. Cruz ("B.J.") was on to something with his (2009) domestic partnership bill and that I would get to it later. So here's the later.

B.J.'s bill would have made it legal for both same-sex and opposite-sex couples to form a domestic partnership which would mirror marriage but did not require solemnization, i.e. exchanging vows before a public official.

At the time, I thought that in the drama surrounding the whole uproar, that B.J. had forgotten to require solemnization. Maybe he did, but looking back on it, it really is where marriage is not only going, it is where marriage has already been, long before the government got a hold of it. 

CAVEMAN MARRIAGE

Before there was such a thing as a marriage license or even the word marriage, a man and a woman were considered bound to each other - usually for life - by their being declared bound to each other, either by their families or by themselves, or by simply holding themselves out as bound to each other by cohabitating and having children. 

B.J.'s bill, even though it still required a license and a filing of some sort, basically hearkens back to this primitive way of forming a lifelong bond between two people. 

Primitive marriage wasn't lifelong because the couple said "till death do we part." Primitive marriage was lifelong because for the better part of human history death was certain if they DID part. 

What came to be called marriage was a naturally occurring primal institution that organically sprang from the impulse to survive.

Of all beings that breed, human offspring takes the longest to mature: on average 14 years for females and 16 years for males. In fact, most state marriage laws reflect this reality - setting those ages as the minimum age to legally marry. The ages are not arbitrary creations of law. They are the dictates of biology: when female and male humans are usually capable of reproducing. 

In primitive times (and even not so long ago), a man and woman would normally bear many children. Again, it was about survival. Infant mortality rate was high, but also many children were needed to produce food - either by hunting or farming - and also to defend the family against hostile outsiders. 

Thus Scripture speaks of children as arrows in a quiver. (Psalm 127)

Having many children - again for survival - meant that mom and dad needed to stick around (and stick together) to see their offspring to maturity, and also so that their offspring would be around to take care of mom and dad when mom and dad couldn't take care of themselves. 

It's just the circle of life, and our laws and court decisions (prior to 2015 - and I'll get to that) reflect this fact: the fact being that what we came to call marriage is a naturally occurring primal institution which pre-exists the political order and of itself was naturally ordered to procreation and "the very existence and survival of the race."

The U.S. Supreme Court even says so:

"Marriage and procreation are fundamental to the very existence and survival of the race." Skinner v. Oklahoma, 316 U.S. 535, 541 (1942). 

WHAT'S LOVE GOT TO DO WITH IT?

I hate to break it to you, but for the better part of human history, the lifelong union of a man and woman, which came to be called "marriage," was not about "love." In fact, prior to the 1960's, the word "love" usually did not appear in any marriage formula or law. 

Here's the Catholic Church formula prior to Vatican II (1962-1965):

PRIEST: WILT though take N., here present, for the lawful wife, according to the Rite of our Holy Mother the Church?

MAN: I will

PRIEST: WILT though take N., here present, for the lawful husband, according to the Rite of our Holy Mother the Church?

WOMAN: I will

(The couple joins hands.)

MAN: I, N. N., take thee, N.N., for my lawful wife, to have and to hold, from this day forward, for better, for worse, for richer, for poorer, in sickness and in health, until death do us part.

WOMAN I, N. N., take thee, N.N., for my lawful husband, to have and to hold, from this day forward, for better, for worse, for richer, for poorer, in sickness and in health, until death do us part.

PRIEST I join you together in marriage, in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost Amen.

Nothing about love, only about law: lawful this and lawful that. That's because marriage was a lawful contract that could not be broken without lawful consequences. (And the same was true for secular marriages.)

Note: Modern Catholic theologians and thinkers prefer the word "covenant" over contract. But that's another post-Vatican II creation. Sure, marriage can be thought of as a covenant, but the traditional emphasis on the word "lawful" positioned marriage (at least in the Catholic Church) as an unbreakable legal contract.

After Vatican II (the 1960's), we begin seeing stuff like "to love all the days of my life" and stuff like that. The problem with that is...so what happens when the couple no longer "loves" each other? - which happens to most, sooner or later. 

THE CATHOLIC CHURCH OPENS THE DOOR TO SSM

On top of this "love" stuff inserted into the Catholic marriage vows, the Church, in 1983, reformulated its canon (law) relative to the purpose of marriage to read:

Can. 1055 §1. The matrimonial covenant, by which a man and a woman establish between themselves a partnership of the whole of life and which is ordered by its nature to the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of offspring.

Prior to 1983, this is what the Church held:

Canon 1013, § 1. The primary end of marriage is the procreation and education of children; the secondary ends are mutual help and the remedy of concupiscence.

The 1983 code not only erased the hierarchy of ends (primary...secondary), it created a new end: "the good of the spouses." And by its placement in the code (before procreation), the new code made "the good of the spouses" the primary end (or purpose) of marriage.

One can argue all day long that the new code did not do what I just said. But no one can argue that since the new code was promulgated that the rate of divorce among Catholics hasn't exploded to match that of non-Catholics. 

And further, perhaps to cover for this radical implosion of the Catholic marriage bond, the number of decrees of nullity ("annulments"), especially in the U.S., have so scandalously exploded that Catholic World Report labeled the U.S. "Annulment Nation."

It's not hard to figure out. Once "the good of the spouses" became the purpose of marriage, or even one of the purposes, it's not long before one of the spouses, or both, don't feel so "good" about who they married. So, the marriage is kaput. And Church tribunals are kept busier than a cat on a hot tin roof processing, and usually granting, requests for annulments. 

MAKING MARRIAGE ABOUT LOVE...NOT CHILDREN

Because there was nothing in U.S. laws or major court decisions relative to marriage that said anything about love, and in fact, (said laws and decisions) continued to emphasize that marriage was about procreation, same-sex marriage advocates needed to make marriage about love and not procreation - for obvious reasons.

Their favorite legal battering ram was the 1967 Supreme Court decision in Loving v Virginia, a decision that found state bans on interracial marriage unconstitutional. Same-sex marriage advocates latched on to a phrase in that decision and turned it into their battle banner. The phrase was:

“Marriage is one of the "basic civil rights of man..."  Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1, 12 (1967)

It worked. This phrase from Loving provided the key precedent in the 2015 SCOTUS decision holding bans on same-sex marriage to be unconstitutional. 

Amazingly, the same-sex marriage advocates succeeded in getting the Obergefell Court (and apparently their opponents) to ignore the fact that their battle phrase was only the first part of a longer sentence, the full sentence being:

Marriage is one of the "basic civil rights of man," fundamental to our very existence and survival. Skinner v. Oklahoma, 316 U.S. 535, 541 (1942).  Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1, 12 (1967)

It's right there. The Loving Court found state bans on interracial marriage to be unconstitutional pursuant to its finding in Skinner wherein the Court held:
We are dealing here with legislation which involves one of the basic civil rights of man. Marriage and procreation are fundamental to the very existence and survival of the race. ” Skinner v. Oklahoma, 316 U.S. 535, 541 (1942)
Pursuant to Skinner, and by extension, Loving, marriage is about procreation and procreation is about marriage. And only in that context is marriage "a basic civil right of man."

Note: At this point it is necessary to address a common argument against the natural connection between marriage and procreation. Critics will call out examples of couples who are incapable of procreation due to age or infertility, and then attempt to impugn the procreative function of marriage. The short answer is this: Even healthy, fertile couples have no control over procreation. They only have control over the procreative act. Use your imagination.

But of course, in order for same-sex marriage to gain a foothold, "love" was made to replace procreation. 

And so Justice Kennedy (in Obergefell) wrote:

No union is more profound than marriage, for it embodies the highest ideals of love...marriage embodies...love...

Ah. A new precedent. Suddenly marriage is about "love"...when it never was before. 

Note: Something tells me that one day Obergefell will "fell," oops, I mean "fall," for the same reason Roe fell. There simply is NOTHING in the Constitution nor in our history that supports the notion of "love" as  grounds for marriage. 

However, who can blame Justice Kennedy, a Catholic, when his own Church opened the door that he (and the majority) walked through three decades later.

By inserting "the good of the spouses" into the definition of the purpose of marriage, the Church made marriage about love. And though the canon includes "procreation," procreation still comes, well, second. 

Thirty years later, Kennedy's Court would do the same.

BACK TO B.J.'S BILL

So back to B.J.'s bill. Both the church and the state have made marriage meaningless. Oh, both still say the right words, but their actions...well, you know how that goes. 

No fault divorce, the constitutionalizing of same-sex marriage, and the wild fiasco of family law that has turned "big brother" into the new mom and dad, has made marriage an almost stupid thing to do - and it appears the younger generation gets this as an increasing number aren't even bothering. 

And, the Catholic Church's avalanche of annulments - and, the current pope's preference to fast track even more annulments, functionally giving credence to what others snicker as "Catholic divorce" - well, why even bother with a sacramental marriage when the Church you married in, can, even against your will, set your sacramentally married spouse free to marry someone else - and in the same Church...at the same altar...and right there in front of your face.

Note: Read this particular annulment adventure involving a famous U.S. Catholic family: Ex-Kennedy wife says Vatican overturns annulment

So maybe the heck with it. If two people want to spend their lives together and raise a family then let's go back to caveman days. In fact, more and more people are already doing it anyway. B.J., Dig out that bill.

A Final Note: Of course I am not rejecting sacramental marriage, and will never support SSM. I will believe in sacramental, potentially procreative marriage, and embrace it till I die because sacramental, potentially procreative marriage was instituted by Jesus Christ. If that makes me more Catholic than the pope, then so be it. Anyway, that's not too hard to do these days. 


Wednesday, August 30, 2017

MARRIAGE: PART 5 - Angry Women and Passive Men

MARRIAGE: PART 1 - FULTON SHEEN: MARRIAGE PROBLEMS
MARRIAGE: PART 2 - THE NEW ALBIGENSIANS
MARRIAGE: PART 3 - "LET THERE BE SPACES IN YOUR TOGETHERNESS"
MARRIAGE: PART 4- "BONUM CONIUGUM"

Note: I began this series after our local church leadership, in response to The Economist article about Guam having the highest divorce rate in the world, announced that the sad statistic was seen as an "opportunity to do more. " So I decided personally to do more by sharing, with you, articles such as this.

By Dr. James Dobson


The problem has its origins in childhood, long before a young man and woman stand at the altar to say, "I do." For her part, the girl is taught subtly by her culture that marriage is a lifelong romantic experience; that loving husbands are entirely responsible for the happiness of their wives; that a good relationship between a man and woman should be sufficient to meet all needs and desires; and that any sadness or depression that a woman might encounter is her husband's fault. At least, he has the power to eradicate it if he cares enough. In other words, many American women come into marriage with unrealistically romantic expectations which are certain to be dashed. Not only does this orientation set up a bride for disappointment and agitation in the future; it also places enormous pressure on her husband to deliver the impossible. CONTINUED

Wednesday, August 16, 2017

MARRIAGE: PART 4- "BONUM CONIUGUM"


In responding to my series of posts on Marriage, particularly my third installment, "LET THERE BE SPACES IN YOUR TOGETHERNESS", Anonymous August 16, 2017 at 6:24 PM states:
"Marriage went down the tubes in the US because mandatory joint income tax return filings are insanely high. Many happily married couples divorced but continued to live together because of that."
To which I replied"
"You are referring to the "marriage penalty." For those who don't know:
I further added:
"I tried to address this back in 2009-2010 during the first debates over legalizing same-sex unions. The pro-crowd kept shouting about all the benefits married people have. LOL. Not!"
I share this as a prequel to what I was already planning for my 4th installment on this series which is not what the civil government did, but what our own bishops did to destroy marriage. I actually wrote about it in 2013 in a post on my blog TheMassNeverEnds. However, I will copy it it here:

Monday, August 14, 2017

MARRIAGE: PART 3 - "LET THERE BE SPACES IN YOUR TOGETHERNESS"

Posted by Tim
Continued from Marriage: Part 3

Taking a break from the battle at hand, I return for a moment to our series on marriage. 

If you recall, we began this series after our church leadership held a press conference about Guam's notorious divorce rate, and about what - at least one priest said - was being done about so many suffering marriages. 

One of the most significant commentaries I have ever read about marriage came in the text of a poem by Kahlil Gibran. And I'll tell you why I think it is so significant after you read it:

On Marriage
 Kahlil Gibran

Tuesday, August 8, 2017

MARRIAGE: PART 2 - THE NEW ALBIGENSIANS

Posted by Tim
There has been increasing news lately, not just about the decline of marriage, but the lack of interest in it altogether. 

As could be expected in the face of this phenomenon, experts weigh in from every side as to the cause: from the trend towards cohabitation to, as the Japan Times reports about its own youth: a lack of interest in sex altogether. 

My outlook on everything (as is the Church's - at least historically), is one of spiritual warfare. Satan hates God. But Satan cannot attack God directly. So Satan attacks the nearest thing: his image: 

"And he said: Let us make man to our image...In the image of God he created them, male and female he created them. And God blessed them, saying: Increase and multiply, and fill the earth, and subdue it..." (Gen 1:26-27)

Man and woman, united by God and faithful to the command to "increase and multiply," is the very image of the "us" in the: "Let us make man in our image," in other words: The Trinity. 

Being the very image of God, we, the sacramentally married, and especially those who have not scarred our bodies with mechanical, surgical, or chemical means to prevent God from having more souls to love, should expect to be hated and warred upon by Satan. And we should expect Satan to pursue his purpose of robbing Heaven by any means. 

In the 11th and 12th century a particularly virulent strain of heresy grew up in southern France and Northern Italy. It was called Albigensianism after the town of Albi, where the heresy took root. 

Today is the feast of Saint Dominic who was the Church's foremost teacher against Albigensianism which condemned marriage and procreation, tolerated concubinage, and praised the desertion of husband or wife. (Read more.)

Today, at least this part of that heresy has returned to rule our modern world with a vengeance. 

St. Dominic, pray for us...and Lord, send us another St. Dominic.

Continued at Marriage: Part 3

Monday, August 7, 2017

MARRIAGE: PART 1 - FULTON SHEEN: MARRIAGE PROBLEMS


Last week, Fr. Jeff San Nicolas (in the name of the Archdiocese of Agana) hosted a press conference to address the embarrassing news that - as per a 2013 Economist report - Guam leads the world in the number of divorces per capita each year. 

Both Fr. Jeff and divorce attorney, William Pesch, appeared to blame Guam's "off-island divorces" as the reason for the world-leading divorce numbers. However, in my post THE REST OF THE STORY (Part 1),  I demonstrated that Pesch himself had earlier downplayed the number of off-island divorces and that even if we subtracted the number of those divorces, Guam would still rank 4th in the world. 

Further into the Daily Post report on the press conference, Fr. Jeff's comments caught my attention: 
"When I hear the numbers, it doesn't discourage me – I see it as an opportunity, as a calling for us to continue to do more," he said...We need to do what we can to be there for all marriages. ... In the sense that we can support them so that a decision that a couple makes to live together to love each other for life – they are equipped to fulfill that promise that they make to each other."
As evidence of the church's "support" for marriage, Fr. Jeff featured representatives of three groups at the press conference: Couples for Christ, Worldwide Marriage Encounter, and the Sponsor Couple program. 

Thursday, August 3, 2017

NEWS: GUAM'S NATION LEADING DIVORCE RATE - THE REST OF THE STORY

Posted by Tim

Marriage: Part 1

KUAM: Archdiocese addressing Guam's nation-leading divorce rate
GUAM DAILY POST: Church sets sights on Guam divorce rates



This past June 8, under the post title APURON'S LEGACY, I posted the Economist news item referenced in the above news stories which I'll copy here:



I first want to address the comment by divorce attorney extraordinaire, William Pesch, wherein (KUAM reports) Pesch believes that the "numbers aren't as high as data suggests...because Guam law allows non-residents to divorce on Guam." (Apparently, Fr. Jeff thinks the same: "...San Nicolas said the statistics could be misleading, since non-residents are also allowed to get divorced on island." - Daily Post)

Thursday, February 2, 2017

GOD'S ANSWER TO ALL OUR PROBLEMS

We interrupt our normal schedule of news about our primary topic to bring you God's answer to all of our problems.

Discover God’s Mercy with Marriage

LINK to online article


Wednesday, April 22, 2015

THE SIXTH COMMANDMENT


There have been several comments related to homosexuality. Some I have published, others I have held as I could see they could be hurtful as well as wrong. 

While our church leaders seem to flounder about when all they need to do is quote the Catechism, let us not make the same mistake by similarly floundering about with our own ideas of what the Church teaches or what we would like it to teach. 

Instead, let us carefully read EXACTLY what the Church teaches as written in the Catechism of the Catholic Church:

Thursday, April 9, 2015

WHERE DO I STAND?

One of the tricks that was used by the proponents of Guam's previous attempt at legalizing same-sex unions was to make it look like the archbishop personally was not willing to compromise. This allowed the proponents to objectify a single target and freeze it, or in this case: him. 

Unfortunately, due to the archbishop's lack of control of the message that was being put out in his name, the trick worked. And once the archbishop was objectified as the sole opponent of the bill, it was easy to then vilify the whole Catholic Church as homophobic, which is standard "m-o" for same-sex protagonists. 

The truth is of course that no bishop or priest has the authority to say anything other than what the Church says on matters of faith and morals where those matters are magisterially defined. And the right use of the sexual function is one of those matters. In short, sex by design, God's design, makes babies:
"God created man in his image; in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them. God blessed them and God said to them: Be fertile and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it." (Gen 1:27-28)
We might use sex for other things (money, pleasure, or even intimacy), but then we depart from God's design.

Friday, February 6, 2015

LISTEN IN

Today on Patty Arroyo's show on K57 at 12pm, Jessica & Angelica Rohr, Hannah White and Sirena Mafnas will be sharing their thoughts about the values of keeping their "V-cards". Their thoughts were previously featured in the following article in the PDN:

http://www.guampdn.com/article/20150202/LIFESTYLE/302020017/Choosing-keep-v-card-

Jessica Rohr, Hannah White and Angelica Rohr with Patti Arroyo


Preserving your virginity for marriage.

Saturday, January 31, 2015

CATHOLIC MEN'S CONFERENCE: "HOW TO TURN YOUR MARRIAGE INTO A PATH TO HEAVEN INSTEAD OF A ROAD TO HELL"

Thank you to those who attended my talks today at the Men's Conference, and thank you to those who invited me. While titled on the program as a talk on "Theology of the Body", I retitled it "How to turn your marriage into a path to heaven instead of road to hell." In the talk I shared how the teachings of John Paul II were incorporated into my own marriage and the raising of my family. 

In the talk I referenced the following:

Matthew 19: 3-8 - "in the beginning it was not so"

Genesis 1: 26-28 - "let us make man in our image"


Saturday, May 26, 2012

WHY IS IT SO DIFFICULT TO TALK ABOUT MARRIAGE?


That’s the question posed by the editors of THE MEANING OF MARRIAGE, a collection of scholarly essays examining the societal impact of same-sex marriage. 

Essentially the answer is “because we’ve never had to”, at least not in the way we are forced to discuss it today. 

Though marriage has been at or near the heart of almost every issue of human endeavor, from royal alliances to what to make for dinner, the fundamental male-female nature of marriage has never before been called into question, which is why we find ourselves stammering in defense of marriage after we say “Because....”

In fact, the very fact that we are at a loss for words is sort of an explanation in itself. From the dawn of human consciousness, and quite without instruction other than that which was carved into our bodies, men and women intuited the need to “marry” long before there was a word or a “grunt” for it. It probably went something like this:

Man and woman make baby. Baby can’t take care of itself. Man go hunt and collect berries to feed baby and woman. Sooner or later, man and woman make another baby. Man go hunt more and collect more berries.

It probably wasn’t out of any external sense of moral obligation that the man did his part to provide and protect. Sons and daughters, in time, meant protection and help when the man could no longer protect or help himself. The permanent bonding necessary to raise a child to adulthood simply derived from the will to survive.

In short, marriage is the organic extension of the procreative act. It proceeds from the very nature of our bodies, which are fundamentally ordered towards generation. All of nature is simply designed to make more of itself. And the life-giving, life-nurturing, life-long thing that we have come to call marriage, which some try to tell us is mere social or religious convention, is really a primordial phenomenon that has, through generations of natural selection, proven to be the most effective model of human survival.

True, both society and religion eventually adapted it, codified it, regulated it, and protected it, but they didn’t create it, and never claimed to. And this is why “same-sex marriage” will never achieve the equality it presumes to seek. Same-sex marriage will forever owe its existence to the state. And irregardless of the rights and status the state might concoct for it, same-sex marriage simply has no history, no primordial roots, and no organic connection to human survival.

This is not because history is homophobic. Same-sex unions of any kind, quite apart from any religious circumscription, are, by their very nature, a Darwinian dead-end. And no legislative or judicial machinations can change that fact.

But this is also why we find it so difficult to defend marriage. Long before same-sex marriage appeared on the legal horizon, heterosexual married couples, through chemical, surgical, or mechanical means, had already divorced sex from its procreative end. And, natural marriage, the organically occurring intuitive relationship between the co-creators of a unique and separate being, once intentionally and artificially stripped of its procreative end, simply has no standing. Thus, our appeals to the procreative purpose of marriage ring with a contraceptive thud relative to the increasing din of chants for marriage equality.

In altering its ends, its purpose, we have altered the nature of marriage itself. Empirically speaking, the “good of the spouses” has become the primary end, and child rearing has not only become a secondary end, it has been relegated to an optional marital appendage - something to fit in once educational and career goals are met and before a woman’s biological clock runs out...if at all.

Such a thing is completely new to the human experience. Marriage has never been ultimately about spouses but about progeny. And unintentional sterility aside, everything about marriage is historically, culturally, and socially ordered to support that end. 


That many if not most of us have subscribed to this new ordering of the purpose of marriage, leaves us little ground on which to stand, be it in opposition to same-sex marriage or explaining why couples should marry at all.

Saturday, July 2, 2011

MARRIAGE "EQUALTIY" CREATES NEW INEQUALITIES


New York has become the sixth state to legalize “gay marriage”. Catholic lawmakers provided the key votes and a Catholic governor signed the bill into law. Catholic senator, Mark Grisanti, said that though he was raised to believe that marriage was between a man and a woman he could not “legally come up with an argument against same-sex marriage.” 

Grisanti continued: "If I take the Catholic out of me...then absolutely they should have these rights...” Grisanti’s comments invite further comment on: 1) the issue of rights, 2) the legislative imposition of personal beliefs, 3) the legal argument against same-sex marriage.

Rights
New York’s gay marriage bill actually had nothing to do with rights. As Katherine Franke, a partner in a same-sex domestic partnership, wrote in the New York Times the day before the vote, same-sex couples, under New York’s domestic partnership law, already have all the rights of married people. Ms. Franke even bemoaned a possible loss of freedom and flexibility that she now enjoys in a domestic partnership that she would not have within the tighter legal strictures of marriage. 

Legislative imposition of personal beliefs
Grisanti’s metaphysical contortion about taking “the Catholic out of me” is another transliteration of the “I’m personally opposed, but...” that lawmakers will resort to when shrinking from a moral stand. Though raised to believe that marriage was between a man and a woman, Grisanti said he could not legally come up with an argument against same-sex marriage. We must then wonder what else Grisanti was raised to believe that he should not be making laws about: lying, cheating, stealing, murder?

All laws have a moral base.  Politicians decide what’s right and wrong for the rest of us all the time whether its setting a speed limit or outlawing murder. As of June 23, Guam senators have introduced 243 bills! That means that Guam senators are deciding what is best for the rest of us 1.4 times every day including holidays and weekends! It’s only when it comes to same-sex legislation and abortion that certain lawmakers suddenly wax philosophical. Hmmm.

Legal argument
As for the lack of a legal argument against same-sex marriage, this was a senate chamber, not a court room. Senators engage the process which makes things legal or illegal. As a senator, Grisanti did not need a legal argument, he was in a position to make one. But since he didn’t, I will, or at least I will borrow one from Don Browning, Professor Emeritus at University of Chicago Divinity School.

Browning, along with other legal theorists, wonder if giving marriage benefits to same-sex couples “does injustice to other human arrangements where people care for one another...” Such arrangements could include a man or woman caring for an ailing sibling, an adult child caring for an aging parent, or two elderly persons of the same sex in a non-sexual relationship pooling resources. 

Why should they, simply because they are NOT in a sexual relationship, be denied the same rights that New York has now extended to same-sex couples because they ARE in a sexual relationship? In short, if marriage is simply a matter of mutual caring divorced from procreation, then it is an INJUSTICE, as Browning says, “to extend marriage privileges to a particular group of sexual friendships while excluding many other interdependent care givers.” 

But beyond the legal argument there is the official teaching of the Catholic Church which these Catholic politicians chose to ignore at their own peril. Every Catholic needs to know exactly what our Church teaches on this matter and where it can be found. It is as follows:


“When legislation in favour of the recognition of homosexual unions is proposed for the first time in a legislative assembly, the Catholic law-maker has a moral duty to express his opposition clearly and publicly and to vote against it. To vote in favour of a law so harmful to the common good is gravely immoral.” (Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Considerations regarding proposals to give legal recognition to unions between homosexual persons, June 3, 2003, Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, Prefect)

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Polygamy advocates in the U.S. have cause for hope

(published in the Marianas Variety (August 2010) as "Matrimonial Chaos)
Justice Vaughn Walker, in striking down California’s ban on gay marriage (Perry v. Schwarzenegger), has opened wide the doors for the much persecuted advocates of plural marriage. A little background:

In 1862, in a response to the Mormon practice of a man taking multiple wives, Congress passed the Morrill Anti-Bigamy Act. The law was largely unenforced. So 20 years later, Congress passed the Edmunds Anti-Polygamy Act (1882), which was enforced, and resulted in more than 1,300 men being sent to prison.

Women were initially seen as victims and were not prosecuted directly, but since the Act also abrogated “spousal privilege”, many were found "in contempt of court" and jailed for refusing to testify against their husbands.

The Edmunds Act not only made polygamy, which it called “unlawful cohabitation”, a felony but also revoked polygamists' right to vote, made them ineligible for jury service, and prohibited them from holding political office.

Five years later, Edmunds was at it again with the Edmunds-Tucker Act (1887) which further persecuted the Mormons. The Act disincorporated the Church, allowed the federal government to confiscate its property, disenfranchised women, and removed local control of school textbook choice...and this is only a partial list. (Talk about a persecuted minority!)

In 1892, Congress hammered another nail in the polygamous coffin with a federal anti-bigamy provision which excluded polygamists from immigration into the United States. It remains part of the current U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Code. (Wonder if they are enforcing this on Muslims?)

In 1878, the first challenge to the federal ban on plural marriage reached the Supreme Court in Reynolds v. United States. Reynolds, a Mormon, simply obeying the statutes of his religion and having two wives,  challenged the ban under the First Amendment clause: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof...”

The Court responded by stating that the word “religion” was not defined in the Constitution and “must go elsewhere...to ascertain its meaning”.  The “elsewhere” that the Court settled on was a letter by Thomas Jefferson to the Danbury Baptist Association wherein Jefferson writes in reference to the Establishment Clause: “...that the legislative powers of the government reach actions only, and not opinions”.

In other words, the federal government cannot tell you what to think about religion (opinion) but they can tell you what you can and cannot do (actions), especially when, as the Court deduced, those actions which are “in violation of social duties or subversive of good order.” (This same letter, by the way, is where we find the troublesome reference to “separation of church and state”.)

The Court then baptized Jefferson’s letter (and in effect judicially amended the Constitution) with the following sentence: “Coming as this does from an acknowledged leader of the advocates of the measure, it may be accepted almost as an authoritative declaration of the scope and effect of the amendment thus secured.” (As you can see, the Court’s argument can be reduced to “because Jefferson said so.”)

But the nasty business of defining “subversive of good order” was still left undone. In order to fill in the blanks, the Court resorted to a reasoning that today would be laughable (but still stands): “Polygamy has always been odious among the northern and western nations of Europe, and, until the establishment of the Mormon Church, was almost exclusively a feature of the life of Asiatic and of African people.” Translation: Europe, the U.S., and White People are civilized. Black and Yellow people are heathens. Today, Reynolds remains the law of the land. (Reynolds went to jail for two years.)

But now the Walker decision has produced the first real opportunity in over a hundred years to reverse Reynolds and legalize polygamy. And if I was a polygamy advocate, I would piggy-back on the Perry case all the way to the Supreme Court. For if marriage is only a “union of equals” (Perry pg 113) then not only is gender no longer a limiting factor, but number as well. In other words, “Why only two?” After all, polygamous marriage has a far greater historical pedigree than does homosexual marriage. (Contrary to the Reynolds reference to Asians and Africans, polygamy was an essential feature of the Judaic tradition, a tradition this country claims as part of its foundation.)

The crazy thing is that we already allow a form of polygamy in our country. Quoting the header at Polygamy.com: “A man can have sex with as many women as he likes. But he can’t marry more than one. If we don’t have a good reason to discriminate, then we probably shouldn’t.” And of course men and women can marry as many partners as they want. They just have to do the paperwork.

In addition, while a man is sent to jail for making a legal commitment to the women he has sex with (if more than one), another man is free to disseminate his seed with abandon (with the state often picking up the tab to care for his progeny), so long has he doesn’t legally commit to any more than one.

But aside from polygamy, there are other considerations regarding legal obstacles to marriage the Walker decision has opened up such as: age requirements, consanguinity (blood relations), affinity (kinship by marriage), vaccination requirements, disease testing, physical exams, proof of sufficient mental capacity, waiting periods, impotency, and consummation laws (still valid in some states, e.g. Alabama).

Given Walker’s decision that “same-sex couples are situated identically to opposite-sex couples in terms of their ability to perform the rights and obligations of marriage...” (Page 113), there simply is no reason to prohibit marriages between brothers and sisters, mothers and sons, uncles and nieces (or nephews for that matter) one man and 10 women, 10 men and one woman, etc.

The fact that such a list of restrictions on marriage exist in law is a testament to the state’s foundational understanding and expectation of marriage: to produce and educate the next generation. If this is no longer the case, then none of the civil impediments to marriage have any foundation and either must be struck down or the civil institution of marriage eliminated altogether.