Showing posts with label Clergy Sex Abuse in Guam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Clergy Sex Abuse in Guam. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 23, 2025

THE EPSTEIN THING


LINK to online version

Putting my “false allegations” series on hold for the moment, I want to address the Epstein thing.

I don’t have a problem acknowledging that Jeffrey Epstein was most likely a deep state intelligence operative. Nothing else explains how he got away with so much for so long. It also explains why the so-called “client list” remains elusive.

I am also quite on board with the assertion that Epstein rose mysteriously to unprecedented wealth and influence because he was extraordinarily adept at supplying a steady stream of sex-workers to powerful people.

I call them “sex-workers” and not “victims” on purpose.

Hardly an Epstein story goes by without the requisite media sobbing about his “victims.” There are two problems with this. First, they weren’t victims. Second, it’s a distraction from the real matter: uncovering Epstein’s deep-state connections and activities - in short, who Epstein was really working for and why.

His “girls,” minors or not, was just the currency he trafficked in to do his job, a job that made him a billionaire since no other business activity or financial venture can be identified as the source of his voluminous cash flow.

They weren’t victims

According to the court papers I have read, all of Epstein’s “girls” arrived at his many mansions willingly and were well-paid for their services. They were sex-workers, not victims, and it appears the majority of them not only liked their “jobs,” but recruited others for similar employment.

I saw and worked with real victims of sexual abuse in the Apuron case. At the time of their being victimized, they were young, trusting altar boys who thought they were only helping their pastor when he invited them to his house of horrors. They weren’t expecting to be molested, raped, and then threatened to keep their mouths shut for the rest of their now ruined lives.

That’s what a victim looks like. That’s what abuse looks like.

Underage?

Court papers say some of Epstein’s sex-workers were as young as 14. So? What’s all the fuss? Being less than 18 years old might keep you from buying cigarettes, but the law in most states, including Guam, says it’s okay to engage in consensual sex at 16.

Meanwhile, while the majority of Americans are all riled up about Epstein and his clients, according to the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry that same majority of Americans (67%) supports distribution of free contraceptives in schools. Ummm, what do you think these little girls and boys are going to do with that stuff?

Here in Guam, as advertised on the website for the Bureau of Women’s Affairs, contraception is free at all public health facilities. Apparently there is no age limit. Hmmm. Kids can’t buy cigarettes until they’re 18, but can help themselves to condoms and birth control pills as soon as they’re tall enough to peer over the counter and say “Please Sir, I want some more.”

Those who think “they’re just going to do it anyway” are probably thinking their teens are having sex with teens, so they might as well be “protected.” But as the Epstein story (and many others) demonstrates, why would a fourteen year old girl want to have sex with a broke fourteen year old boy when she can score thousands of dollars off an older man with means?

So don’t give me that “they were only 14 and didn’t know any better.” Parents (67% anyway) are practically handing their minor children contraceptives and signing a permission slip to have sex with whoever they want. Should we now be upset when those same kids figure out a way to make money at it - as Epstein’s girls did?

Pedophile?

It’s a useful word because of its “disgust” level, but Epstein was no pedophile - a pervert yes, but no pedophile. Pedophilia is clinically defined as a sexual preference for prepubescent children. While the record shows that Jeffrey liked them young, he didn’t like them that young.

The same with Apuron and just about all of the clergy sex abuse cases nationwide. The record (the John Jay Report) shows that the sexual preference was for adolescents, i.e. sexually mature, and in the clergy cases, overwhelmingly male. So pedophilia was not the operative perversion. I’ll let you figure out what was.

Given the filth and perversity we as a society unthinkingly accommodate daily, it’s hard not to see that all this righteous fixation on Epstein’s “list” isn’t a collective Freudian conscience-swabbing exercise in projection.

Tim Rohr has resided in Guam since 1987. He has raised a family of 11 children, owned several businesses, and is active in local issues via his blog, JungleWatch.info, letters to local publications, and occasional public appearances. He may be contacted at timrohr.guam@gmail.com 

Sunday, April 13, 2025

THE FILTH IN THE CHURCH

By Tim Rohr


As April is "Child Abuse Awareness Month," I've been seeing multiple articles and notices about what the Archdiocese of Agana is doing.

The Guam Daily Post reports:

Guam's Catholic church is holding a series of forums in April in conjunction with Child Abuse Prevention month, Sexual Assault Awareness month, and Youth Violence Prevention month.

The meetings, to be hosted at various parishes across the island, were also mandated by a federal bankruptcy court settlement in the clergy sexual abuse cases. 

One wonders if the archdiocese, or more specifically, the current archbishop, would be doing anything if not MANDATED by the federal court settlement. 

I ask this because sex abuse of minors was rampant for decades in this diocese and it wasn't a secret. It was whispered about everywhere, and not just by clergy, but many lay people too. 

But no one did anything. And when finally a very few people did do something, we were publicly threatened with "canonical and legal measures." 

As the Pacific Daily News reported on June 1, 2016:

“Those who are orchestrating this campaign are inciting people into hatred of the Archbishop and the Catholic Church. They have produced scandal, confusion and grave errors with the cruel intent to injure the Archbishop, the Catholic Church in Guam and many other people of good will who have been outraged and harassed. Therefore, the Archdiocese of Agana is in the process of taking canonical and legal measures against those perpetrating these malicious lies,” the Archdiocese said.

Such threats cost some of us a lot: financially, personally, societally, psychologically. And some of us paid with our families. You might say that those who spoke up for the abused were just as abused, and maybe even more given that the majority of abuse victims who came forward never had to give their names, but our names were front page news for months.

After years of being at the center of this ugliness, I have to wonder if those of us who stood up accomplished anything at all. Sure, Apuron is gone (or is he?), as well as some of his gestapo (Adrian, David the Tall, Edivaldo), but has anything been done to address the clerical culture in this diocese that engendered, protected, and promoted this filth for decades? 

Giving kids a "safe space" sounds good, but there is no safe space as long as the demon at the core of all this filth is still allowed to roam. 

And what is that demon? I won't go into it here, but I'll leave a clue. The real abuse was not pedophilia, but ephebophilia. There is a big difference. 

Meanwhile, the archbishop would do well to apologize for all the hell his predecessor wreaked on the few brave people who stood up to what Benedict 16 famously called "the filth in the church." 


Sunday, November 10, 2024

SO THAT THIS SH*T NEVER HAPPENS AGAIN!

By Tim Rohr

Troy's post (or here) titled "The Archdiocese is being dishonest, feigning remorse but now blaming their rape victims" provides much to comment on, everything from the accusation in the title to the other side of the story to the real reason to attend Mass in the first place. 

So let's give it a go.

Troy is upset over an announcement at a recent Mass wherein parishioners were asked to contribute money in order to purchase a parish property which was forfeited as part of the archdiocesan bankruptcy settlement to compensate victims of clergy sex abuse. 

Upon hearing the announcement, Troy writes:

I sat there embarrassed, feeling bad. I felt ashamed. And then I thought, fuck you. I was ashamed when my St. Anthony School vice principal raped me for the first time on December 8, 1993, and then scores more over the next several months. I was 13. I’m tired of the shame that I was raped by a Catholic school teacher when I was a kid. I’m tired of the Catholic Church covering up for its holier than thou pedophiles and pedo sympathizers. Sick miscreants. Piss off, and then when your little penises scrape the last pieces of shit stuck in your degenerate and pedophile  anal canals, piss off again. 

I can somewhat empathize with Troy. Several months ago as the bankruptcy case came to a close, there were several announcements after many Masses about the financial hardship my particular parish would be facing. And there I stood in my pew, feeling like all eyes were on me, since after all, the bankruptcy had its genesis on this very blog.

Given what the fallout of my actions to expose the largest clergy sex abuse machine in the whole Catholic world (per capita) cost me, I've often second guessed myself, especially since, other than ridding the church of Apuron and closing down the fake seminary, nothing much has changed. 

The Neo's are still here and going strong. The Neo-priests, one of whom appears to now be Troy's new hero, are still here. And several who aren't here are still on our payroll. And the sordid moral culture which gave both rise and cover to the sexual perversity that spawned the worst record of clergy sex abuse in the whole Catholic world is still here. 

So while standing there at Mass, all alone in my pew (because I lost my family), and hearing how the church and parish is now suffering as a result of my actions...well...let's say I certainly did feel singled out. But I stopped short of feeling "embarrassed" or "ashamed" as Troy relates. 

I can also relate with Troy on another thing. I don't talk about it much but I have referred to it in previous posts: I was also "abused" by a priest in my teens. (Note: Troy was abused by a teacher, not a priest.) He didn't get very far with me because I ran away. But just the "approach" violated me, especially since the priest had showed such interest in me - which I thought was genuine, but turned out to be "grooming."

And that was just the beginning of the damage. The only way I can explain the damage that followed is to refer to that scene in Fiddler on the Roof where Tevye sings "And one little time you pull out a thread, and where has it led? Where has it led?"

Tevye was referring to "tradition," tradition as the thing that keeps everything together. In the family I grew up in, the Church and the pastor were everything, especially for my father who was not only the head usher, the president of the Holy Name Society, and the parish troop Boy Scout Master, he was also the pastor's right hand man - the man who the pastor called in the middle of the night when the rectory roof was leaking or the toilet wasn't working.

I didn't tell my father what happened to me. I didn't really know what happened to me. I just knew something was wrong and I had gotten away from it. But a few years later I inadvertently discovered the pastor in a sexual situation with an adult man who lived next to the church in a house that the parish owned, and a house my father had often worked on free of charge. It turned out that the neighbor man was not only in a sexual relationship with our pastor but was living in the house rent free and helping himself to the parish funds as a perk for being the pastor's boyfriend.

Learning all this, especially way back in the 70's before any of this was known, devastated my father. He stopped going to Mass, developed a hatred for the Church and especially for priests, and things went downhill for him from there. As things descended for my father, so did they descend for the rest of us, leading to the death of my brother which my father blamed on himself, causing him to descend ever further. 

"One little time you pull out a thread, and where has it led? Where has it led?"

In the meantime, all this caused me to become a warrior, not against the Church, but for it. I hated what the Judases were doing to my faith, my religion, my Church, and my family, and it made me hyper-vigilant to anything that smelled of the smoke of Satan, particularly in the sanctuary. 

I ran into it again when I was a teacher in the U.S. Virgin Islands. No need to go into that story here, but it was almost a replica of what happened in my home parish years earlier. So I wasn't new to this stuff when the Apuron thing showed up in my face. In fact, it had been showing up ever since I moved here in 1987, especially living in Agat with all those stories about "the Agat boys."

In January of 2015, I related these experiences to an Apostolic Visitator (aka "Inquisitor") named Archbishop Savio Hon, the then-Secretary for the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples. The same Hon would be appointed Apostolic Administrator to this archdiocese after Apuron fled Guam over one year later. 

I don't remember how those stories came up when Hon interrogated me, but they did. And upon telling Hon of my past experiences with the likes of Apuron, Hon accused me of carrying out a personal vendetta against Apuron. 

There were others in the room, including Archbishop Martin Krebs, the then-apostolic nuncio. Upon being accused by Hon, I stuck my hand in his face and said "Stop! I am the father of eleven children and all I'm trying to do is get them into heaven, and I'm having to fight against clerics like you to do it."

Hon adjourned the inquisition and showed me the door. Archbishop Krebs walked out with me. When we got outside, he put his arm around me and said "good show." Krebs knew what was going on. And I believe he knew that Hon had not been sent to Guam to get to the bottom of the problem, but to save the Neocatechumenal Way, which is exactly what we would find out a couple years later.

(At the time Hon was taking orders from Cardinal Filoni, the "Red Pope," and the Neocats main man in Rome.)

And this is what makes this thing with Troy weird. As mentioned, his apparent new priest-hero is the neocat priest, Harold Colorado Prieto, who Troy is now defending (I wrote about it here and here), yet Harold was not only Apuron's right hand man and constant companion for several years, but he was also part of the cabal that worked to shut me up and shut me down so that the same clergy abuse that Troy hates so much would never be exposed.

Weird.

Now, let's get back to the thing that Troy is mad about.

Usually when I see a post from Troy about church, it's about Mass at St. Anthony's in Tamuning. However, the thing Troy describes happened at San Juan Bautista in Ordot. So I don't know if Troy was visiting or not, but per a comment by Ron Eclavea on Troy's FB post, if Ron's account is true, then Troy missed the Mass where there was more context to the announcement. Here's what Ron says:

+++++

Ron Eclavea

I go to 6:30pm mass on Sundays at Ordot.

Can you provide a transcript of exactly what was said regarding blaming of the victims? If that is really the case it is definitely wrong.

A few months ago the parishioners were informed of the land parcel in question being up for sale as a “result” of the “court litigation”.

Everyone in the world is basically aware off this sad scandal in the church here on Guam.

The truth regarding the land is that the Ordot Parish put out a questionnaire asking the parish members what to do whether to simply let the process go as is ….or to attempt to re-acquire the property.

The overwhelming response was to re-acquire.

So this is what the parish will attempt to do based on the parishioners wishes.

We have to be very mindful and well informed regarding priests ….

Zechariah 13:7

“Strike the shepherd and the sheep scatter.”

Scattered sheep are lost sheep.

Satan’s time is short now and is brilliant today at discrediting the priests & the priesthood and he is using every method available to him to do this!

God established the priesthood in Leviticus and it is perpetual and everlasting!

No priests …no forgiveness of sins.

People abandoning the church and the priests is EXACTLY the aim of Satan in his quest to take souls

It is quite evident…he’s winning around the world. 🙏🏻⛪️🙏🏻

Divide …& conquer

+++++

So according to Ron's account, it was the parishioners who decided they wanted to purchase the property back. This is both allowed and reasonable. For properties for sale in the settlement trust fund, there is a provision in the listings which gives the "Archbishop of Agana" (the Church) the RIGHT TO REPURCHASE.

And, per Ron's account, it was the parishioners of this parish who decided they wanted to raise the money to repurchase the property, and not "the Church" acting selfishly or insensitively as Troy seems to perceive it. 

That piece of land isn't going to do the victims any good. The only good that land is going to do for the victims is if it gets sold. The bottom line is that the money for the purchase of the property, regardless of who purchases it, ends up in the trust fund for the victims. So why does Troy care who buys it?

As an aside, even though I was at the root of the stuff that led to the bankruptcy, after the bankruptcy proceedings were finalized, I advocated for parishioners to do exactly what these parishioners are doing: come together, organize, and buy back their properties, but this time keep the title under an entity separate from the "Archbishop of Agana." 

There's a few other things Troy says that I want to comment on:

TROY: "Just like hundreds of religious and lay people within the Archdiocese of Agana said and did nothing while hundreds of boys and girls were being raped by priests and Catholic school teachers for decades."

ME: Yes, that's true: "hundreds of religious and lay people...did nothing." Why did they do nothing? And I don't want to hear about fear or respect for the priest, blah, blah, blah. Here's what I think it was. I think it was the same bullcrap that goes on in families all the time, the same thing that shuts you up about what Uncle Bill is doing to your daughter because you don't want to shame the family or cause trouble in the "familia." I think it also has to do with some of these lay people (maybe a lot) getting favors from Fr. Whoever, maybe greasing the skids for an annulment or overlooking the fact that your cousin isn't a practicing Catholic and letting him be the godfather anyway. 

TROY: "The archdiocese is going to blame me and the other victims for what they did? They sound like government of Guam elected officials. At least elected officials aren’t child rapists dressed in desecrated garments. At least corrupt politicians aren’t covering for a system that perpetuates sexual assault against children."

ME: Actually, Troy, that's a bit laughable. This stuff happens in public schools all the time. In fact, when we were working to get the bill passed which gave Troy and others the right to sue the archdiocese, the main concern coming from certain senators was whether or not the law could be used to sue the government. I forget the details but there was something like "sovereign immunity" which protected government entities, or at least limited the extent of the suit. Once the senators were assured the public schools and GovGuam wouldn't suffer, they were all for it - since they knew it was really just aimed at the archdiocese.

And that brings me to something else before I forget. And it's something I said before. The initial victims, those who had the courage to take a public stand before there was any law to protect them - and did not hide behind their initials but used their real faces and names, did not want money damages, they wanted an apology, an apology from Apuron. 

But Apuron ran away after the first public allegation from Roy Quintanilla in May 2016. And that's when Harold's "Red Pope" sent Hon out here to kill the uprising. I say "Harold's Red Pope" because it was the Neocat master, Cardinal Filoni, who was calling the shots. I point out "Harold" because, as already referenced a couple of times, Troy is now his best buddy. 

Hon failed to put down the uprising because of a very few faithful people, mostly older, who refused to sit down and shut up. And, on orders from Filoni, Hon made a last gasp attempt to sink the bill lifting the statute of limitations after it received unanimous support from the legislature and made its way to the governor's desk, when Hon put out an all points bulletin to all the parishes to sign a petition demanding that then-Governor Calvo not sign it.

Remember now, Hon was acting on Filoni's orders, and this was all about saving Harold and the Neocats, and particularly the fake seminary. 

Thanks to the people who wouldn't shut up or sit down, which did not include Troy at the time, Filoni and Hon failed, Governor Calvo signed the bill into law, and victims like Troy had a path to $$$$, be it via private settlement, as it appears to be the case with Troy, or those who stuck it out for the full-fledged lawsuit and bankruptcy proceedings.

I'm actually disappointed that so many "settled" for out of court settlements. By doing so they kept their names and an account of what happened out of the public record. And those of us who fought so hard and lost so much would have really liked to see those records. 

Yes, yes. I understand about the need for privacy and to avoid further shame and all that. But people, other people, many people suffered and lost much to win justice, not just for you, but for this whole archdiocese. And the only way to insure that justice was really done was to run up all those names and details on a flagpole so that this sh*t never happens again! Private settlements took that away from us and leaves the door open for it to happen again and again and again.

Troy also takes a slap at Archbishop Jimenez and the church's anti-abortion stance saying that if life is so important why not use the money to support the fight for life instead of buying the property.

That's sort of a stretch, but it's not uncommon to hear something to the same effect, i.e. "if you care about the unborn so much then why don't you do this and why don't you do that, etc." I'm not going to go there on that. The bottom line is what I've already said. According to Ron Eclavea, the parishioners decided to do this, not the archbishop, not the pastor, and not the church. 

Lastly, I want to address some stuff in the comments where people, agreeing with Troy, say that this is why they still believe in God and love Jesus, but don't go to church anymore. 

I can only say what I've said many times before: Don't leave Jesus because of Judas. And while I can love Jesus and pray to him anytime, anywhere, there is only one place I can receive Him, Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. And that's at the Catholic Mass. And to be received Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity by YOU is why he was born to this world, suffered, died and rose again. 

Next time, just don't stay for the announcements.


Thursday, August 15, 2024

AND WE'RE CONCERNED ABOUT PAGANS IN PARIS?


LINK to online version

So the news is about the mocking of Christianity at the opening ceremony of the Paris Olympics. It may surprise some readers but I don’t care. In fact, I might say it was even “deserved.”

But before I go there, there is the question as to whether or not critics jumped to conclusions about what appeared to be a reenactment “in drag” of the Last Supper as immortalized in paint by Leonardo Da Vinci.

According to the ceremony creator, David Jolly, the scene in question was not meant to imitate the Last Supper but “to do a big pagan party linked to the gods of Olympus” and “promote tolerance of different sexual and gender identities.”

The alleged “Last Supper” was not the only seeming biblical parody. Jolly also staged what appeared to be the worship of a golden calf and a horse and rider right out of the last pages of the Book of Apocalypse.

To “flesh” out the bacchanal, Jolly, according to the AP, mixed in performances of  “a practically naked singer painted blue (who) made thinly veiled references to his body parts; a blonde-bearded drag queen (who) crawled on all fours to the thumping beat of ‘Freed From Desire,’ and “the tail end of an intimate embrace between two men who danced away, hugging and holding hands.”

And then there was Marie Antoinette’s guillotined head sitting in the window of the same building where the condemned Marie awaited her execution.

What any of this has to do with the Olympics, I don’t know, but all seems to be well in the “City of Love” because Jolly and his pals were reportedly doing nothing more than having a jolly good time, albeit in the spirit of the French Revolution. Anyway, Jolly said he was sorry if anyone was offended.

Now, to my point. Let’s assume that Jolly and his pals intended to mock Christianity, and, given the scene at issue, to mock specifically the Catholic belief in the Sacrament of the Eucharist. While I’m all for condemning sacrilege, how much worse is what a bunch of wild pagans did on the shores of the Seine than what most U.S. Catholics believe and do - at least according to polls.

I’m not preaching anything personal here, so don’t shoot the messenger. Following are some direct quotes from the Catechism of the Catholic Church (“CCC”) relative to tough moral teachings contrasted with what Catholics actually believe and do. I would say again “at least according to the polls,” but most serious Catholics know these facts to be true.

On abortion, the CCC teaches that “abortion willed either as an end or a means, is gravely contrary to the moral law…(and is) an abominable crime.” (CCC 2271). Meanwhile, a 2019 Pew Research poll reports that only one in ten Catholics believe abortion is wrong in all cases, and, President Biden, a Catholic who 49% of Catholics voted for and who is the most strident pro-abortion president ever, continues to receive communion with impunity. (By the way, the same is true of our local governor.)

On homosexual acts, the CCC teaches that such acts are "acts of grave depravity…and under no circumstances can they be approved.” (CCC 2357) However, according to Pew: “ in the United States, about six-in-ten Catholics (61%) said… that they favor allowing gays and lesbians to marry.” And recently, the current pope has muddied the waters further by authorizing blessings for “couples of the same sex.” (Fiducia supplicans III.)

On contraception, the CCC teaches: “every action which, whether in anticipation of the conjugal act, or in its accomplishment, or in the development of its natural consequences, proposes, whether as an end or as a means, to render procreation impossible is intrinsically evil.” (CCC 2370) But, according to Pew: “Just 15% of Catholics say that using contraception is morally wrong.”

And then there’s Guam, perhaps the most Catholic place in the world per capita, with also - per capita, the Catholic world’s worst record of the sex abuse of minors by Catholic authorities from the bishop to grade-school teachers.

Finally, it’s ironic that many Catholics are upset about what appeared to be a mocking of the scene wherein Christ institutes the Sacrament of the Eucharist, when, according to Pew, only one-third of U.S. Catholics believe in the sacramental presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist: that Jesus Christ is fully present, body, blood, soul and divinity in the consecrated species (bread and wine).

And we’re concerned about pagans in Paris?


Tim Rohr has resided in Guam since 1987. He has raised a family of 11 children, owned several businesses, and is active in local issues via his blog, JungleWatch.info, letters to local publications, and occasional public appearances. He may be contacted at timrohr.guam@gmail.com   

Friday, November 17, 2023

ALL WANT TO TELL ME STORIES THEY NEVER TOLD

By Tim Rohr


Theodore McCarrick (born 1930), ordered in 2018 by Pope Francis to a life of prayer and penance.[1] Found guilty of sexual crimes against adults and minors and abuse of power, he was dismissed from the clergy in February 2019.[2] He is the most senior church official in modern times to be laicized and is the first cardinal laicized for sexual misconduct.

Today, I happened to meet up with a friend on regular business. We spoke a bit about the business at hand. However, he soon asked me if I was in a hurry. As my following appointment had been rescheduled, I said "no." 

Given the very public role I played in exposing the worst clergy sex abuse, per capita, in the western world (Guam's), it is not uncommon for friends, or sometimes strangers, to say "have you got a few minutes?"

All want to tell me stories they never told. And it's pretty much the same story. 

"Father so and so..." And it gets really graphic - grotesquely graphic - from there. 

Since a law was enacted in 2016 in Guam giving victims of sex abuse, clergy or otherwise, to sue both their perpetrators and certain institutions, many, many victims have come forward to tell their stories to attorneys. 

Almost all of those victims, in their public filings, hid behind their initials. 

Given that I was intimately involved with the first victims who put their names and faces to their accusations (of Apuron) before there was a law to protect them, I did not like subsequent victims hiding behind mere initials.

But the conversation with my friend today helped me to better understand. 

The real reason these victims hid behind their initials was not out of any fear of repercussions from the accused, nor even public embarrassment, but fear from their own families, especially their parents.

The usual narrative is that parents were so respectful of The Church and the clergy that child victims knew they would not be believed. And indeed, that was the testimony of the few that we publicly heard from: that their perpetrators said "nobody will believe you."

But my friend, today, a local boy who grew to manhood in Guam in the 50's and 60's, and specifically a Catholic "boy" during the reigns of Bishops Baumgartner and Flores, under whose episcopates most of the legally-alleged clerical abuses occurred, helped me understand.

The real issue - if not the real culprit - was "a culture" which curried favor with elites (especially clergy) at the expense of their own children. 

In other words (at least per my friend), these parents KNEW there was "a problem" with their fave priests. 

But because having a priest (or a nun) in the family or being in anyway closely associated with a priest or a nun was such an elevation of status in local culture, it was a grave sin - not against God's law - but against "the law of family status" to admit or permit the mere mention of any clerical or religious peccadillo.

Sorry, if that's too esoteric. Here it is in shorter form.

Status, in Guam Spanish and post-Spanish culture, was radically elevated by either having one's own family members admitted to the states of clergy or religious (monks and nuns), or being closely associated with anyone who was (a clergy or religious), and wherein such status accrued to the family name. 

You don't have to think too hard to figure how this false sense of status played into the figurative - and sometimes real - slap down of children who dared tell their parents what Father or Sister so-and-so had done to them. 

To be continued...maybe.

Thursday, June 22, 2023

IT'S NOT THE CHURCH AND IT'S NOT THE "CHILDREN"

By Tim Rohr

The following was posted on the Facebook page of the Umatuna. I will follow the text with a few comments.



June 21, 2023--Prot. 2023-141
Message by the Apostolic Administrator
U.S. District Court issues Final Decree
consummating compensation plan,
closing archdiocese bankruptcy case

---

To all in our Catholic family,

With deep thanksgiving to our Almighty God, I share much welcome news from the United States District Court of Guam announcing the official closing of the Archdiocese of Agana’s Chapter 11 Reorganization (bankruptcy) case related to clergy sexual abuse.

We received the following from the Bankruptcy Division of the District Court of Guam late yesterday, June 20:

---

Notice of Electronic Filing

The following transaction was received from fad entered on 6/20/2023 at 11:44 AM CST and filed on 6/20/2023

Case Name: Archbishop of Agana, a Corporation Sole, Most Rev.

Case Number: 19-00010

Document Number: 1204

Docket Text:

Final Decree. Debtor's [1202] Motion for a Final Decree - GRANTED. The Plan has been substantially consummated; and This Chapter 11 case and Estate are hereby CLOSED. (fad)

---

"But as for you, be strong and do not relax, for your work shall be rewarded." – 2 Chronicles 15:7

The final decree by Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood means that the archdiocese’s compensation agreement with the victim survivors of clergy sexual abuse is officially approved and completed. That chapter may be closed. However, to be certain, there is much work yet to do in our journey of bringing healing, justice and reparation to those whom our Church gravely harmed.

Legally at least, our bankruptcy status is lifted. Spiritually, it affirms the steadfast truth that God never abandons us. So long as we dedicate ourselves to Him in our efforts to do good, Our Lord blesses us.

Thus, we must continue to focus wholeheartedly on the many tasks and responsibilities of post-bankruptcy work. This includes but is not limited to completing the transfer of properties and assets to the victim survivors through their court appointed trustee; providing tuition vouchers and cemetery plots to their families; activating the non-monetary compensation elements of the plan; strengthening our Child Protection and Safe Environment protocols and policies; reorganizing the archdiocese; and rebuilding our finances. We must work harder to protect all children from harm of any kind.

I convey my sincerest gratitude to the numerous individuals, groups and families of our schools, parishes and archdiocesan organizations for your tireless work, sacrifice and continued support. We have reached this important point of our journey of atonement and reparation because of your steadfast trust in our Lord.

Thank you to Archbishop Emeritus Michael J. Byrnes. We continue to pray for your healing. Thank you to my brother clergy and dear religious sisters. I extend much gratitude to former Finance Officer Josie Villanueva. Thank you to the many volunteers who help the Church in different ways, including the dedicated members of our Finance Council and Internal Review Board, past and present. 

Thank you to the many others even outside of our Church who have had major roles in helping us, from our hardworking attorneys here and abroad, the attorneys of the victim survivors, the banking and insurance institutions, Judge Tydingco-Gatewood, Chief Bankruptcy Judge Robert J. Faris and Curtis Ching of the Office of the U.S. Trustee, and companies which have supported us amid our trials and failures.

Thank you to all the victims, the courageous men and women who have endured in pain and continue to bear the wounds of betrayal and sexual abuse from members of our Church on Guam in the past. We are deeply sorry for the agony, betrayal, deceit and coverup by leaders and members of our archdiocese in the past.

As we work to pick ourselves up from the recent typhoon and the many other storms we have experienced in the past, we give ultimate thanks to our merciful Creator. Thank you dearest God for your unending love for us. In closing, I repeat a Bible passage which I have cited before:

“Rejoice always. Pray without ceasing. In all circumstances give thanks, for this is the will of God for you in Christ Jesus.” – 1 Thessalonians 5:16-18

Yours in Christ,

/s/Father Romeo D. Convocar

Apostolic Administrator, Archdiocese of Agaña

+++++++

My comments

Fr. Convocar errs in initially referring to the victims as "those whom our Church gravely harmed." However, he fixes the error at end of his message when he again refers to the victims, but this time as those "who have endured in pain and continue to bear the wounds of betrayal and sexual abuse from members of our Church on Guam in the past."

I'm glad he fixed it. "The Church" is the Bride of Christ. It is one, holy, catholic, and apostolic, and thus, is not only incapable of harming Her own children, but it is blasphemy and the "unforgivable sin," a "sin against the Holy Spirit," (Mk 3:28–29, Mt 12:31–32, Lk 12:10), to even infer it. 

Moreover, by laying the blame for these and so many more atrocities on "The Church," we not only defile the Bride of Christ and thus Christ Himself, we lessen or even remove the blame from the real perpetrators and the evil rot. 

No doubt, the sickness that fomented what Pope Benedict called "the filth in the Church," is systemic, and it is nothing new. In Liber Gomorrhianus (Book of Gomorrah) St. Peter Damian called out even filthier atrocities in the 11th century. 

The following is copied from the book's page on Amazon:

"Alas, it is shameful to speak of it! It is shameful to relate such a disgusting scandal to sacred ears! But if the doctor fears the virus of the plague, who will apply the cauterization? If he is nauseated by those whom he is to cure, who will lead sick souls back to the state of health?"
With these words, St. Peter Damian introduces the Book of Gomorrah, undoubtedly the most stirringly eloquent and impassioned denunciation of sexual perversion ever penned by a Catholic saint. Although it was written almost a thousand years ago, the Book of Gomorrah in many ways seems addressed to our own times, associating the phenomena of clerical homosexual behavior and pederasty, and endorsing the imprisonment of clergy who are a danger to youth. 
The Book of Gomorrah offers a scathing analysis of the evil of sodomy, while also expressing compassion for those who have fallen into such vice and the possibility of their redemption by the aid of divine grace. It explains the devastating effects of the vice both spiritually and psychologically, and warns that such behavior, particularly among the clergy, will bring down the wrath of God. It also urges the permanent defrocking of clerics who are habituated to homosexual behavior and endorses the permanent confinement those guilty of child sex abuse. 

Meanwhile, I still have an issue with Fr. Convocar's correction where he refers to "members of our Church on Guam in the past." It's not "in the past." Sin, immorality, filth, perverted atrocities are never "in the past," especially in the Church because Satan never sleeps and the ordained are his most delectable targets. Church history, if anything, demonstrates that.

Thus St. Peter warns:

"Be sober, be vigilant; because your adversary the devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour." - 1 Peter 5:8

It is understandable that Fr. Convocar and most others in our local Church want to put the atrocities of Apuron et. al behind us ("in the past"), but that is exactly what Satan wants us to do. 

In fact, what Fr. Convocar really needs to do is erect a Hall of Shame wherein are displayed the names, pictures, history, and all documents related to the proven perps as well as (with their permission) the names and pictures (where possible) of their victims. 
Note: Longtime readers of JW will remember that JW published pictures of Apuron's victims at or about the age when they were raped or molested or otherwise abused by the priest they served. Those pictures probably had more to do with turning the tide against Apuron and ultimately his conviction and sentencing by Pope Francis than anything else. We should be made to stare at such pictures again today x 300 plus. 
 

The other thing I find bothersome in Fr. Convocar's message,  * and this is not unique to him, is the constant coloring of "children" as the "victims." They may have been minors, but they weren't "children," at least not most. And this is a dirty ugly fact that not only few are brave enough to address, but by continually making this about "children" masks  (maybe intentionally) the real problem.

The fact is that our Church leadership has done nothing to address the real problem, and no amount of "Child Protection and Safe Environment protocols and policies" is going to do it. And it's not going to do it because it wasn't "children" who were the victims, and second, nothing has been done to screen out the worms who perpetrated these atrocities in the first place. 

There is also a third problem: the "deep church" that shielded Apuron and attempted to thwart the efforts of the people on the street at every turn. Said "deep church" is still in place. But we'll get to that another time. 

* I continue to refer to "Fr. Romy Convocar" directly because he is the papal-appointed Apostolic Administrator for the Archdiocese of Agana. In other words, on his desk, and at least for now, there is a sign - even if you don't see it - which reads: THE BUCK STOPS HERE. 

Saturday, May 13, 2023

THE FALL OF GUAM: IT'S WORSE AND GETTING "WORSER" - PART 1

By Tim Rohr




+++++

On this past Friday's Tall Tales with Bob Klitzkie, Bob riffed off a piece by Troy Torres which had to do with coming forward and exposing corruption. (LINK at 16:32) 

Bob's riff singled out what "we went through with Anthony Apuron" and how a lot of people knew for a very long time about the horrors happening deep inside our (Catholic) church and did nothing about it. 

Bob has referenced this fact several times and it's important to keep referencing it, because as Bob points out, nothing can stop these horrors from recurring other than constant vigilance. 

It's too easy to point our fingers at this abstract thing called "the archdiocese" or even "Apuron," or the name of any other cleric we may want to blame. 

Sure, we in the pews have a right to expect sanctity from our clergy and religious - or at least good behavior. But when parents look the other way or bury their heads in the sand as they did for decades as hundreds of their own children were routinely sexually molested, then something else is going on. 

It's simply NOT natural to look the other way while your own child is being abused - let alone sexually molested. And I don't care if it was a priest, a bishop, a nun, a teacher, or Uncle Bill.

Yes, yes, I've heard all of the arguments (excuses really) from culture: that local Catholics were taught never to question the priest or speak ill of him, etc. But seriously...at the expense of your children??? 

Later in the same show, after Bob's usual Friday expose of our now-governor arguing before the Guam Legislature to let babies who survive abortion die in a bio-waste bucket, Bob used the word "miracle" to describe how such an ardent, public, virulent, and even vicious advocate for baby killing could be elected governor - and twice, especially since the majority of those dead babies are CHamoru and the majority of voters are Catholic.

It's really the same thing. 

Parents looked the other way as their sick church superiors helped themselves to their children's bodies. And parents are looking the other way as their sick government superiors have been spending countless tax dollars and judicial resources in an effort to stack up ever more children's bodies - dead ones.  

So what's going on Guam? 

Well, the first thing to note is that we're not alone. 

Abusing children - or murdering them  - in or out of the womb - is not unique to Guam. But - and this is a big BUT - it is worse in Guam than anywhere else that flies the Stars and Stripes. 

JW has already - and many times - made reference to the numerical reality that the clergy sex abuse crisis is, exponentially, worse than anywhere in the entire Catholic World. 

I don't have time to link all this, but the clergy sex abuse crisis - in Guam - as of 2019, was, per capita, 14 times the size of the Boston crisis that provided the story for the Academy Award Winning Movie - SPOTLIGHT.  

14 TIMES! See: MORE

We really shouldn't be surprised. While we celebrate ourselves and plan for the next fiesta, there are these ugly facts:

• Guam has the most liberal abortion laws in the nation, which allow for the termination of nearly one out of 10 pregnancies with more than 60 percent being Chamorro (2012 Guam Medical Records).

• Guam has the highest divorce rate in the world (4.7 divorces per 1,000 population, 2010 Guam Statistical Yearbook, vs. Russia's 4.5 per 1,000, 2011 United Nations Demographic Yearbook).

• Guam has the 14th highest suicide rate in the world and a rate 1.2 times the national average (2011 World Health Organization and A Profile of Suicide on Guam, September 2011).

• Guam has a 20-percent age points higher out-of-wedlock birth rate (60 percent) compared to the rest of the nation (40.8 percent, CDC 2010). Note: Guam stopped reporting "illegitimate" births in 2005 -- 60 percent is based on the average between 2000 and 2005.

• Guam has double the teen birthrate compared to the rest of the nation (June 25 Pacific Daily News).

• Guam's rape rate is 94.4 per 100,000 (2011 Yearbook: 151 reported rapes). This is nearly triple the national average of 29.8. (U.S. Census Bureau, Statistical Abstract of the United States: 2013, Table 314).

• And, worst of all, Guam abuses and neglects its children at nearly double the national average (Guam child maltreatment rate of 76.81 per 1,000 children, based on 2012 CPS report and 2010 census vs. 41.2 per 1,000 children national average as per Table 3-2, Child Maltreatment 2011, Children's Bureau, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services).

Okay, so those look like decade old facts. Yah. They are. They are copied from my letter to the editor printed in the PDN on Jul. 14, 2013. 

It's a good thing I saved a PDF copy of the online version of the letter because not only has the PDN been wiped dry of this letter it doesn't even appear in Newspapers.com 

The stats may be a decade old, however, our every day news tell us that not only has nothing changed in "Catholic" Guam, but it's exponentially worse...and getting "worser." 

Tuesday, December 20, 2022

OSV: "...IT'S NOT ABOUT ABORTION"

Posted by Tim Rohr

Our Sunday Visitor has a fair article about the Pavonne matter. A key insight is here:

"When a priest becomes a celebrity, he needs a strong support system of people who help keep him humble...I have no insider knowledge on this in particular, but I ran into him frequently over the years, and it was clear some people adored him. And the combination of people adoring you and you and others being convinced you are a victim of persecution can be a dangerous thing."

The Frank Pavone story is not about abortion


Please: Be careful — prayerful — about how you react to the news about Father Frank Pavone now becoming Mr. Frank Pavone by order of the Vatican. Try not to see it through a political lens. Step away of any opinions you may have of the Roman pontiff. Know that abortion is the human-rights issue of our time. The priest who ran Priests for Life is still capable of creating an untenable circumstance for himself to continue as a priest.

CONTINUED

My Note: Unfortunately we (Catholics) are in very strange and uncertain times...IN THE CHURCH! The current occupant of the Chair of Peter, himself, has stated, on many occasions, what some would say are "blasphemous things" - the same accusation made against Pavonne. 

Nevertheless, we, the laity, would do well not to second guess stuff that is above our heads. Pavonne provoked the war that eventually came. Let's let him fight it the way he chooses. 

To be clear though, we, the laity of the Archdiocese of Agana, were not in "over our heads" and completely within our moral right to protest and demand Vatican action against more than half a century of the rape and abuse of our children by certain members of our clergy - all of which the current leadership of this Archdiocese has admitted. 

Thursday, March 17, 2022

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: WHO ON THE HILL?


Someone 'on the hill' blocking justice for church sex abuse victims

By Tim Rohr

It appears the judge has “had it” in what continues to appear to be a cat and mouse game – if not a real-life Tom and Jerry cartoon – in the case of the Archdiocese of Agana v. its creditors, including lenders and decades of clergy sex abuse victims. CONTINUED

Monday, February 28, 2022

LETTER TO THE EDITOR: ARCHDIOCESE ATTORNEYS LET CLIENTS DOWN

ARCHDIOCESE ATTORNEYS LET CLIENTS DOWN

by Tim Rohr


Like shooting ducks in a barrel. That’s what it looked like, at least from what I saw of the recent trial to determine whether churches and schools could be included in archdiocesan assets to satisfy its creditors.

It was as if the church attorneys painted a target on its own witnesses and then instructed the other side to “aim here.” In fact, the attorneys for the creditors didn’t even need to aim. Just shoot.

CONTINUED


PDF COPY

Monday, February 8, 2021

APURON UPDATE, FEB. 8. 2021

Vatican removed as defendant in Guam clergy sex abuse case

The nephew of former Guam Archbishop Anthony Apuron removed the Holy See, or the Vatican, from the list of defendants in his clergy sex abuse case.

Mark Apuron, through attorney Delia Lujan Wolff, filed a "notice of voluntary dismissal without prejudice" of all claims against "Defendant Holy See, State of the Vatican City, its instrumentalities and/or agents." CONTINUED

Wednesday, June 3, 2020

THIS IS WHERE I WAS RAPED

“You know, just standing here, right behind you, that is where I was raped,” says Denton, 56.



'Look what he's taken from me': the deadly toll of Catholic church sex abuse on Guam

There are now nearly 300 sexual abuse lawsuits against more than 20 priests on the deeply religious island in the western Pacific

by Anita Hofschneider in Agat, photographs by Ken D'Souza


Comments can be made on this post, but they may or may not be moderated. If you wish your comment to be seen, please make your comment at www.FaceBook.com/JungleWatch where you see this post. 

Saturday, November 30, 2019

TANQUAM NON FUERIT - Part 3: "I THOUGHT THEY LIKED IT."


Per Parts 1 and 2 of this series, blaming "The World," and in this case, "The Sexual Revolution," for the latest installment of clergy perversions (it's definitely not the first time - see Book of Gomorrah), is not just wrong, it lays bare the real problem.

And here it is: 
The refusal of our Church leadership to own the fact that "As the Church goes, so goes the World," ... and NOT the other way around. 
And this fact ("As the Church goes...") is never clearer than in the facts which led up to the so-called "Sexual Revolution" - which our Church leadership apparently now wants to blame!!

Long before Woodstock (1969), and "The World's" orgasmic lust for "The Pill" - which essentially precipitated the sexual nirvana of sex without babies (i.e. consequences) - our Church (specifically Pope John 23) opened the Box (Pandora's) which led to both Woodstock and the Western World's rabid rush to contracept and abort itself out of existence.

In 1963, the now sainted Pope established The Pontifical Commission on Birth Control to examine the question as to whether or not Catholics could morally use The Pill to avoid pregnancy. 

It was an absurd proposition to begin with. 

The Church could never change GOD's design for the union of the procreative act with its procreative ends.

But it was the 1960's, and it appears Papa John wanted to show that...well, at least he "cared."



It's easy to see that John never intended the Commission to go anywhere. He only commissioned six non-theologians as members and separated the Commission from the Council (Vatican II), keeping personal control over it.

However, within weeks of opening both the Council and the Commission, something happened that John didn't plan on.

HE DIED. 



His successor, Paul VI, had the opportunity to close what should have never been opened. But it appears Paul (now also sainted) was even more eager to show the 1960's that he too "cared."



Instead of shutting down the investigation into a question that could only have one answer:

NO!

Paul expanded the Commission membership from the original 6 members to 72!, and included several secular members who cared little about THE CHURCH.

As you might imagine, the then-progressives in The Church went wild with glee. Paul's continuance  and sudden exponential expansion of the Commission could only mean one thing:

Catholics would soon copulate without the "threat" of babies,  just like everybody else! 

In fact, Paul all but sealed the deal, when, upon expanding the Commission in 1964, he said THIS:

"We say frankly that so far we do not have sufficient reason to consider the norms given by Pope Pius XII on this matter [of contraception] as out of date and therefore as not binding. They must be considered as valid, at least until We feel obliged in conscience to change them." - Paul VI Acta apostolicae sedis (AAS) 56 (1964) 588-59, 1964 address to the special papal commission on the use of contraceptives.
Anyone familiar with "pope-speak" will recognize that Paul isn't just giving his personal opinion (as Francis is so prone to do on airplanes), Paul is using the Papal "We," meaning, he is speaking magisterially, doctrinally, even dogmatically, and in the name of The Church. 

Amazingly, Paul cast his comments as a response to a previous Pope (Pius 12), and then lets us know that said "opinion" is subject to change if "We" (the papal We) feel obliged in conscience to change them." 

Read that again:

"until We feel obliged in conscience to change them." 

That one phrase opened the door for Catholics to, "in conscience," contracept, abort, divorce, engage in fornication and homosexual sex, vote for pro-abortion polices and politicians (i.e. the Kennedy's) and ultimately, for the Church's own priests and bishops, to rape and molest trusting young boys (and some girls) at will, in the name of "conscience" and "born that way." 

The now-dead, "Mass-Molester" (literally) of the Archdiocese of Agana, Fr. Louis Brouillard, even testified in a deposition:



"At that time, I did believe that the boys enjoyed the sexual contact and I also had gratification as well," 
Brouillard said in his affidavit. 

I.E. "IF IT FEELS GOOD, DO IT." 

Paul 6 even further cemented the idea that Catholics could make up their own mind about contraception in the very document he wrote to refute it: Humane Vitae:

6. However, the conclusions arrived at by the commission could not be considered by Us as definitive and absolutely certain, dispensing Us from the duty of examining personally this serious question. This was all the more necessary because, within the commission itself, there was not complete agreement concerning the moral norms to be proposed, and especially because certain approaches and criteria for a solution to this question had emerged which were at variance with the moral doctrine on marriage constantly taught by the magisterium of the Church.
Read that highlighted part again. 

Paul tells the Universal Church that the only reason what has always been "intrinsically evil" must remain "intrinsically evil" is due to the lack of a "complete agreement" (i.e. a unanimous vote) by something called a "commission."  


Well it was almost unanimous. Only 7 member of the 72 dissented. The majority voted in favor of lifting the Church's "ban" on birth control.

Paul tried to put the horses back in the barn on July 29, 1968, the date he promulgated Humanae Vitae. 

Woodstock would begin on August 15, 1969. 

No. It ain't the "sexual revolution...:




And NOTHING will change until we, the LAITY...call our leadership to account. And Guam has a good beginning.


Monday, October 28, 2019

CLERICALISM? .

From a culture of silence to cover-ups: How Guam ended up with 280 clergy sex abuse claims


A 9-year-old boy confided in his grandmother on several occasions that the parish priest was sexually abusing him.

The grandmother spanked the boy, identified in court documents only by C.B.D. to protect his privacy. She lectured him that the priest was "God's representative and not capable of such actions."

CONTINUED

Tuesday, October 1, 2019

PDN: "Capuchins...more Guam sex abuse claims"

Many Catholics on Guam want to grant an exception to the Capuchins. "We have an 'Capuchin' parish," they say. But they forget. Apuron was a Capuchin. And he learned his filthy trade early. And he was NOT ALONE. 


Capuchins, Boy Scouts offer confidential amounts to settle more Guam sex abuse claims


Capuchin Franciscans and the Boy Scouts of America offered confidential amounts to settle additional Guam clergy sex abuse claims, which are still subject to court approval. CONTINUED