Showing posts with label ACLU Lawsuit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ACLU Lawsuit. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 2, 2023

LOU LOSES

By Tim Rohr


"We reject Plaintiffs’ argument that an in-person informed-consent requirement for women seeking an abortion is not rationally connected to any legitimate governmental interest." - Case: 21-16559, 08/01/2023, ID: 12765649, DktEntry: 55-1, Page 12 of 20
12 RAIDOO V. MOYLAN

+++++

Recently, we laid out, here in JW, the entire scenario, backed with documents, wherein Governor "Lou," conspired with her abortion lieutenant, "The Jayne" to recruit two abortionists based in Hawaii to get licensed in Guam for no other reason than to sue us - you and me. 

Along the way, Lou and Jayne and their Hawaii stooges, recruited the big, bad ACLU. 

At first, Lou and Jayne won. The Guam District Court enjoined the enforcement of a Guam law requiring women seeking an abortion to receive in-person consultation. This opened the door for the Hawaii abortionists to provide the required consultation via tele-anything, and then send the mothers their baby killing pills (probably with a note saying "best wishes").

At the time, things weren't looking good for the pro-life side. 

The Defendants, the guys on our side, were headed up by then-AG Leevin Camacho - in his official capacity as AG, and Leevin wasn't known for his being a stickler for defending the laws of Guam when they conflicted with Lou's wishes. 

In fact:

"In 2021, the Guam Attorney General specifically stipulated in another lawsuit that Guam law permits the use of telemedicine to provide medication abortions." (See: 9th Circuit Opinion linked below)

Still, one way or another, a somewhat half-hearted appeal was filed with the 9th Circuit and the appeal was heard this past February, 2023. 

Our man on the floor was a certain Jordan L. Pauluhn, then an attorney with the AG (he's not now). 

I watched the proceedings via video and in my view, Mr. Pauluhn did a somewhat impressive job. I even called him a "rockstar." However, he was only doing his job - which was defending the laws of Guam, whereas the ACLU lawyers were highly if not viciously ideologically motivated. 

Note: They may have also been financially motivated. Given what we know now about the connection between Lou and the ACLU, a nice FOIA may turn up some interesting checks. 

Today, the 9th Circuit promulgated its Opinion, which I copy here in relevant part (emphases added):

In Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the Supreme Court made clear that the Constitution does not guarantee a right to an abortion because it is neither enumerated in the constitutional text nor deeply rooted in our nation’s history. 142 S. Ct. 2228 (2022). So now the people’s representatives—not judges—decide whether to allow, ban, or regulate abortions. And in turn, courts play only a modest and minor role: We merely apply a highly deferential rational basis review in assessing the constitutionality of an abortion-related law.

Under this new legal landscape, we vacate the district court’s preliminary injunction against Guam’s in-person informed-consent law. That law requires women seeking abortions to have an in-person meeting with a physician—or a qualified agent of the doctor—who must disclose certain medical as well as other information (e.g., medical risks, adoption opportunities) to a patient before she has an abortion. Guam has legitimate interests in requiring an in-person consultation: the consultation can underscore the medical and moral gravity of an abortion and encourage a robust exchange of information. As we learned during the pandemic, a telephonic or video meeting may be a poor substitute for an in-person meeting, whether it be in the classroom, courtroom, or clinic.

Plaintiffs point out that women in Guam seeking abortions must obtain chemical abortifacients via telemedicine, given the current lack of doctors who perform abortions on the island. Plaintiffs argue that the law may thus thwart informed consent because the treating doctor off the island may have to pick a non-medical agent to provide the in-person medical disclosures. But nothing in the law prevents the treating doctor from providing the same or additional information as that required in the in-person meeting when the doctor meets with patient via videoconference or phone. The law sets a minimum, not a maximum, disclosure requirement, and does not prohibit the doctor from communicating additional information that the doctor believes is required under another law or professional obligation. In short, Guam’s law passes muster under the low bar of rational basis review.

Plaintiffs’ equal protection challenge fails as well. Guam can require an in-person consultation for abortions— but not for other medical procedures—because abortion is different, as it involves what Dobbs described as the “States’ interest in protecting fetal life.” Id. at 2261. People across the United States and its territories may in good-faith strongly disagree on abortion, but the people of Guam can make the policy choice to treat abortion differently from other medical procedures.

In other words, Lou loses. 

But beyond Lou losing, the 9th Circuit Opinion is a real example of how courts should work. In spite of which side makes the most spirited argument, the court looked past the personalities and ideologies of the "arguers" and simply opined based on its interpretation of the law relative to the current legal landscape. 

Note: There is NO REASON our own District Court judge could not have done the same thing. 

Read the full opinion here. 

And while "Lou loses," we are the real loser. How much of OUR time and OUR money did Lou spend on trying to kill more Guam babies? But then that's who you voted for. Isn't it. 

Wednesday, July 12, 2023

GOV. LEON GUERRERO'S MONKEY TRIAL

By Tim Rohr



Today (July 10 - when I started working on this post) in 1925, the "Trial of the Century," the "Scopes Monkey Trial" began in Dayton, Tennessee. 

As copied here from a post on History.com, the "trial of the century" was a set up:

In Dayton, Tennessee, the so-called Scopes Monkey Trial begins with John Thomas Scopes, a young high school science teacher, accused of teaching evolution in violation of a Tennessee state law. The law, which had been passed in March, made it a misdemeanor punishable by fine to “teach any theory that denies the story of the Divine Creation of man as taught in the Bible, and to teach instead that man has descended from a lower order of animals.” With local businessman George Rappleyea, Scopes had conspired to get charged with this violation, and after his arrest the pair enlisted the aid of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) to organize a defense.

Does that sound familiar? If not, it should. Almost one hundred years later, a very similar conspiracy, perpetrated by Guam's own governor, is presently playing out here and now.

2019

In 2019, Governor Leon Guerrero ("Lou"), through her abortion lieutenant, Jayne Flores, began recruiting two abortion doctors from Hawaii to get licensed in Guam. 

The purported reason for recruiting these doctors was to provide abortions in Guam since none of Guam's 300 plus doctors would do them after Guam's last abortion doctor, William Freeman, retired in 2018.

However, as the following will demonstrate, it appears the real reason for Lou's recruiting these doctors was to set up a law suit, with "the aid of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), to sue "us." By "us" I mean "us," the people who live, work, vote, and pay taxes here. 

The suit lists the names of several Defendants. But they are merely names of people in their official capacities. Functionally, the suit is against us in that: 1) the suit seeks to enjoin a law that we, through our elected lawmakers, "said" we wanted (informed consent for abortion); and 2) forces us, the taxpayers, to pay for the suit to sue ourselves. 

One wonders where in the rest of the civilized democratic world do we find a governor who clandestinely conspires to undermine laws said governor is sworn to uphold, and then punishes her own people by forcing them to pay for a lawsuit she herself conspired to bring about. But hey, you voted for her, Guam.

There is much to suggest that Lou is the "Scopes George Rappleyea" in that she appears to have fronted a couple of stooges (Drs. Raidoo and Kaneshiro) in order to enlist "the aid of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) to organize a defense" - exactly as Rappleyea did in Scopes. 

The Evidence

Let's start with the correspondence between Jayne Flores, Lou's abortion lieutenant (since it appears Jayne - as Director of Bureau of Women's Affairs - does nothing else but track down baby killers to do business in Guam), and these Hawaii people.

The following is copied from papers retrieved via a FOIA by the Vigilance Committee (the originals of which can be accessed here). I will add my comments in RED:


June 24, 2019, 10:17 AM
Jayne Flores to Bliss Kaneshiro
Subject: Situation on Guam

Hafa Adai Dr. Kaneshiro,

I am the director of the Bureau of Women’s Affairs and am coordinating the effort to bring a doctor (or doctors on a rotational basis) to Guam willing to help our women (and unfortunately some girls) who have a choice to make. Can you please give me a call at your earliest convenience?

Jayne refers to abortion as "a choice to make." As you will see from Kaneshiro's reply, the doctors Jayne is attempting to recruit have no qualms about using the real word: ABORTION. Pay attention to the word "girls." We'll get to that in a minute.


*****

June 25, 2019, 1:10 PM
Bliss Kaneshiro to Jayne Flores
Subject: Connecting you to Planned Parenthood

Jayne,

I’m connecting you to Deb Nucatola, the medical director of the PP clinics in Hawaii. She is cc’ed on this email and is aware of the lack of an abortion provider in Guam.

Kaneshiro doesn't hesitate to read through Jayne's code ("a choice to make"). Kaneshiro blatantly and unapologetically replies with the word "abortion." Why is Jayne so cowardly to call it what it is? 


*****

June 25, 2019, 1:19 PM
Deborah Nucatola to Jayne Flores
Subject: Connecting you to Planned Parenthood

Hi Jayne!

Nice to meet you virtually! 
I do believe you have been in contact with staff at our Patient Access Center. Our Area Service Director, Deighton Kavarne, was planning to reach out to you by phone. I’m not sure if you have already spoke but to close the loop I’m cc’ing him on this email. And, FYI, we have been discussing the need in Guam for several months now and are eager to speak with you to see how we might be able to meet the need.

*****

June 25, 2019, 2:40 PM
Jayne Flores to Deborah Nucatola cc: Bliss Kaneshiro, Deighton Kavarne, Anita Arriola, Dr. Ellen Bez
Subject: Connecting you to Planned Parenthood

Hafa Adai Deborah (and Deighton)!

Thank you for reaching out to us here on Guam. Yes, we are in need of abortion services for our women (and unfortunately some pre-teens). We are also in great need of the other services Planned Parenthood provides (free birth control, STD/HIV testing, HPV vaccines, cancer screening, family planning, etc.) We are currently trying to quietly survey clinics on Guam that would allow visiting physicians to perform surgical abortions. Another option, if PP wanted to open a clinic here, is that we do have a medical clinic that recently closed. Would there be a possibility that PP would be interested in leasing this space to set up its own clinic?

I would describe the atmosphere on our island, with its 165,000 population that is majority Catholic, as initially hostile toward this issue. However, over half of the voting public cast ballots in favor of our first female governor, Maga’haga Lourdes Leon Guerrero, in November 2018 despite her openly pro-choice stance. So there is hope. 

Here, we have a lot, beginning with a cc to Atty. Anita Arriola and Dr. Ellen Bez, two well-known abortion advocates in Guam; and, in the case of Arriola, not just well-known, but famous, given Arriola's role in opposing her own mother's "Belle's Law," in 1990. 

In the last paragraph, Jayne clearly lays out what we in JW have said many times: Guam is Catholic in name only and is pro-abortion in all measurable metrics.  So according to Jayne: "there is hope." Of course Jayne's "hope" is that we can continue to kill even more CHamoru children. 


Meanwhile, the real red flag in this email from Jayne is the reference to "pre-teens," previously referenced by Jayne as "unfortunately some girls." Hmmmm. "Pre-teens." So 12 and under. WHERE IS THE POLICE REPORTING for girls 12 and under being impregnated? Impregnated by whom? Let me say that again - since Jayne won't: Girls age 12 and under impregnated by whom? Why aren't you asking, Jayne? Instead of asking who the hell is impregnating girls age 12 and under, Jayne and Lou are out there begging for someone to come to Guam and kill their babies - and the evidence. So much for the Bureau of Women's Affairs. Damn.


*****

June 25, 2019, 2:50 PM
Jayne Flores to Bliss Kaneshiro
Subject: Situation on Guam

Thank you Dr. Bliss. I really appreciate your reaching out to me. I just sent an email to Deborah and Deighton. Thank you for connecting us. I look forward to speaking with you at our meeting later this week.

If for no other reason, Lou should fire Jayne for begin stupid enough to subject critical correspondence to a possible FOIA, a FOIA neither Jayne, nor her arrogant employer probably anticipated. But perhaps they didn't care. After all, like Jayne says: "over half of the voting public cast ballots in favor of our first female governor, Maga’haga Lourdes Leon Guerrero, in November 2018 despite her openly pro-choice stance. So there is hope." 

*****

Feb. 6, 2020, 1:40 PM
Jayne Flores to Drs. Shandhini Raidoo, Bliss Kaneshiro and Dr. John Rivera
Subject: Possible UOG collaboration with UH research project

Hafa Adai Drs. Shandhini and Bliss from UH and Dr. John from UOG

Dr. Shandhini and Dr. Bliss, allow me to introduce, through email, Dr. John Rivera, Program Chair of the Public Administration program at the University of Guam. His Mast of Public Administration students often assist with research issues. I think his UOG program would be a great partner for your research project on abortion attitudes on Guam. I spoke briefly with Dr. Rivera about your intent to find a local partner for the project, his email address is cc’d above. Good luck with the project. 

*****

Feb. 17, 2020, 10:15 AM
Dr. Shandhini Raidoo to John Rivera, Jayne Flores, Bliss Kaneshiro, and Jesse John Quenga.
Subject: Possible UOG collaboration with UH research project

Hi Dr. Rivera,

Thank you for your email. We have just submitted our proposal for this project. We are very excited about it and will definitely be in touch with you once we know more about the next steps. Thank you Jayne for the introduction.

 I know John, and have known him for many years before I saw this email. So I contacted John to see what was up. Not much is what I gathered. He was contacted in his capacity as noted above and as far as I know, no such survey was ever done, probably because Lou and Jayne weren't really interested in a survey, they were only interested - as we shall see - in getting the ACLU to sue us.

*****

The FOIA'd paper trail between Jayne Flores and the Hawaii abortion docs ends here, but apparently there were other private communications between the LLG regime and the baby-whackers from Hawaii, because suddenly, both Raidoo and Kaneshiro are licensed to practice "MEDICINE and SURGERY" in Guam:

Jul. 16, 2020 - (LINK to copy of letter)
Nathaniel Berg, MD, Chairperson, Guam Board of Medical Examiners to Shandhini Raidoo, MD

Dear Dr. Raidoo:

Congratulations! The Guam Board of Medical Examiners approved your application for medical licensure during their board meeting held on July 15, 2020, and herby issues you medical license No. M-2222 effective July 15, 2020 to practice MEDICINE and SURGERY in Guam. The expiration date of this license is December 31, 2021….Welcome to the practice of medicine on Guam!


 


Nov. 20, 2020 (LINK to copy of letter)
Nathaniel Berg, MD, Chairperson, Guam Board of Medical Examiners to Bliss Kaneshiro.

Dear Dr. Kaneshiro,

Congratulations! The Guam Board of Medical Examiners approved your application for medical licensure during their regular board meeting held on November 18, 2020, and hereby issues you medical license No. M-2234 effective November 18, 2020 to practice MEDICINE and SURGERY in Guam. The expiration date of this license is December 31, 2021…Welcome to the practice of medicine on Guam!


 It's curious as to why there was nearly a four month space between the licensure of Raidoo in July 2020 and Kaneshiro in November 2020. But it's not hard to figure out given what came next.

On Jan. 28, 2021, barely two months after Kaneshiro retained licensure to practice "MEDICINE and SURGERY" (i.e. surgical abortions) in Guam, Kaneshiro and her buddy, Raidoo, sued you and me.

The ACLU, a la the "Scopes Monkey Trial" joined Raidoo and Kaneshiro's lawsuit on the same day. 

Of course, it's laughable - for the intelligent - that doctors who 1) have never been to Guam, 2) have never practiced in Guam, and 3) never intended to practice in Guam, would file suit in Guam and against Guam for not letting them practice in Guam. 

Talk about MONKEY BUSINESS.

 

Wednesday, April 12, 2023

AND THE CLERGY THAT CONTINUE TO COWER

By Tim Rohr



There has been much in the news about a federal judge's recent ruling blocking the sale of the baby-killing drug "mifepristone." 

The name of the drug should sound familiar to Guam residents.  The drug is how those two Hawaii doctors (Raidoo and Kaneshiro), at the invitation of Governor Lou Leon Guerrero, have been killing Guam babies and intend to kill many more. 

President Biden, a communion-going "Catholic" (thanks to his liberal bishop friends) has moved to block the judge's ruling.

One thing you will not see or hear in the news is WHY the judge chose to engage the suit brought against the FDA by ALLIANCE FOR HIPPOCRATIC MEDICINE, et al. two decades after the drug's approval by the FDA.

At the outset of the ruling, the judge states:

Over twenty years ago, the United States Food and Drug Administration (“FDA”) approved chemical abortion (“2000 Approval”). The legality of the 2000 Approval is now before this Court. Why did it take two decades for judicial review in federal court? After all, Plaintiffs' petitions challenging the 2000 Approval date back to the year 2002, right?

Simply put, FDA stonewalled judicial review - until now. Before Plaintiffs filed this case, FDA ignored their petitions for over sixteen years, even though the law requires an agency response within “180 days of receipt of the petition.” 21 C.F.R. § 10.30(e)(2)). But FDA waited 4,971 days to adjudicate Plaintiffs' first petition and 994 days to adjudicate the second. See ECF Nos. 1-14, 1-28, 1-36, 1-44 (“2002 Petition,” “2019 Petition,” respectively). Had FDA responded to Plaintiffs' petitions within the 360 total days allotted, this case would have been in federal court decades earlier. Instead, FDA postponed and procrastinated for nearly 6,000 days.

All. for Hippocratic Med. v. U.S. Food & Drug Admin., 2:22-CV-223-Z, at *1 (N.D. Tex. Apr. 7, 2023)

See the full MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER here. 

NOTE: Guam, like it was in 1990, is interestingly once again at the forefront of the abortion war nationally. Two years before the new ruling against mifepristone, Guam was already embroiled in a federal case involving the use of the drug to kill Guam babies remotely: a prescription for the baby-killing drug after a zoom consultation with one of two Hawaii doctors who were only licensed to practice in Guam after being invited to do so by LLG's abortion lieutenant, Jayne Flores - of course at LLG's orders.

While pro-lifers may shake their heads at how LLG and JF, both communion-going Catholics like Biden, can, in apparent "good conscience" advocate for the wholesale chemical slaughter of Guam's unborn, the real head-shaking needs to be directed at the "Catholic" communion-going voters who elected LLG and the clergy that continue to cower. 

*****

A description of mifepristone by the judge:

Mifepristone - also known as RU-486 or Mifeprex - is a synthetic steroid that blocks the hormone progesterone, halts nutrition, and ultimately starves the unborn human until death. ECF No. 7 at 7-8. Because mifepristone alone will not always complete the abortion, FDA mandates a two-step drug regimen: mifepristone to kill the unborn human, followed by misoprostol to induce cramping and contractions to expel the unborn human from the mother's womb. Id. at 8.

All. for Hippocratic Med. v. U.S. Food & Drug Admin., 2:22-CV-223-Z, at *2 (N.D. Tex. Apr. 7, 2023)

The judge also attacks the head-fake use of the word "fetus:"

Jurists often use the word “fetus” to inaccurately identify unborn humans in unscientific ways. The word “fetus” refers to a specific gestational stage of development, as opposed to the zygote, blastocyst, or embryo stages. See ROBERT P. GEORGE & CHRISTOPHER TOLLEFSEN, EMBRYO 27-56 (2008) (explaining the gestational stages of an unborn human). Because other jurists use the terms “unborn human” or “unborn child” interchangeably, and because both terms are inclusive of the multiple gestational stages relevant to the FDA Approval, 2016 Changes, and 2021 Changes, this Court uses “unborn human” or “unborn child” terminology throughout this Order, as appropriate.

All. for Hippocratic Med. v. U.S. Food & Drug Admin., 2:22-CV-223-Z, at *2 n.1 (N.D. Tex. Apr. 7, 2023)

Friday, February 24, 2023

I THINK... MAYBE NOT

By Tim Rohr

In the previous post, I praised Atty. Pauluhn for "doing his job," i.e. defending a Guam law relative to an abortion matter before the Ninth Circuit. 

I don't know enough about standards of review and that sort of thing to know if Mr. Pauluhn argued effectively to the satisfaction of the Court. It was just nice to see someone professionally argue the law and not the issue.

In this regard, Mr. Pauluhn's argument stood out in clear contrast to his adversary, the ACLU lawyer, who appeared wholly ideologically motivated. But then that's what the ACLU is. 

There is one thing though that bothers me and I'm not sure why lawyers say this, and both lawyers said this when arguing before the judges and that's: "I think..." 

Several times both attorneys, in responding to a question from the Court, began with "I think..." 

When listening to the rest of the answer that began with "I think..." it is clear that the answer could have stood on its own without the preface of "I think..."

"I think..." moves what follows from what may well be a fact down to the level of a personal opinion. 

My gut reaction to a lawyer saying "I think" is "I don't care what you think." I want to know what the law says, or at least the position you are arguing."

In other words, "opining" is something the Court does, not the advocates. 

Thus, "I think..." that even if one is unsure of the answer, "I think..." it's better to just give the answer without prefacing it with "I think..." 

It just sounds better. 

I also hear this "I think..." from the pulpit quite a bit, when there's usually no reason for it. It would be much better to say "the Catholic Church teaches in Paragraph 2734 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church that ... " (or whatever document or source can be referenced. In fact, some of the most compelling preachers consistently reference what the saints have said.)

If asked what I think about something, my favorite way to answer is to answer without saying "I think," and then end with "what do you think?"

By the way, here's a little help if you must say "I think."

Thursday, February 23, 2023

MR. PAULUHN DOES HIS JOB

By Tim Rohr

I don't know who this rockstar is. 

I had read his filings and took him for a pretty da*m good attorney, but I had never seen him - until this video (below). 

In fact, by his haircut - or lack of one (LOL) - I almost took him - as the video began - for some dude hired to arrange stuff for the actual hearing.

I was wrong. Really wrong. 

Mr. (Jordan) Pauluhn - in his argument before the Ninth Circuit -  did a damn good job. But let me qualify that. 

Mr. Pauluhn did exactly what we are paying him to do. 

Regardless of any personal beliefs or proclivities relative to the issue at hand (ABORTION), Mr. Pauluhn, representing the Office of the Attorney General of Guam, DID HIS JOB before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals by doing EXACTLY what he is being paid to do: Defend the Laws of Guam.

What a pleasant surprise - given what we have come to expect from partisan politicians AND (some) attorneys - some of whom have occupied the Office of the Attorney General of Guam. 

It does not matter that this particular action involves the particularities of the "in-person" mandate as set forth in Guam Law requiring informed consent for abortion. 

The Office of the Attorney General's job description is to defend the Laws of Guam - and Mr. Pauluhn did exactly what he was paid to do. 

I made many notes and will have some - if not several comments - in future posts. But for now, here is the argument before the Ninth Circuit. 

Regardless of the outcome, Mr. Pauluhn deserves his pay and here's a note to his current boss to keep paying him. 



Date Argued: February 16th, 2023
Docket Number: 21-16559
Judges: Carlos T. Bea, Daniel Paul Collins, Kenneth Kiyul Lee

Also available at Court Listener here

ACLU LAWYER: "PEOPLE WERE AFRAID"

By Tim Rohr


Governor Lou Leon Guerrero and her pro-abort comrades (Atty. Vanessa Williams, Jayne Flores, et. al) continue, via their ACLU attorneys, to play the fear card.

From the Guam Daily Post:

Physicians on Guam are unwilling to provide abortion care and are afraid of retaliation for doing so, or for even being known to be formally affiliated with abortion providers, she added.

“It was a mistake for Mr. Pauluhn to suggest that physicians could just fly out to Guam to provide this care. They did want to try to do that, and they could not find any place that was willing to let them set up and actually provide the care because people were afraid,” Kolbi-Molinas said.

Let's clarify about what the in-person mandate requires. It requires only that a person seeking an abortion be given certain information. It does not require the person giving the information to perform the abortion. 

So what is there to be afraid of?

Nothing.

However, it's the only card LLG and the ACLU has.

So since "fear" is the only argument they have, then the OAG should argue that said "fear" be demonstrated, or at least that it cannot be demonstrated. Maybe Mr. Pauluhn did. I don't know. The story doesn't say. 

The fact is, of course, is that it is a lie. The local population embraces abortion as evidenced by a decade of abortion reports, and as also evidenced by the election and re-election of the most radical and public pro-abort in Guam's history, the governor herself. 

Several local doctors, including Annie Bordallo and Ellen Bez have already been very public about their support for abortion. So where's the fear? 

Are they afraid of the few people who stand on the sidewalk for an hour a week?

Of course they aren't. 

Tuesday, January 17, 2023

WHO IS RUNNING THIS PLACE ANYWAY?

By Tim Rohr


As a postscript to the previous post PARKINSON WIMPS OUT, this writer asks: WHY IS PARKINSON CONSULTING WITH THE ACLU? 

Per the PDN news story:

“Today, I was originally going to announce an introduction of a bill that would repeal Public Law 20-134. However, after having consultation with the ACLU, I decided to hold off on this decision in order to allow the situation to play out in the courts,” Parkinson said Thursday.

The ACLU's lawsuit is about the in-person mandate required by Guam's informed consent for abortion law. The suit has nothing to do with P.L. 20-134, "Belle's Law." In fact the ACLU suit was initiated several months before the Dobb's decision overturning Roe that brought the long-enjoined "Belle's Law" to the fore as an issue.

So why is Parkinson consulting with the ACLU about a completely different issue. Who is running this place anyway? And is the ACLU now running Parkinson?

Let's not hear of any talk of "independence for Guam" from senators like Parkinson who must "run to papa" before they make a move. 

Monday, January 16, 2023

PARKINSON WIMPS OUT

By Tim Rohr

Sen. Will Parkinson is right about one thing. 

From the Pacific Daily News story:

Although the 1990 law calls for a voter referendum, Parkinson said he does not want the matter to go to a public vote.

“I don’t agree with the idea of a referendum as a lawmaker, because we were elected by the people of Guam to make the hard decisions,” Parkinson said.

“(If) every time we have a difficult decision like abortion, we stick it to the people, then what are we here for? … Let’s make a decision and not pass the buck.” 

Parkinson is absolutely right. Enough of the cowards in the legislature. What do they get paid for if not "to make hard decisions?" 

He WAS also right about his intent to introduce a bill to repeal "Guam's decades old abortion ban," Public Law 20-134. Deciding what to do about an abortion law is precisely the job of the legislature. 

However, in this writer's opinion, Parkinson wimped out after apparently getting spanked by the ACLU:

"...after having consultation with the ACLU, I decided to hold off on this decision in order to allow the situation to play out in the courts...”

So after "holding court" about the duty of the legislature not to "pass the buck" to the people, Parkinson passes the buck to the courts.

Allowing "the situation to play out in the courts" is probably going to be an extremely long, drawn out, and costly affair - which it already is, all paid for of course by the people who Parkinson says should not be saddled with "the buck."

It could be of course, as radio talk show show host Bob Klitzkie points out, that Parkinson is just playing his cards in return for "earned media." But Parkinson's ducking behind the ACLU should still cost Parkinson something and not us. 

Sunday, January 15, 2023

CHALLENGING THE "ANCIENT-NESS" OF CHAMORU ABORTIONS

CHamoru activists like Michael Bevacqua and the governor herself have maintained that abortion is historically consistent with Chamoru values. 

In his declaration in support of the current ACLU lawsuit challenging Guam's informed consent for abortion law, Bevacqua writes:

...ensuring access to safe and legal abortion in Guam is consistent with Chamoru values, culture and history and, indeed, there is substantial evidence that Chamoru women have long exercised autonomy and moral authority to make decisions about their pregnancies.

Bevacqua leans on the cultural phenomenon of matriarchal power for the historical roots of abortion in Chamorro culture:

Ancient accounts tell us that Chamoru women in Guam were more than merely vessels for their communities but were empowered to make decisions about their bodies and families. We see a matrilineal focus, where lineage and symbolic societal power resides primarily with women, in many traditional Micronesian Island cultures, but in the Chamoru culture of the Marianas, that it has historically being the strongest. This is something which the earliest accounts of contact with Europeans highlight. Chamoru women in ancient times had authority over themselves and men in many ways that frankly appalled the early Catholic missionaries, who saw as part of their evangelism the reduction of this social and cultural power.

Bevacqua goes on to support his view by referring to research by Dr. Donald Rubinstein describing "ancient" Chamoru abortifacients: 

Dr. Rubinstein has found historical, ethnographic and linguistic evidence dating back to the 18th century showing that, over time, women in Guam and throughout the region have utilized a variety of methods to induce miscarriage or end their pregnancies, as well as to use birth control and other methods to control their fertility.

However, Bevacqua fails to reference a significant entry in Rubinstein's research that traces abortion in CHamoru history - at least on a genocidal scale - to the Spanish period, which means that abortion in CHamoru culture is not so "ancient," and also reveals that abortion was not an exercise of matriarchal power but a desperate response to colonial subjugation.

In a paper titled "Culture in court: notes and reflection on abortion in Guam," Rubinstein recounts a journal entry by a Jesuit priest historian in 1751 describing what Rubinstein labels: "the catastrophic depopulation of the Chamorro people:"

[T]hey cannot abide the yoke of the Spaniards because of their great pride and haughtiness, and that they would like to live as they did in the past, in freedom and [following their] barbarous customs. Because of this, many hang themselves and others kill themselves [each other?]…The women, likewise, purposely sterilize themselves; or if they conceive, they find ways to abort, and some kill their children after birth in order to save them from the subjugation of the Spaniards. 

Later, in 1788, the same Jesuit historian, as quoted by Rubinstein, writes:

The very large diminution of population comes from the subjugation imposed upon them by the force of arms. As lovers of liberty they could not tolerate a foreign yoke. This became so painful for them that, not being able to free themselves of it, they preferred to lose their lives by hanging and by other desperate means. The women purposely sterilized themselves, and they threw their newborn children into the sea, convinced that an early death would free them of travails and a painful life…[in death] they would be fortunate and happy. Subjugation was so despicable that, for them, it was the ultimate and most deplorable calamity.

Regarding the reference to “purposely sterilized themselves," Rubinstein writes that it "is usually interpreted to refer to intentional abortion."

At least according to the above observations from the 18th century, abortion in CHamoru history was not and is not an "ancient" indigenous value but a relatively recent response to colonial subjugation wherein self-genocide was preferable to a "foreign yoke." 

But is that the reason today's Chamorros still kill their babies at many times the rate of other ethnicities? 


SOURCE



 

Saturday, December 24, 2022

UPDATE ON GOV. LLG'S LAWSUIT AGAINST YOU AND ME

A couple of things about the story in today's Guam Daily Post: "Appeal hearing scheduled for abortion law’s in-person mandate"

The story first references the recently passed Guam Heartbeat Act, and describes it as "the controversial measure that would ban abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected, or within about six weeks of conception, when most women may not know they are pregnant."

First, the Act does not actually "ban" abortions once a fetal heartbeat is detected but permits a civil suit against certain persons involved in the abortion. Second, the local media continues to echo the pro-abortion talking point: "when most women may not know they are pregnant." It would be better for reporters to write "when, according to abortion supporters, most women may not know they are pregnant." 

Going on to the main story which is GovGuam's "appeal of the injunction placed on Guam's in-person consultation mandate for abortions," via the Office of the Attorney General. The injunction has permitted off-island doctors to tele-consult and prescribe abortion pills. 

The case is an odd one given that the ACLU's suit is against the Government of Guam which is headed by the most public, pro-abortion governor ever elected and now re-elected. 

Monday, November 21, 2022

ACLU MYTHS RE ABORTION IN GUAM

The following letter to the editor was submitted to the Pacific Daily News on Sep. 16, 2022. To my knowledge, and after several follow ups to the editor, it was never published so I am publishing it here with the addition of links and references.

+++++

By Tim Rohr

According to the ACLU, Guam’s informed consent law for abortion violates the 14th amendment and “causes irreparable harm and unnecessary shame in a community where the procedure is stigmatized.” (Pacific Daily News, Sep. 16, 2022)

That abortion is stigmatized in Guam is an ACLU myth. Compared to a study published by Americans United for Life in 2008, Guam, due to its lack of abortion regulation, was the easiest place in the nation to procure an abortion.

Since 2008, regulation has increased, but not through any effort by “stigmatizing” religious groups or pro-life lawmakers, but mostly via the efforts of The Esperansa Project which purposely steered clear of religious arguments, and in doing so, helped enact eight pro-life laws in eight years. 

Saturday, November 19, 2022

COMMENTING ON PDN'S TAKE ON "BILL TO RESTRICT ABORTION"

Posted by Tim Rohr


PDN: Bill to restrict abortion was stalled until days after election

"Legislation to further restrict access to abortion on Guam sat idle until just days after this year’s general election.

Over a thousand people testified for and against the Guam Heartbeat Act of 2022, which would ban abortion after a fetal heartbeat is detected in the womb. The measure was unable to be debated by lawmakers and go to vote on the session floor without final approval from the Legislature’s Committee on Health — until Nov. 10, the day after the final, unofficial results for the general election were tabulated."

Bill 291-36 sat idle because the sponsors did not care to move the bill through the Legislature. Apparently they only wanted to get the credit for introducing said legislation and then ran and hid. Nothing new here.

For contrast, in 2012, and just days before the election, The Esperansa Project pushed then-Governor Eddie Calvo to call for a special session to debate a bill requiring informed consent for abortion - which had been languishing for nearly 2 years.

The session was held and it was quite a spectacle with certain lawmakers breaking into tears, leashing hell on Calvo, and attacking me personally (though not by name), NOT for the actual issue, but for actually requiring them to do their job before an election: which was to publicly take a stand.

A very smart pro-abort senator (BJ Cruz) publicly testified in favor of the bill and then later and quietly added a provision that would require the bill to go through the administrative rules process in the next legislature. Smart guy.

The bill was eventually enacted into law but not until The Esperansa Project had to fight the battle all over again and get the bill past the rules process.

BTW, the informed consent legislation is the law which is currently at issue relative to the ACLU lawsuit re "zoom abortions." 

Note: As time permits, I will add links to the 2012 matter and the ACLU lawsuit later.

Tuesday, October 25, 2022

LETTER: ACLU ANSWER IS ABSURD

Letter to the editor

Looking at data, abortion doctors have nothing to fear on Guam

Tim Rohr

Per an Oct. 21 news story in this publication, “lawyers for two Hawaii-based doctors have filed their answer to the brief submitted by the Office of the Attorney General in the ongoing appeal of an injunction placed on Guam's in-person consultation mandate for abortions.”

From the story it appears that the Hawaii-based doctors have nothing to support their “answer” other than Guam is a scary place:  

CONTINUED

Wednesday, September 21, 2022

WHY NOT THE GOVERNOR?

 Letter to the editor

Nurse can satisfy abortion requirement

https://www.postguam.com/forum/letter_to_the_editor/nurse-can-satisfy-abortion-requirement/article_5b89b884-388e-11ed-a0fb-3b7ae751f473.html

The published letter is copied below with links added for references. 

The ACLU’s argument in its suit against the Government of Guam is that in-person consultation relative to Guam’s law requiring informed consent for abortion prevents the administration of “medication abortion through telemedicine.” (Guam Daily Post, Sept. 19, 2022)

The law requires that certain information be provided to a woman seeking an abortion, and be provided in person by the attending physician or by another qualified person.

The only reason telemedicine is necessary, and thus the suit, is because no doctor on Guam, including those who publicly support abortion access, are willing to provide the required information to women.

But the law says by a physician “or another qualified person.” So why not a nurse? In fact, why not Gov. Lou Leon Guerrero, a registered nurse?

This is a perfect campaign opportunity for the governor.

There is no other issue that she is more publicly passionate about. And given no physician or other qualified person is willing to do it, by providing this service to women, she will lead by example and save the government many thousands of dollars by avoiding a lawsuit.

Recently obtained reports show that there have been approximately 3 abortions per month via telemedicine. The governor could easily fit in 3 hours per month to meet with the women she says she cares about.

Tim Rohr is a resident of HĂĄgat.

  • Link to the Attorney General's Defendant-Appellant Opening Brief
  • Link to HelpThemBoth.org
  • The Esperansa Project site

Tuesday, September 20, 2022

APPELLANT'S OPENING BRIEF IN THE ACLU MATTER

Deputy Attorney General James Canto II's Brief is excellent and should be read by anyone who cares about presenting solid arguments for life in the womb. 

It is not necessary to "throw religious bombs." They don't work anyway. And they don't work because the pro-aborts are expecting them and ready to discard them with their usual "separation of church and state" rhetoric. 

Pray, yes. But work to win by knowing how to craft legal arguments, and just as important, learn how to present those arguments in a strategic way. 

The Esperansa Project, between 2008 and 2016, initiated and shepherded eight bills regulating abortion that were enacted into law by staying away from religious and even scientific arguments and focusing on legal precedent and shaping public opinion...as well as exposing what was going on behind closed doors in the legislature.

Read Atty. Canto's Brief here.

Monday, March 15, 2021

BOB KLITZKIE ON TALL TALES: CALAMITY JAYNE VS CHAMORRO BABIES

 Bob spends the better part of his show today exposing several matters relative to our own governor's role (in the person of Jayne Flores) in the ACLU lawsuit, including what appears to be a scam cooked up between Jayne and the Plaintiffs to sue Guam. 

CONTINUED at The Esperansa Project Blog

LETTER TO THE EDITOR

Letter: Settlement didn't restore abortion access

Tim Rohr

Recently, the Pacific Daily News reported that a settlement in the ACLU abortion suit “will restore abortion access” and further reported an ACLU attorney claiming the settlement to be a “victory for reproductive freedom in Guam.”

However, the court order tells a different story. CONTINUED

Sunday, March 14, 2021

LLG's WAR AGAINST CHAMORRO CHILDREN

 Question: Why would two Hawaii-based doctors go through the trouble and expense of applying for and acquiring licenses to practice medicine in Guam when neither doctor apparently has ever been to Guam or intends to come to Guam?

Read more at The Esperansa Project Blog.