Saturday, May 10, 2025

BECAUSE YOU'RE A LIAR

By Tim Rohr

Apuron at the Vatican, after he ran away from Guam in 2016


In light of what Apuron is claiming (his innocence), let us review what he claimed on April 4, 2019, after Pope Francis personally upheld his guilty verdict by the Vatican court. 

My comments in red, and all emphases added.

LINK to original copy. 

+++++

April 4, 2019

PRESS RELEASE

Statement of Archbishop Anthony Sablan Apuron, OFM Cap. D.D.

 

I am deeply saddened by the decision of the Holy Father to confirm the decision of the court of first instance. I lodged an appeal against that decision last year because I am innocent and the sentence of the court of first instance had vindicated me declaring non credible the majority of the charges made against me: I believe that the facts and evidence presented demonstrated my total innocence.

Here is what the court of the first instance found on March 13, 2018: 

The Apostolic Tribunal of the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, composed of five judges, has issued its sentence of first instance, finding the accused guilty of certain of the accusations and imposing upon the accused the penalties of privation of office and prohibition of residence in the Archdiocese of Guam.

Apuron and his supporters have consistently claimed that because the court did not specifically state "sex abuse of minors," that Apuron was not found guilty of that crime. However, whatever "certain of the accusations" means, it was serious enough to deprive him of his office and prohibit him from residing in Guam - forever. So whatever he did, it was obviously very serious. 

Of course we know what he did, because upon Pope Francis upholding Apuron's guilty verdict, Francis clearly stated what Apuron was guilty of:

...the Tribunal of Second Instance upheld the sentence of First Instance finding the Archbishop guilty of delicts against the Sixth Commandment with minors. 

Moreover, in addition to privation of office and prohibition from residing in Guam, the Pope went on to add an additional penalty: 

...the perpetual prohibition from using the insignia attached to the rank of Bishop. 

Yet, Apuron wants us to believe that the first Vatican tribunal and then the Pope are wrong. And he still wants us to believe given his little speech the other day after his accusers decided to dismiss their complaints after ten years of going nowhere. 

In fact, it's quite a slap in the face to them. They were told for ten years how old and sickly Apuron was and how he couldn't even sit for a single deposition, so it's quite possible out of mercy that they dropped their cases. And then immediately Apuron runs to the cameras, not looking old or sickly at all, proclaims his innocence (again), and slams the very people who showed him mercy. But that's Apuron. 

It's also quite possible that the court of the first instance, out of reserve and mercy for Apuron, did not detail the exact crimes Apuron had been found guilty of. And of course, Apuron right away ran to the cameras saying that this was evidence of his innocence. Apuron's complete disregard for the mercy the first court showed him is probably why Francis made the reason for the guilty verdict very clear upon the failure of Apuron's appeal.  

In addition to the pattern of contradictions evident in the accusations laid against me, my hopes for a successful appeal were supported by what I considered to be definitive new evidence which illustrated what I have always asserted to be a coordinated campaign against me.

As the primary "coordinator" of the alleged "campaign," I can tell you yes, it became a "coordinated campaign." I detailed the whole thing in a series I titled "Orchestrated." 

The short version is this. After Apuron kicked Fr. Paul Gofigan out of his parish, and then Msgr. James Benavente, a man living in San Francisco named John Toves publicly claimed that Apuron had sexually molested a relative. As that story gained traction, others who Apuron had sexually abused began to wake up. 

After Roy Quintanilla came forward to accuse Apuron, the news got to a woman living in Arizona who used to live in Agat, Guam, and whose son, on his deathbed, told her that Apuron had raped him. The woman, Doris Concepcion, made the story known to the press whereupon Apuron, on May 31, 2016, threatened to sue me, Doris, and anyone else involved in exposing his crimes:

Therefore, the Archdiocese of Agana is in the process of taking canonical and legal measures against those perpetrating these malicious lies. (Archdiocese of Agana, Press Release, May 31, 2016)

This is when things started to get coordinated. We had no legal protections against Apuron, and he had the money of the archdiocese to crush us. So we began working on legislation that would allow us to fight back. That legislation became the public law lifting the civil statute of limitations on the sex abuse of minors which was enacted in September 2016. 

By then Apuron had already run away and been hiding for months. The problem escalated when the guy Rome sent to run things, Archbishop Savio Hon, who worked for Cardinal Fernando Filoni, a Neocat cardinal, mocked Apuron's accusers - in a clear attempt to save the Neocatechumenal Way in Guam. At that point, the late-Senator Bob Klitzkie got involved and developed the legislation to include institutional liability, which was critical to attracting lawyers to the case. 

So yah, it was "coordinated," but not from the start. Every time Apuron made a move, beginning with his treatment of Gofigan, there was an "equal and opposite reaction." Apuron, per his recent video, is still making those moves and provoking ever more "equal and opposite reactions," if only, at this point, my reminding everyone of just how terrible this man was...and still is.

The pontifical secret prevents me from litigating my good name in public, but I wish to take this opportunity to offer my deepest thanks to the many individuals who have privately and publicly come forward in my defense, despite threats and the climate of fear on my beloved home of Guam. This climate, - shown by the local media, - which hampered the work of the court of first instance, testifies to the presence of a pressure group that plotted to destroy me, and which has made itself clearly known even to authorities in Rome. Several persons have told me - with great pain and fear and asking me not to reveal their names - they had been asked to make allegations against me, even offered money.

So pathetic. This man is either Evil Incarnate or he is sick, very mentally sick. Out of charity, I'll assume the latter. Apuron has had no problem over the years "litigating (his) good name in public." In fact, if there really was a "pontifical secret" in place, he could not have even written this very statement where he proclaims his innocence immediately after being found guilty for the second time by Pope Francis himself. 

If there really were threats, a climate of fear, a pressure group that plotted to destroy him, and people who were offered money to make allegations against him, then now's your moment Mr. Apuron. Now's your moment. There is no more legal action in either the church or the civil courts, so you are free to name names. So why aren't you? Because you're a liar. 

Child sexual abuse is an abhorrent crime that cries to heaven for vengeance. The desperate need for justice and compassion for the survivors is fundamental. So too is the urgent need to fight this evil always and everywhere through a transparent and courageous search for the truth.

LOL. I sure hope Apuron is truly mentally ill, because otherwise this statement is a sacrilege which itself "cries to heaven for vengeance."

The sentence of the Holy Father concludes my search for justice in the canonical forum: I owe His Holiness my obedience as a bishop, priest and son of the Church. I totally submit to the judgment of the Holy Father as I thank him for allowing me to continue serving as a priest and archbishop without insignia. This sentence exiles me from my beloved Guam: a penalty analogous to a death sentence for me. I lose my homeland, my family, my church, my people, even my language, and I remain alone in complete humiliation, old and in failing health.

Oh boo-hoo. Alone, old, and in failing health. Well here we are six years later and he looks just fine on his little personal TV station. He's being well cared for by his Neocat brethren. That was the deal from the outset. And he DID NOT "totally submit to the judgment of the Holy Father." If he did, he would not have immediately released this statement which functionally states that the Holy Father is WRONG. 

I offer this suffering for the Holy Father: may the Lord guide him at this difficult time at the helm of the Church; I offer my suffering to my accusers and to those who have plotted for my removal: may the Lord fill them with everything they want and pray - Father, forgive them for they do not know what they do.

Oh, here we go again with Apuron mocking Jesus on the cross. And by the way, we did know what we did. Because we know what YOU DID.

I hope that one day new witnesses, who have been prevented from coming forward by the atmosphere of fear and intimidation, will yet fully vindicate my name. I also pray for my accusers and for those who have plotted against me. We will each meet before that final tribunal where the full truth will be laid bare before the Supreme Judge.

The only atmosphere of fear and intimidation - and this is on the record - was coming from Apuron who constantly threatened to sue us. And, as I already said, now's your time, Mr. Apuron. Now's your opportunity to bring forth those "new witnesses." I recommend you do it before you get to the Supreme Judge yourself. 

I pray unceasingly for the Holy Church and I look forward to the justice that awaits me beyond this valley of tears: when I awake I will be satisfied with your face, oh Lord.

You'll see justice alright. And we didn't see any tears in your video. 

JOSE IS RIGHT

 


LINK to original

TIM ROHR WITH PATTI ARROYO ON APURON

By Tim Rohr


On May 9, on "Mornings with Patti" on the Wave 105.1 FM, I spoke with Patti Arroyo regarding Apuron's new "I'm innocent" road show. This LINK should take you to the point where the call starts. Otherwise it is about the 2:40:00 mark on the video.  

NEOCATS. NEOCATS. NEOCATS. IT'S ALWAYS THE SAME ANSWER.

By Tim Rohr


Apuron's recent pathetic claim to "innocence" after the civil cases against him were voluntarily dismissed by the plaintiffs is made all the more stupid by the fact that guilt and innocence can only be adjudicated in criminal cases, and these were not criminal cases. They were civil liability cases. 

The 2016 statute that permitted legal action against Apuron was a law that lifted the CIVIL statute of limitations on sex abuse of minors. This means that Apuron could only be found LIABLE or NOT LIABLE, not INNOCENT or GUILTY. 

The only court that had the authority to find Apuron GUILTY was the Vatican court. And, as Archbishop Jimenez reaffirmed yesterday:

While the Archdiocese respects the decisions of the victims of the former archbishop to end their cases before civil authorities, it remains the fact that on 07 February 2019, he was found guilty of committing abuse against minors. That determination was made following a canonical investigation and penal trial conducted by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of Faith in Rome. That determination led to the former bishop losing his rank and duties as the leader of the Catholic Church on Guam, as well as a perpetual prohibition preventing him from returning to Guam or presenting himself with the insignia attached to the rank of bishop. Nothing about that determination has changed.
(Emphases added)

Apuron's attorney, Jacqueline Terlaje, knows this, yet she trotted him out onto the public stage to take a bow and proclaim that the voluntary dismissal in a civil case proved his "innocence!" What a joke! But why would she do this? Neocats, Neocats, Neocats. It's always the same answer. 

+++++

By the way, the above picture of the "trained lawyer" (as she calls herself), is from a 2017 article titled: "Apuron not considering settling lawsuits till canonical trial is over." In the article Atty. Terlaje is quoted as saying: 

"I am not considering, my client is not considering settling any cases until such time as a canonical trial is complete." 

So, apparently as far back as 2017, the option to settle was already being considered by Apuron. Apparently he changed his mind after he got rid of his largest assets, if not all of them - as I set out in this post. 

Friday, May 9, 2025

ARCHBISHOP JIMENEZ MAKES THE RIGHT MOVE

LINK to copy of Original 

(Emphases added)

09 May 2025

To: Clergy and Religious Women of the Archdiocese of Agaña Re: Apuron Civil Proceedings

Dear Brother Priests, Deacons and Sisters,

The Archdiocese of Agaña has learned that the plaintiffs who maintained various civil claims before the District Court of Guam against former Archbishop Anthony Apuron have agreed, through a stipulation of their respective lawyers, to voluntarily dismiss those cases effective 07 May 2025. I have asked our legal counsel to explain what those dismissals mean, and our counsel has confirmed that a dismissal under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii) does not operate as an adjudication about the merits of a particular case, but is a mechanism that allows the parties to a particular civil case to mutually agree to end that legal matter. The decision of the parties to stipulate to a dismissal with prejudice means that the Plaintiffs have agreed to not pursue their claims in the future in any court. We are directing questions regarding the recently announced resolution of the civil court cases involving the former archbishop to the parties and counsels involved in those cases.

While the Archdiocese respects the decisions of the victims of the former archbishop to end their cases before civil authorities, it remains the fact that on 07 February 2019, he was found guilty of committing abuse against minors. That determination was made following a canonical investigation and penal trial conducted by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of Faith in Rome. That determination led to the former bishop losing his rank and duties as the leader of the Catholic Church on Guam, as well as a perpetual prohibition preventing him from returning to Guam or presenting himself with the insignia attached to the rank of bishop. Nothing about that determination has changed.

Until every obligation is met, the Archdiocese continues the important work of fulfilling the directives under the reorganization plan set in motion by Archbishop Michael Jude Byrnes. We will not forget that the 302 claims filed against the Archdiocese would not have been settled without the financial contributions from all Archdiocesan entities and the important work you all have done in the parishes and schools to identify real property that can be sold to fund the settlement trust fund. The Archdiocese subsequently resolved its role as a defendant in every civil case it was a part of when the District Court of Guam issued its Order confirming the bankruptcy reorganization plan for the Archdiocese in 2022.

It cannot ever be overstated or undermined the vigilance we all must have to protect our most vulnerable. I remain committed to carrying out the pledge expressed in my letter of 06 December 2024, to all our brothers and sisters “to walk in fidelity with the survivors and all concerned to the end when we see God face to face and our tears are no more.”

Finally, to my brother priests, my co-workers in our shared service to the People of God, let us be good shepherds and heralds of the Gospel. And, to all, in these remaining days of Easter, let us anticipate God’s love poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us by the Father and the Son.

Yours in Christ,

+Ryan P. Jimenez, DD Archbishop of Agaña 


MY NOTES

"...a dismissal under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii) does not operate as an adjudication about the merits of a particular case, but is a mechanism that allows the parties to a particular civil case to mutually agree to end that legal matter." 

- This means that there was no adjudication (judgment) in the matter and the dismissal does not operate as a judgment of innocence as Apuron is claiming - AND his attorney, Jacque Terlaje, knows this. Yet, she provided the video of Apuron's victory dance to the media and may have even written the script he was obviously reading. 

"...the victims of the former archbishop..."

- There is no question. Archbishop Jimenez makes it clear that Apuron victimized the plaintiffs.

"...it remains the fact that on 07 February 2019, he was found guilty of committing abuse against minors...Nothing about that determination has changed."

- Actually, Apuron was found guilty by the court of the first instance on March 18, 2018. He lost his appeal when Pope Francis upheld the guilty verdict on Feb. 7, 2019.

- Now we shall see if Archbishop Jimenez can withstand the backlash of Apuron's Neo-backers. 

Thursday, May 8, 2025

THE HORRIBLE THINGS

By Tim Rohr



In the latest update on this story, the attorney for the plaintiffs, Delia Wolff, stated that despite the plaintiffs agreeing to dismiss their complaints against Apuron, the plaintiffs "continue to stand by their allegations that Apuron did horrible things to them."

It would be good to review once again those "horrible things." Following are the cases filed by Roy Quintanilla, Walter Denton, Mary Jane Quinata Cruz as Administratrix of the Estate of Joseph "Sonny" Quinata, Roland Sondia, Ramon De Plata, and Mark Apuron. There are three more plaintiffs but they only used their initials and not their names. 


Walter Denton

 Joseph "Sonny" Quinata

Roland Sondia

Ramon De Plata

Mark Apuron

APURON BETTER BE HOPING FOR ANOTHER DISMISSAL

By Tim Rohr

As I've already set out in a previous post, this dismissal has all the signs and smells of "no money in it." The plaintiffs and their attorneys already got their money from the church bankruptcy case. There was no reason to continue except for the apology from Apuron which is what his initial accusers stated from the outset that that was all they wanted. 

Maybe they got it. But then why is Apuron trumpeting his innocence if he said he was sorry? Well that's not hard to answer. Because he is Apuron. And the only thing that matters to Apuron is Apuron. Besides, with the case dismissed permanently, no one will ever know what really happened. That is unless the plaintiff's want to talk. 

However, I don't think they will. If I can speculate further, I think the deal (we can't call it a settlement) may have included an apology on condition that the plaintiffs never speak of it. I wouldn't put it past Apuron - or his attorney to make such a deal. 

You have to hand it to the "trained lawyer" * though. Delaying this case for nearly a decade was perfect strategy. It gave Apuron time to get rid of his assets (or hide them), as I set out in a previous post. It gave time for the bankruptcy case to go through which funneled money to the plaintiffs and their attorneys. 

And most important, it gave time for the case to become a "loser" for the plaintiff's attorneys, Lujan and Wolff, as they had always been working on contingency, and, as Apuron had few assets after nearly ten years, they were essentially working for free. And attorneys don't like to do that. 

Perfect, Jacque. Perfect. Bravo. 

* "Trained lawyer." That's how Jacque Terlaje referred to herself back in 2015 when she was defending Apuron's canonically illegal alienation of what was then a 70 Million Dollar property and handing it over to the Neocats. 

The Pacific Daily News updated its initial story after plaintiffs' attorney, Delia Wolff, made a statement. For my own better understanding, I am going to parse it out with my comments in red.

By the way, the PDN's choice of a picture for the story is ironic. "Louie," the neocat priest the cops found with an underaged girl in a car at an Agat beach back in 2015 - which his head in the wrong place - is the guy behind Apuron. After the story broke, Apuron rushed Louie off-island where he disappeared for most of the next decade. And, like Apuron, he was harbored by Neocats. Louie is back, by the way.




UPDATED Former archbishop breaks years of silence, plaintiffs' counsel says dismissal 'not evidence that Apuron did not sexually abuse or defame them'

Former Archbishop Anthony Apuron on Wednesday broke his years of silence in a video message, maintaining he’s innocent of the clergy sex abuse allegations against him.

He issued a video message after plaintiffs initiated proceedings that sought dismissal of cases, according to his attorney. Apuron is required to agree to the dismissal, his counsel said.

"Required?" Required by who? That sounds like a settlement: "If we do this, then you do that." No court rule requires a party to agree to a dismissal, unless the court itself dismisses a case. And that's not what happened here. So maybe they're not calling it a settlement - probably because Apuron has no assets to settle with. But it certainly is an agreement - which is a functionally a settlement.

He did, and the parties filed a motion that dismisses with prejudice eight clergy sex abuse cases and one defamation case against him.

Delia Lujan Wolff, attorney for the plaintiffs, on Wednesday night said dismissal of the plaintiffs’ claims against Apuron “is not evidence that Apuron did not sexually abuse or defame them.”

“To be clear, Apuron has not been vindicated by the dismissals and they do not affirm his innocence. While our clients have dismissed their claims against Apuron, after delays in taking his deposition due to Apuron’s alleged health problems and his claim that he has very limited financial resources, they continue to stand by their allegations that Apuron did horrible things to them,” Wolff stated. “In fact, our clients have already received partial relief on their claims.”

There's a lot here. But primarily it points to Wolff herself talking the plaintiffs into dismissing the case. I can't prove that. But it makes sense, especially when she says "he has very limited financial resources." As I already said, lawyers don't like to work for free. Nobody does. So it was a business decision. 

Of course it was always a business decision. Wolff's father, David Lujan, took the cases back in 2017, after the law lifting the civil statute of limitations on sex abuse against minors had been enacted. Lujan is a smart businessman. I'm sure he knew that the real money would be in the suit against the archdiocese, not Apuron individually. And he was right. Now that the archdiocese case is settled - to the tune of many millions of dollars - why bother with a washed up 80-year old Apuron who has no money? 

Meanwhile, though, to get the bill passed that would pave the way to many millions for the attorneys, the case needed a human face to stir the passions needed to see the legislation through. And those faces were provided by the initial four boys who "Apuron did horrible things to..." as Wolff says above. 

Meanwhile, it's helpful that Wolff says "Apuron has not been vindicated by the dismissals and they do not affirm his innocence," but as you can see from Apuron's victory lap and what is obviously a campaign to return to Guam, Wolff's clarification means nothing - and the plaintiffs are now barred from ever bringing up the "horrible things" that happened to them ever again.

A federal judge has yet to act on the voluntary dismissal.

It appears the judge has to sign off on this. However, I often wondered why this same judge allowed this case to languish for nearly a decade - with only a bit of prodding here and there. I don't know about local District Court rules but according to AI:

The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provides tools for the court to actively manage cases and address delays by:
  • Setting clear deadlines and allowing for extensions under specific circumstances . 
  • Using scheduling orders and case management conferences to ensure progress . 
  • Utilizing various motions to expedite resolution or address specific issues . 
  • Taking action against parties who are deliberately delaying the process . 

However, none of this appeared to happen in this case. I wonder why?

Apuron, in his video message, shared by his attorney, Jacqueline Terlaje, said he can now speak freely about the canonical process.

He was always free to speak about the canonical process (his Vatican trial). In fact, he did on many occasions: repeatedly swearing to his innocence even after the first court found him guilty and again after Pope Francis personally denied his appeal. In fact, Apuron repeatedly claimed that he was framed by "Tim Rohr and his associates" for the purposes of serving a Chinese gambling interest. 

Here is what he said after the Vatican found him guilt as reported in the Guam Daily Post on March 19, 2018:

“I have been informed of the conclusion of the first instance canonical trial against me. While I am relieved that the tribunal dismissed the majority of the accusations against me, I have appealed the verdict. God is my witness – I am innocent, and I look forward to proving my innocence in the appeals process."

And here is what KUAM reported on April 4, 2019, after Apuron lost his Vatican appeal and the first guilty verdict was personally upheld by Pope Francis:

Apuron in a statement said he was “deeply saddened by the decision of the Holy Father to confirm the decision of the court of first instance. I lodged an appeal against that decision last year because I am innocent and the sentence of the court of first instance had vindicated me declaring non credible the majority of the charges made against me: I believe that the facts and evidence presented demonstrated my total innocence.”

(The same KUAM story contains a full press release by Apuron that will turn your stomach. I'll deal with it separately.)

Bottom line is that Apuron did not "suffer in silence" as he wants us now to believe. He has not only virulently and publicly protested his innocence, he has just as virulently and publicly threatened those of us who stood up to him. Just more lies and more lies. 

“The canonical process did not result in my laicization. No priest or bishop who has been found guilty of these crimes has remained a priest or bishop as I have. This indicates my innocence,” he said.

Lies, lies and more lies. There's a long list of priests and cardinals who have been found "guilty of these crimes" and "has remained a priest of bishop." Cardinal Theodore McCarrick is one. Even though he was eventually laicized due to his gross disobedience, he was first simply removed from office as Apuron was. There was also Cardinal George Pell of Australia who was found guilty of the same crimes by an Australian court and spent 404 days in jail and had his nose broken before being acquitted by the High Court of Australia. Pell was never laicized and died a Cardinal in 2023 in the good graces of the Church - and truly innocent. He didn't just have the cases against him mysteriously dismissed.

Moreover, Apuron here is functionally calling Pope Francis a liar. It was Francis who personally upheld his guilty verdict upon Apuron's appeal and in doing so, clarified exactly what Apuron was guilty of: "delicts against the Sixth Commandment with minors."


‘Forever disgraced’

Apuron was stripped of his title, permanently removed from his post and was exiled, after a Vatican tribunal found him guilty related to sexual abuse of minors. He left Guam in 2016.

Note the dates, because his defenders are claiming that he was "ordered to leave Guam." Nope. Apuron ran away within one day of Roy Quintanilla coming forward with accusations against Apuron on May 17, 2016. He was not ordered to never return to Guam until the conclusion of the canonical trial in March 2018, two years later. 

He lost his appeal and the Vatican tribunal in 2019 upheld the earlier guilty verdict.

The plaintiffs’ attorney, Wolff, said “as a result of the Vatican finding Apuron ‘guilty of delicts against the Sixth Amendment with minors’ and Apuron losing his appeal, Apuron was removed from the office of the Archbishop of Agana and perpetually prohibited from dwelling, even temporarily, in Guam.”

“That is huge for our clients. He has been forever disgraced and he cannot change that with a press release,” Wolff stated.

It's funny to read Wolff saying this now because in 2017, when Pope Francis sent Cardinal Burke to Guam to investigate this mess, I was told that Wolff's father, David Lujan, had advised his clients (Roy, Walter, Roland, and Doris), not to speak to Burke. Lujan's interest was his own case, not the Vatican's, so he had good reason to control his clients. 
However, I knew then what has proven to be true now, that if the Vatican did not convict Apuron, then Lujan's case wouldn't matter. Lujan had the power to sue Apuron and hold him liable in behalf of his clients, but he didn't have the power to remove Apuron from the archdiocese. Only the Vatican could do that. 
Also, at this point, things were growing very tense for me and my family. Apuron had publicly threatened to sue me. My family wanted me out of this, and understandably so. However, I had come too far at that point and my only hope for saving my family and myself was for the Vatican to find Apuron guilty and remove him. 
So I went to see Mr. Lujan myself and pled my case: to let his clients participate in the Vatican investigation. Eventually, all four did participate, Apuron was found guilty and was removed. Unfortunately, it was too late for some members of my family, at least one of whom had been compromised by the Neocats. I have evidence of that. 
So, as I started off saying, it's funny to see Lujan's partner and daughter relying now on the Vatican verdict that may never have happened had I not intervened with her father all those years ago. I'm not taking credit for it. Maybe Lujan had planned to do it anyway. 

‘Injustice in silence’

Apuron, who was the head of the Catholic Church on Guam for some 30 years, said he was unjustly condemned by the media and by public opinion because of false accusations made against him, and that he accepted the injustice in silence.

Actually, the "media" only reported what his accusers were saying. His accusers, the boys he molested and raped, accused him. So it's interesting that he doesn't call out their names here, but falls back on the generic "media" and "public opinion." If you're innocent, Mr. Apuron, why not name names? 

Well, we know why. You're not innocent. And naming names could open paths to new litigation. In fact, why not name my name - like you did in so many press releases before? In fact, I was the only "media" (JungleWatch) that provided a forum for those accusations for most of the first couple years of this. If anyone could be accused of "unjustly condemning" you, it's me. So have at it. 

And, as already demonstrated, he sure as hell did not "accept the injustice in silence." Here's one reminder of how he accepted the so-called injustice:

“Tim Rohr and his associates launched a 'vicious and calumnious attack' on the archbishop and the church,” the statement says...The archdiocese is in the process of taking canonical and legal measures against those perpetrating these malicious lies.” - Guam Daily Post, June 1, 2016

In fact, here is what his attorney said after Apuron was found hiding in his friends' house near San Francisco:

Attorney Jacque Terlaje provided a statement to KUAM: "As you are aware, I am legal counsel for Archbishop Anthony Apuron, OFM Cap. D.D. In response to your inquires regarding his whereabouts, the Archbishop is in a location where he is able to continue working on defending his innocence without distraction." - KUAM, Feb. 2, 2017 

So according to his own attorney, Apuron wasn't suffering in silence and praying for his accusers, he was "working on defending his innocence without distraction." LOL. 

“Today I pray to God to have mercy on those who smeared my reputation and destroyed my life for economic and political reasons...and also for those who judged me listening to them. United to the Lord I can say: Father, forgive them, they do not know what they are doing.”

Wow. To take the words of Jesus hanging on the cross and apply them to yourself! SMH. But beyond that, Mr. Apuron, please demonstrate how any of us who stood up to you benefitted economically or politically. You can't. In fact, several of us paid terrible prices while you danced around your "hill" singing "No one can touch me." Some of us gave up years of lives and had our own reputations smeared - by you and your goons - while we fought to end the "filth in the church" you and your friends smeared it with.

Apuron said many people have expressed their solidarity and support to him and that many people in the Archdiocese of Agana know the truth.

If any of that were true, then Apuron would have had his "day in court" as he so often said he wanted. He could have brought those "people" who expressed "their solidarity and support" and who knew "the truth." But he didn't. Instead, he ran away at the first accusation and was even found hiding in a house owned by the VP of the Bank of Guam in San Francisco. Never forget where he was found hiding.

Accusers locate Apuron - Guam Daily Post, Jan. 18, 2018


He said a climate of fear remains in the church of Guam, created, he said, by people who want to destroy Guam and have no shame using the church to gain money and power.

Well, he had ten years to prove that. But he didn't. Instead he stayed in hiding, claiming to be too old and sickly to show up for a deposition - though he had no problem romping about on video yesterday proclaiming victory. 

“I pray that one day my exile may be lifted and that I may return to my beloved motherland. I keep living this time in prayer and offer my sufferings also for my enemies and for those who condemned me,” he said. “I pray also for the current Archbishop of Guam, may the Lord give him strength, discernment and courage to seek the truth and to do what is right.”

Ummm, Mr. Apuron. Your accusers accused you. They didn't condemn you. The POPE did.

Can’t bring same claims

Apuron’s counsel issued a press release following the filing of the stipulation.

“The claims against Archbishop Apuron have now been voluntarily dismissed with prejudice, meaning that these plaintiffs are prohibited from bringing the same claims against him ever again,” Terlaje stated.

She said these “voluntary dismissals bring to a close nearly a decade of protracted litigation.”

You gotta admit. Jacque is good. She sure as hell was careful not to say "my client has been vindicated" - something any lawyer representing the winning party would be happy to exclaim. But she didn't. Because he wasn't. 

U.S. District Court Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood, who has presided over the Guam clergy sex abuse cases and the Archdiocese of Agana bankruptcy case, has yet to act on the voluntary dismissal.

Also named in the lawsuits were the Archdiocese of Agana, which settled the cases to exit bankruptcy; the Holy See; and several Capuchin Franciscan entities.

The cases included eight allegations of sexual abuse dating back to the 1970s, mostly from former Hågat alter boys and one defamation case.

‘Made a settlement offer’

Plaintiffs’ counsel earlier stated in a court filing that during a Zoom meeting, “Atty. Terlaje, on behalf of Apuron, made a settlement offer to the plaintiffs.”

“Thereafter, the parties have been engaged in settlement discussions to resolve the dispute between them. The parties’ settlement discussions are in line with what I recall and understood to be the Court’s previous encouragement to the parties to consider resolution and the financial burden of continued litigation,” the April 30 court filing stated.

Another April 30 filing stated that Apuron’s counsel “made a settlement offer to Plaintiff.”

Terlaje’s statement, meanwhile, echoed Apuron’s video message that he has never offered or entered into any settlement agreement with the plaintiffs, nor has he offered any money or other consideration to any plaintiff to resolve these cases.

“Archbishop Apuron has only asserted his willingness to execute a stipulation of dismissal to resolve the cases, as is required under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure...to dismiss any case at this stage of litigation,” according to Terlaje’s statement.

In 2016, Apuron’s accusers said all they wanted was an apology from Apuron.

“Archbishop Apuron has always maintained his innocence in the face of these claims, and has continued to defend his good name within the process permitted under our laws,” Terlaje said in a Wednesday statement.”

Ummm, really? Defended his good name? That's what we were looking forward to: a solid defense at his "day in court." But Jacque, you were careful never to let that happen, weren't you. In fact, as the next line in the story says:

Apuron has not been deposed in any of the cases.

 LOL. You say he "continued to defend his good name but he never even showed up for so much as a single deposition. So there was no defense, just his measly whining from whatever hole he was hiding in - and still is. And by the way, and once again, it was the POPE who trashed his "good name." And he did it personally.

“Unfortunately, due to extenuating circumstances beyond his control, the trial and discovery process was delayed partly by unwillingness of plaintiffs to comply with basic requests for information, which is the basis for motions to compel Archbishop Apuron’s unwavering dedication to due process and justice, in asserting his innocence, is affirmed by the plaintiffs’ decision to dismiss their claims today,” Terlaje said in a statement.

It's hard to wrap my head around this B.S. It appears Jacque is saying that the circumstances beyond Apuron's control was the plaintiff's unwillingness to comply with requests for information. That's bullshit. That is totally in Jacque's control. Requests for Admissions, Interrogatories, and other Discovery tools must be complied with or the "unwilling" party is subject to contempt of court. They can't just say no. That was totally in Jacque's control. Did she file motions to compel production? Did she file motions to show cause? Contempt? I don't think so. It's clear that Jacque and her buddy wanted to draw this out as long as they could, and they did. And they did it to tire out the opposition. It worked.

Apuron’s health concerns were among reasons cited earlier as to why the planned deposition did not go forward.

As already mentioned and demonstrated, Apuron certainly had no problem going on camera and celebrating. So much for the lies about his health. 

“Archbishop Anthony Apuron continues to pray, in solitude, for the Church of Guam, his accusers, and all those victims of abuse in Guam and throughout the Church,” Terlaje stated.

What a joke. He's certainly not in solitude. He's living it up with the Neocats. That was the deal.

The archdiocese settled nearly 300 clergy sex abuse claims as part of the bankruptcy process.

And now comes the moment of truth for Archbishop Ryan Jimenez. In case he wants my advice, Jimenez would do best with sticking what Rome has decided, not what Jacque or Apuron is saying about this mixed up dismissal thing. In any event, Apuron's actions plunged this archdiocese into bankruptcy. And that's not the least of it. How many souls have been lost. How many? Apuron better be hoping for another dismissal. And in a much higher court.

Wednesday, May 7, 2025

LIES, LIES, LIES. STAGGERING LIES.

By Tim Rohr

Apuron's lies continue to be staggering. In today's PDN he is reported as saying:

"Today, I can speak freely, also about the canonical process," Apuron said. "The canonical process did not result in my laicization. No priest or bishop who has been found guilty of these crimes has remained a priest or bishop as I have. This indicates my innocence." 

The Holy See says differently:


In fact, Pope Francis himself found him guilty as the above statement was released after Francis personally heard Apuron's appeal. 

HE SURE LOOKS HEALTHY TO ME!

By Tim Rohr

Pacific Daily News Headlines:

Apuron breaks years of silence, reasserts innocence as his accusers seek dismissal of clergy sex abuse, defamation cases

Now WHY would his accusers "seek dismissal" of cases they so painfully brought into the light nearly ten years ago? 

I'm going to hazard a very good guess. But before I do that, here is the mind-boggling part of the PDN report:

Plaintiffs' counsel earlier filed in court that during a Zoom meeting, "Atty. Terlaje, on behalf of Apuron, made a settlement offer to the plaintiffs."

"Thereafter, the parties have been engaged in settlement discussions to resolve the dispute between them. The parties' settlement discussions are in line with what I recall and understood to be the Court's previous encouragement to the parties to consider resolution and the financial burden of continued litigation," the April 30 court filing stated.

Another April 30 filing stated that Apuron's counsel "made a settlement offer to Plaintiff."

Terlaje's statement, meanwhile, echoed Apuron's video message that he has never offered or entered into any settlement agreement with the plaintiffs, nor has he offered any money or other consideration to any plaintiff to resolve these cases.

"Archbishop Apuron has only asserted his willingness to execute a stipulation of dismissal to resolve the cases, as is required under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure...to dismiss any case at this stage of litigation," according to Terlaje's statement.

So we have, in the court record, a record, several records, of Apuron making "a settlement offer to plaintiffs." And we have, specifically on April 30, a record that Apuron's counsel (Jackie Terlaje) "made a settlement offer to Plaintiff."

But then today we have Apuron saying that he never offered to settle, and the same Jackie Terlaje backing up Apuron's denial of a settlement.  

The gobble-de-goop that catches my attention is this paragraph:

"Archbishop Apuron has only asserted his willingness to execute a stipulation of dismissal to resolve the cases, as is required under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure...to dismiss any case at this stage of litigation," according to Terlaje's statement.

So wait a minute. The headlines says that Plaintiffs are seeking the dismissal, but here it implies ("asserted his willingness to execute a stipulation of dismissal") that the stipulation was put forth by Apuron. 

And then there's the "as is required under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure." Huh? The Rules do not require the dismissal of a case - unless a deadline was missed or some other procedural thing. 

The most interesting thing here though are the words "at this stage of litigation." Interesting. Well, we're nearly ten years into this. Is the case too old to continue? 

Note: As far back as 2017, Apuron's counsel, Jackie Terlaje, was reported to have asked the court to for time to work on a settlement:

Apuron’s attorney, Jacqueline Terlaje, and attorneys representing the accusers asked Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood to delay her decision until Dec. 31 to give them time to work on a possible settlement. - USA Today, Nov. 15, 2017

Now, WHY would they be discussing "settlement" if Apuron was innocent?

Meanwhile, I'm not surprised. I expected something like this. And here's why. 

There's no money in it for the attorneys. Lujan and Wolff already made their money in the church bankruptcy case. And Terlaje was just fighting to protect her interests in the Neocatechumenal Way. 

Apuron had no personal assets. He did at one time. But as things began to heat up back around 2014 I noticed that he sold his home in Vegas, and then another home in California. And it appears that he got rid of his local property in Adacao in 2020 AFTER the cases were brought against him.

On January 16, 2020, a Special Power of Attorney was recorded showing Apuron giving Jackie Terlaje Special Power of Attorney to execute the sale of his property (Tract 1535, Lot 5-R3, Mangilao) on his behalf.


On the same day, a Warranty Deed for the Adacao property was executed by Apuron as Grantor and Raymond Benavente and Eleanor Bongato as Grantees. (Apuron sold the property to these two.)


On the same day, Benavente and Bongato recorded a mortgage on the property.


So Apuron, with his cases already in court and liable for millions of dollars, with the help of his attorney, sold his property.

And there is another interesting twist. Less than two months ago, Raymond Benavente quitclaimed his share of the property to Eleanor Bongato. I don't know if it's coincidence, but it is certainly interesting timing given today's news. 


Also very interesting. Throughout this nearly 10 year long ordeal, Apuron's counsel, Jackie Terlaje has been making excuse after excuse for Apuron claiming he's too old and sickly to even sit through a single deposition. 

However, from what we can see in the video he posted, Apuron, too sickly to sit through a deposition, has no problem spending quite a bit of time and energy proclaiming his innocence and mocking his accusers. 

He sure looks healthy to me. 

Bottom line is this though. Apuron ran. He ran. And he ran after only one accusation. That's not what an innocent man does. 

Apuron says he praying for his accusers. No thank you, Tony. You had better spend your time praying for your own lying soul...and your attorney's. 



Tuesday, May 6, 2025

WHY I DON'T CARE WHO THE NEXT POPE WILL BE

By Tim Rohr



Earl Nightingale used to tell the story of a father who was a worthless drunk who had two sons. When the two sons grew up, one became a worthless drunk like his father and the other never touched a drink and was prosperous. One day the two sons were asked why they had turned out like they did. They both had the same answer: "What would you expect with a father like mine?"

You might need to read that again. But in short, one son used his father's failure as an excuse to drink and the other used it as a reason not to. 

So it doesn't matter who the next "Papa" (Pope) is. Oh sure, it will matter to many, but it won't matter to me. Nor should it matter to you, at least not in the context of the larger picture as to where you want your immortal soul to spend eternity. 

Our hope is in Jesus, not a pope. Jesus promised that the gates of hell would not prevail against his Church, and that includes popes, pastors, and priests who raise hell. And besides, historically our Church does best when it's persecuted - even from within.

If we know our Faith, then nothing should surprise us, not even the demons within the heart of our Church - since that is where Jesus told us where we would find them: 

“When you see the desolating abomination spoken of through Daniel the prophet standing in the holy place (let the reader understand), then those in Judea must flee to the mountains, a person on the housetop must not go down to get things out of his house, a person in the field must not return to get his cloak. Woe to pregnant women and nursing mothers in those days. Pray that your flight not be in winter or on the sabbath, for at that time there will be great tribulation, such as has not been since the beginning of the world until now, nor ever will be. And if those days had not been shortened, no one would be saved; but for the sake of the elect they will be shortened." - Mt. 24:15-22

So let's be one of the "elect." And that doesn't depend on who is pope. The next pope may even be the "desolating abomination." 

+++++

As an aside, and for our reference, here are some solid teachings to keep in mind when we have bad leaders:

CATHOLIC OBEDIENCE MUST ALWAYS BE TO THE FAITH. 

Where there is a proximate danger to the faith, prelates must be rebuked, even publicly, by subjects. Thus, St. Paul, who was subject to St. Peter, rebuked him publicly.  - St. Thomas Aquinas, Commentary on the Epistle to the Galations 2:14 

When the Supreme Pontiff pronounces a sentence of excommunication which is unjust or null, it must not be accepted, without, however, straying from the respect due to the Holy See. - St. Robert Bellarmine 

All disciplinary authority, all obedience to a bishop presupposes the pure teaching of the Holy Church. Obedience to the bishop is grounded in complete faith in the teaching of the Holy Church. As soon as the ecclesiastical authority yields to pluralism in questions of faith, it has lost the right to claim obedience to its disciplinary ordinances. - Professor Dietrich von Hildebrand, The Devasted Vineyard (chicago 1973), pp 3-5 

Obedience to manifest error is sinful and the obligations to obey ceases once you are commanded to do some evil. Helping to destroy the Church in the name of "obedience" is also sinful. Blind obedience is not, and has never been Catholic (this is because true obedience can never conflicts with the will of God, namely that it can't contradict the Churches constant teaching). 

The history of the Church gives us several examples of saints who, in order to remain faithful, have resisted the Church authorities (and were even excommunicated ) who were wrong. Thus St. Godefrey of Amiens, St. Hughes of Grenoble and Guy of Vienne (who later became Pope Calixtus II ) wrote to Pope Pascal II who was wavering concerning "the investitures": "If, what we absolutely do not believe, you would choose another way and would - God forbid - refuse to confirm the decisions of our paternity , you would force us away from obeying you." (Bouix, Tract, de Papa, T. II, p. 650). 

We learn that St. Athanasius had to "disobey" Pope Liberius. But such apparent his "disobedience" was not real disobedience, but rather true obedience to the Church and it's constant teaching. 
In Summa Theologica, Q.33 Art 4, St. Thomas Aquinas makes it clear that we are bound to correct even his superior saying "if the faith is endangered a subject ought to rebuke his prelate even publicly. Hence Paul, who was Peter's subject, rebuked him in public, on account of the imminent danger of scandal concerning the faith, and, as the gloss of Augustine says on Gal. 2:11: "Peter gave an example to superiors that if at any time they should happen to stray from the straight path, they should not disdain to be reproved by their subjects". 

We become obedient to the Church and her officials only when we become obedient to the constant teaching of the church as taught by the Magisterium throughout the ages. If what is taught by an appointed servants of God (bishop, priest or Pope) is contrary to Catholic teaching then they are Not to be obeyed but even publicly rebuked (Titus 1:10) as they no longer speak on behalf of church but become representatives of their own novelty.

Monday, May 5, 2025

ON HOW THE TRANSITION FROM BYRNES TO JIMENEZ WAS NOT HANDLED AS IT SHOULD HAVE.

Posted By Frenchie






Starting with the 2020 Pandemic, it became slowly apparent to many observers that Archbishop Byrnes cognitive abilities were eroding fairly fast. I personally started noticing something was going awry during the Archbishop's homilies. As Byrnes had been a very proficient homilist, with short, to the point analysis of the scriptures and an easy lead into what it meant for us. He soon started forgetting what he had just talked about, or wandering without rime or reason from one subject to another. He even seemed lost during the celebration of the Eucharist.

By 2021 Archbishop Byrnes spent more and more time on the mainland for his health issues. His long and repeated absences created a noticeable vacuum of power in the Archdiocese, which led me to write an article about its consequences on September 21st, 2021. Specifically I called for decisions regarding the man who had filled said vacuum  with his own unbridled ambitions: Fr Ron Richards from the Archdiocese of Detroit. 



The problem at the time being his amassing of powers: Chancellor, Episcopal Vicar ( a rarely use title) Self appointed Canon Lawyer, Head of the Episcopal council, etc, etc.....

His tendency to make Back room deals with certain quarters, and not follow Canon Law. All the while leading a fairly disolutte and flamboyant  public life. Hardly the beacon of integrity you expect from the most powerful clergyman on island, in Byrnes absence. He also made a lot of questionable alliances with some members of Clergy that looked like there was a preferential set of personnel.


While Archbishop Byrnes had previously put in place his "Virtus" Safe environment program, to both prevent future sexual abuse, but also to handle any possible complaint still not yet addressed; this issue did not appear to be a high priority on Fr Richards agenda.

See Here

This issue, as well as its timing will be very relevant, to our current issues.

Fast Forward to 2022, knowing that his welcome on Guam had been wearing thin, and his self appointed mission of "handling" the bankruptcy of the Archdiocese accomplished (at least partially), Fr Richards rejoins the Archdiocese of Detroit on July 1st. Meanwhile the Archdiocese of Agana had reorganised and Fr Romeo Concovar ended becoming the new Vicar General. After Archbishop Byrnes resignation for health reasons, Fr Concovar's role would widen when he became in 2023 the Apostolic Administrator of the Archdiocese, (the de facto head of the Archdiocese) until the official nomination of Archbishop Jimenez in 2024 by Pope Francis.



So, why is it necessary to go back over these troubled years?

Going back to 2021 we were warned at the Junglewatch that there were still victims, filing testimonies, but no one was willing to verify who, whom, about what when and how. We heard for example that a woman had filed grave accusations against Msg Bibi, but the Chancery was not forthcoming about their discoveries and conclusions. By the same token there were contradicting reports about the measures taken by the Archbishop. After Byrnes returned to the mainland, the lead lid fell down on any kind of info, thanks to an obvious coverup by father Richards, with the collaboration to the infamous Tony Diaz. (the incarnation of passive aggressiveness)



There were also several rumors regarding personnel in or around the Cathedral, that were never confirmed or denied. With no witnesses willing to go on the record, or inside sources in the know able to do any clarification, it gave Fr Richards and most likely Fr Concovar an opportunity to sweep said rumors under the proverbial carpet.

What was even more frustrating is that some of the targets of said rumors were being very friendly with both Fr Richards and Fr Concovar. Which implied that the friendships were part of a good old boy network, in the Apuron old style of backroom deals and coverups.

Therefore we would have to be patient, and hope for the old Sicilian adage that :" if you are patient enough, you shall see the bodies of your enemies float by"

Fr Richards, according to the Archdiocese of Detroit is restricted and inactive.

Fr Concovar has been promoted to Bishop of Chalan Kanoa

Msg Bibi Arroyo is still incardinated, retired and officially restricted  in his priestly capabilities, restrictions he does not appear to abide to.

As for the other people implicated, so far they are still white as snow. It is rumored that the victim(s) might be running out of patience.

While Archbishop Jimenez has been off island in relation with his duties of President of the Pacific Conference of Catholic Bishops, he could be confronted by several dossiers upon his return that could be coming forward sooner than later, due to lack of answers the 2021 complaints failed to receive.



All this has the potential to become a time bomb, specially detrimental to the good work started during the different forum on Child Abuse Prevention launched last month. Was this an attempt to get in front of revelations of another scandal? Lets hope Archbishop Jimenez takes the Bull by the horns, and fulfill the engagements taken by Archbishop Byrnes and himself. Do not let the coverup of unscrupulous predecessors tarnish the image of the Archdiocese of Agana, the whole Clergy and the faithful.

IT'S BEEN ALMOST A DECADE AND DELAY, DELAY, DELAY

 Apuron offers settlement in clergy sex abuse cases, health woes postpone March-April deposition

(Pacific Daily News) 

Former Archbishop Anthony Apuron, through his attorney, “made a settlement offer” to plaintiffs in a handful of Guam clergy sex abuse and defamation cases, according to plaintiffs’ attorney, Delia Lujan Wolff. CONTINUED

Friday, May 2, 2025

FRANCIS THE CATASTROPHIC

 "The late Cardinal George Pell...described Francis’ papacy as ‘catastrophic’."

Many are crying "Santo Subito" (Make him a Saint, Now!) However, there is a reason why the late Cardinal Pell described Francis' papacy as "catastrophic." 

Pope Francis the Catastrophic

Thursday, May 1, 2025

DOES GOD ELECT THE POPE?

By Tim Rohr

Rodrigo Borgia/Pope Alexander VI


Back during the days of the Apuron Wars (2013-2018), his defenders claimed that we, the anti-Apuron people, were fighting against God because Apuron was God's choice to be Archbishop of Agana - or so they reasoned.

I suppose there could be some truth to their argument. 

After all, as we now know, the Archdiocese of Agana had been wallowing in sexual filth for decades, so they could be right given that God has often given his people the leaders they deserved (see the history of Israel).

By 1986, when Apuron ascended to his episcopal throne, and again, as we now know, not only had this diocese been trafficking in the bodies of hundreds if not thousands of boys, Guam's abortuaries were running full tilt, slaughtering an estimated 600 babies a year. (Senator Elizabeth Arriola's estimation in 1989).  

Given all the graces God had blessed Guam with for hundreds of years, it's quite possible that by 1986, God threw up his hands and said "Here, have it your way!" And gave us Apuron -  boy molester in-chief. 

After all, that's what Paul said God would do:

Therefore, God handed them over to impurity through the lusts of their hearts* for the mutual degradation of their bodies. They exchanged the truth of God for a lie and revered and worshiped the creature rather than the creator, who is blessed forever. Amen.

Therefore, God handed them over to degrading passions. Their females exchanged natural relations for unnatural, and the males likewise gave up natural relations with females and burned with lust for one another. Males did shameful things with males and thus received in their own persons the due penalty for their perversity.

And since they did not see fit to acknowledge God, God handed them over to their undiscerning mind to do what is improper. They are filled with every form of wickedness, evil, greed, and malice; full of envy, murder, rivalry, treachery, and spite. They are gossips and scandalmongers and they hate God. They are insolent, haughty, boastful, ingenious in their wickedness, and rebellious toward their parents.

They are senseless, faithless, heartless, ruthless. Although they know the just decree of God that all who practice such things deserve death, they not only do them but give approval to those who practice them. - Romans 1: 24-32

So, yah. You could definitely make a case for Apuron being God's choice. It wouldn't be the first time God punished his wayward people with a wicked leader. 

And there were plenty of wicked popes too. 

The nasty, corpulent, and lustful Rodrigo Borgia, aka Pope Alexander VI (1492-1503) usually heads the list of wicked popes, but there were many bad guys who sat in Peter's Chair who made a mess long before Francis ordered the kids at World Youth Day in 2013 to do it. 

One of my "favorite" periods in Church history is what has become known as the "Iron Age of the Papacy," the period between 872 and 965, a 94 year period during which there were no less than 24 popes, 7 of whom were assassinated:

• John VIII was bludgeoned to death by his own entourage, 

• Stephen VI strangled, 

• Leo V murdered by his successor Sergius III, 

• John X suffocated, 

• Stephen VIII horribly mutilated - having had his eyes gouged out and ears, nose, and hands cut off - died of his injuries, 

• Hadrian III poisoned, 

• and John XII beaten to death.

I wrote about this several years ago in a column for the Umatuna titled: THE STRANGE TRIAL OF THE GOOD LOOKING POPE.

And lest you think this was just medieval malfeasance, the suspicion that Pope John Paul I, who only reigned 33 days (in 1978), was poisoned, is still a conspiracy that is alive and circulating. 

In fact, while most believe that Pope Francis decision to reside in the Santa Marta guest house instead of the Apostolic Palace was an act of humility, the other story is that Francis was in fear for his life and believed he'd be killed in the Apostolic Palace. So he chose the guest house for security reasons. 

But back to the matter at hand. Is the pope chosen by God, or more specifically, by the Holy Spirit? 

I would answer "No." 

At the conclave, there is said to be as much politicking as there is prayer. If this were really just a meeting to find out who the Holy Spirit has chosen, then they wouldn't need to be in there for days, sometimes many days, and hold numerous votes. They'd just draw straws like the apostles did at the first "conclave:"

Then they prayed, “You, Lord, who know the hearts of all, show which one of these two you have chosen to take the place in this apostolic ministry from which Judas turned away to go to his own place.” Then they gave lots to them, and the lot fell upon Matthias, and he was counted with the eleven apostles. - Acts 1:24-26

Copying from Catholic.com:

When he was still a cardinal, back in 1997, Benedict XVI acknowledged that cardinals can elect sub-optimal popes. When asked on German television whether the Holy Spirit is responsible for the election of a pope, he said:

I would not say so, in the sense that the Holy Spirit picks out the pope. . . . I would say that the Spirit does not exactly take control of the affair, but rather like a good educator, as it were, leaves us much space, much freedom, without entirely abandoning us. Thus the Spirit’s role should be understood in a much more elastic sense, not that he dictates the candidate for whom one must vote. Probably the only assurance he offers is that the thing cannot be totally ruined.

He continued:

There are too many contrary instances of popes the Holy Spirit obviously would not have picked!

As for Francis, I believe the Holy Spirit did pick him, and picked him to punish a wayward and rebellious church. Today...

  • Only one in ten Catholics believe abortion is wrong in all cases.
  • Six-in-ten Catholics (61%) favor allowing gays and lesbians to marry.
  • Just 15% of Catholics say that using contraception is morally wrong.

- SOURCE 

Francis was certainly "the people's pope."