Tuesday, May 9, 2023

HAPPY (?) ANNIVERSARY TO "THE PILL"

By Tim Rohr

HISTORY.COM: On May 9, 1960, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approves the world’s first commercially produced birth-control pill—Enovid-10, made by the G.D. Searle Company of Chicago, Illinois. FULL ARTICLE

Aside from the moral controversy, there is the basic fact that "the pill" is not "medication." 

Medication is stuff you put into your body to fix something that is wrong with it. "The pill" is stuff a woman puts into her body to stop something that is right with it: ovulation. 

Medication is also something you stop taking once the problem is fixed. That's not what happens with "the pill." A woman wanting to avoid conception might ingest "the pill" for decades. 

It is hard to imagine anyone not asking the obvious: 

What are the consequences of chemically forcing your body to suppress something it is naturally designed to do (ovulate) and possibly for decades?

We don't hear about them much, or at all, but there are a ton of cases brought by women who have been harmed by "the pill." Here's a couple:

On July 24, 1976, after approximately three years of using the pills, MacDonald suffered an occlusion of a cerebral artery by a blood clot, an injury commonly referred to as a stroke. The injury caused the death of approximately twenty per cent of MacDonald's brain tissue, and left her permanently disabled.

MacDonald v. Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp., 394 Mass. 131, 134 (Mass. 1985)

On June 26, 1991, Ms. Gurski went to the Mercy Hospital in Springfield, Massachusetts, with severe abdominal pain. After an initial analysis, she was airlifted to Hartford Hospital where she underwent surgery for a ruptured hepatic adenoma (benign liver tumor). To control the hemorrhaging, a right hepatectomy was performed which resulted in the removal of sixty percent of her liver. On July 23, 1991, Ms. Gurski was released from the hospital only to be readmitted the next day due to an abscess around her liver. She was ultimately released on August 11, 1991 and to this day suffers permanent injuries.

Gurski v. Wyeth-Ayerst, 953 F. Supp. 412, 413-14 (D. Mass. 1997)

Note: In Gurski, the manufacturer of the drug, in part, lost its case because, as the court pointed out, the literature accompanying the drug downplayed the risks of liver tumors by repeatedly using the words "rare," "very rare," and "extremely rare." (Familiar words whenever we hear about the potential risks and harms of chemical contraception.)

Beyond the tragedy of damaged women and their ensuing legal battles, there is a whole genre of cases with an ironic twist: men suing women for not being on birth control and getting pregnant. Just google "man sues woman for not using birth control." 

It appears "the pill" liberated the wrong sex. 

SEN. FISHER MEETS WITH PRESIDENT OF CATHOLIC PRO-LIFE COMMITTEE

The following is an account of a meeting between Catholic Pro-Life Committee President Sharon O'Mallan and Senator Tom Fisher prior to the introduction of the Fisher-Barnes Abortion bill (Bill 106-37). Ms. O'Mallan has given her permission to publish her account. JW has redacted two names that are not relevant to the story.

+++++

I received a copy of the DRAFT proposed legislation with the names of Thomas Fisher, Chris Barnett and Tina Rose Muna Barnes.  At first glance it looks like it is a proposal for a referendum of the Abortion Law PL 20-134.  Upon closer look I noticed that it not only takes a vote BUT proposes a completely new and very abortion law to replace existing laws now.  

 The question is, “Shall the Health Protection Act of 2023, as recited herein and below, be enacted into Guam law?” After reading the new proposed Health Protection Act of 2023, I felt I needed to talk to our new senators to find out where they are in this new legislation and why they are writing it.  I left messages to meet with both Senators Barnett and Fisher.   I was given a meeting date with Tom Fisher for Friday, March 10, 2023 at 11:45a.m.

 On Thursday night March 9, 2023, Senator Chris Barnett calls me up and tells me that he is withdrawing his name on the legislation.   I wish I could take credit for this but he told me that Attorney XXX called him up the other night and gave him information on the draft bill and also an earful…   so he was going to remove his name.  He thought this bill was only a question regarding the referendum and didn’t know about the rest of the language.    

When I start recounting my meeting with Tom Fisher, I suspect I am going to forget some of the details of all that was said since the meeting was about 20 minutes long and I did not take notes or make a recording.  My companion xxx was my support/witness person.  After the meeting she told me that she couldn’t believe how I kept going and going by pressing the issues when he kept getting louder and louder and shouting at some points.  I said, I guess I didn’t realize it at the time even when he started hitting the desk towards the end.  I was trying my hardest to understand him as he constantly wouldn’t let me finish.

This is my summary of the meeting.   Tom Fisher says he wrote the legislation.  I tried to ask him why such an abortion minded bill when he stated that a woman has a right to an abortion and it’s nobody’s business.    I started trying to point out some of the parts of the law saying that if this passes it would replace all the good laws passed to protect both the woman and the baby.   I told him that abortion has never been illegal.   He said that it has been around since “ancient times” and was not a problem then.  I said, before ultrasound we could not really know what happened inside the womb and what happened during an abortion.  Now we know and we cannot go back to “ancient times”

I told him that if this bill passes then Partial Birth Abortion would be legal again.   The act of delivering a baby partially and leaving the head inside the birth canal and then sticking a sharp instrument up his head and scrambling his/her’s brains until he/she painfully dies!  He said, it’s the woman’s choice and it was none of our business.  

I said, your bill would make abortion legal up to right before the baby is born.   He said it’s the woman’s choice and none of our business.  

He questioned me about why I am doing this and I told him that in an abortion someone dies.   A little baby dies.   If the mother changes her mind the next day, it’s too late because she can’t go back and bring her dead baby back to life.   I told him I want to stop this tragedy before the baby dies and the mother is forever suffering from this.   He told me that I should mind my own business and the mother will be fine.

I told him that this law would remove the parents consent rights and minors could have abortion without their knowledge.   He said GOOD because then those parents won’t force their kids to stay pregnant.  He said that if minors want an abortion they should be allowed to have an abortion!

I told him that this law would remove the abortion reporting law.  He said GOOD because it’s none of our business.   I told him that these laws are meant to get statistical information and also for the safety of the woman.   I told him this law provides for Complication Abortion Reporting.   I showed him the 2022 report where there was a complication reported.  He turned around and tried to make it look like the doctor had broken HIPPA laws.   I told him the doctor didn’t break HIPPA law!   He asked me how I knew about the complication?  I told him from the report!!!   How did I get the report?   I said from Public Health!!!   It’s the law!!!  He kept trying to twist it all around saying there was broken HIPPA law from the doctor which I told him I never met and if he reads the report he can see that the doctor was only following the law.  (later on I felt like telling him to do his own FOIA with public health to get the abortion reports!!!.  It was a lot of work to get Abortion Reporting back on track and it is suspected that a lot of doctors are still not reporting. )  

I brought up to him the part of the proposed legislation where he claims that abortion services has been obstructed across the United States and Guam in various ways, including blockages of health care facilities, and associated violence.    I asked him WHAT? WHERE? WHEN? Did this happen on Guam???    He said that YOU PEOPLE HOLDING UP YOUR ROSARIES IN FRONT OF AN ABORTION CLINIC!!!   He said if a woman was coming to get an abortion and came up to the clinic with people holding rosaries and praying, that is VERY INTIMIDATING AND VIOLENT!!!   She would be afraid to proceed and that would delay her abortion.  (Can I mention here at this point he was holding his hand up as if holding a rosary.   Yep… and his voice was elevated.   Yep, us rosary wielding violent people…)  I told him we were praying for conversion and change of heart.   He said…. IT’S NONE OF OUR BUSINESS.

I then tried to bring up that we are trying our hardest to help these women by making sure there are services available to help them.   I also told him that our Catholic Pro-Life Committee is also offering Rachel’s Vineyard Retreats which is post-abortive healing.   He blew up here in a shouted disbelieving laugh-- shouting…. “SO YOU ARE THE ONES BRINGING THAT CRAP HERE!!!”   Then he went into this whole spill about us trying to remind woman of their abortions and dragging them through it again…. Then he BANGED his hand on the table saying “I SHOULD NAME THIS BILL THE MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS BILL”  

 At different times during the meeting which lasted about 20 minutes, he kept saying that we are very judgmental people.   I kept telling him that we are not.  We are not judging anyone about their abortion, we are trying to stop it before it happens to save the babies life as well as the mother’s well being for the rest of her life.  

Can I add… I told him I now have to add him to my prayer list for his conversion.   He said…”put me on your list!”  with a straight forward sneer on his face.   My long list…

   

Sunday, May 7, 2023

THE REST OF THE STORY...

By Tim Rohr

Monday is May 8. Five years ago, this day was the last day of my life - at least the one I still had control of.

Even though tragedy had struck myself and my family nearly one year earlier, I still, up until May 9, 2018, had been working with hope to heal the problem. 

But what happened on May 9, 2018, changed everything. 

I've waited five years to tell what happened on that day, and have waited this long because I didn't know how to tell it without further hurting my family. 

However, it's important that the story be known, not because I want to be exonerated (I could care less at this point), but because the evil behind the whole thing is still here - and it's growing.

In researching my archives for how to tell this story, I came across a radio interview with myself and Patti Arroyo on "the day after" (May 10, 2018). 

I'll share the interview and come back later to tell more of the story. 

Note: The above picture of Pope Francis and the newly-bearded Anthony Apuron is sourced from this story by the Catholic News Agency which reports:

The archbishop claimed that this climate of fear and its publicity in the local media hampered the work of the Vatican court in its conviction and "testifies to the presence of a pressure group that plotted to destroy me, and which has made itself clearly known even to authorities in Rome."

I (Tim Rohr) am that "pressure group."

Meanwhile, Apuron compares himself to Christ on the Cross:

I offer my suffering to my accusers and to those who have plotted for my removal: may the Lord fill them with everything they want and pray - Father, forgive them for they do not know what they do."

FISHER AND BARNES DO NOT WANT TO CODIFY ROE AND CASEY. THEY WANT MUCH MORE.

By Tim Rohr

Following are some thoughts and questions relative to the article titled "'Be prepared': Bill 106 would let voters decide on abortion" as published in the Guam Daily Post on May 2, 2023. 

I.

Bill 106-37 was recently introduced by Senators Tom Fisher and Tina Muna-Barnes. Since the effect of their bill is to send the abortion issue directly to the voters, the senators have nicknamed their bill "The You Decide Bill." 

Given the nickname, voters may think that they are voting for or against abortion. They are not. Assuming that the Fisher-Barnes bill gets through the legislature and is enacted into law, voters will vote directly on what Fisher and Barnes have titled THE HEALTH PROTECTION ACT OF 2023 ("The ACT"). 

If The ACT passes, then abortion is legal in Guam. If The ACT doesn't pass, then abortion is legal in Guam - since it already is. The only difference is The ACT will strip away Guam's few existing abortion regulations, which are not enforced nor policed anyway. So there is really nothing for the voter to decide. 

II.

Then, of course, there is the matter of the false name of The ACT. It would have been nice if its sponsors had titled their legislation what it really is THE ABORTION PROTECTION ACT OF 2023, or if that's a little too truthful then maybe a title with the words "reproductive rights" in it - even if the object of The ACT is to terminate reproduction and not protect it. 

There's still time to fix it. And this is where our "pro-life" senators can step up. They won't have the votes to sink this ACT altogether, nor the same ACT as introduced by Senator Will Parkinson (Bill 111-37), however they can move to amend the name to call it what it is. 

Such a move will provoke immediate objections from the pro-aborts and this is what we want. We already know who is pro-abortion and who isn't. But it would be even more telling to see which senators want to hide the true intent of the legislation behind a completely false title. For if abortion is really healthcare, which they tell us it is over and over, then why not happily and proudly stand by the word "abortion?" Of course, we know why.

III.

The Post story reports:

He said it wasn't easy concluding that the public should be the ones to decide the abortion issue, but added that it felt necessary, as the Guam Legislature has not proven itself to be "particularly adept at resolving the question of reproductive health or abortion rights."

Beyond Fisher's beating up on his colleagues, the Guam Legislature has not HAD the opportunity to prove itself "adept at resolving the question of reproductive health or abortion rights" since no abortion legislation has come before the Legislature since the issue, via Dobbs, was returned to state legislatures, including Guam's. 

If Fisher is referring to pre-Dobbs legislation, then the Guam Legislature has proved itself to be very "adept" at handling the question because those measures were thoroughly vetted, passed, and enacted into law because not only were they constitutionally compliant, they were common sense and humane. They are as follows:

  1. Parental consent for minors for abortion
  2. Informed consent for women seeking abortion
  3. An abortion reporting requirement
  4. A ban on partial-birth abortion (a procedure in which a child, already fully delivered except for her head, is stabbed in the base of her skull whereupon her brains are scrambled and her skull is crushed and then fully delivered). 
  5. A requirement to provide normal medical care for children who survive a failed abortion

If Fisher and Barnes have their way, then all of the above will go away:

If approved by voters, the Health Protection Act would supersede existing abortion laws on Guam, according to Fisher.

IV.

The Post reports:

...the Health Protection Act allows the health care provider to determine viability - the point in which a fetus can survive outside the womb with or without support - and prohibits limitations or restriction to abortions prior to fetal viability. 

Roe set "viability" at 28 weeks. Twenty years later, the Court in Casey acknowledged that new technologies had moved "viability"  to as few as "23 or 24 weeks." And now, more than three decades after Casey, "preemies" are surviving and thriving outside the womb at 21 weeks.


A baby born at 21 weeks gestation in Alabama last year is the most premature baby in the world to survive, according to Guinness World Records. - SOURCE
The Fisher-Barnes bill removes the scientific and legislative determination of viability and simply leaves it to the "provider to determine viability," a provider who is being paid to deliver a dead child, not a live one. 

V.

The Post reports:

The senator stated that the public would essentially decide on whether to codify a version of Roe v. Wade and Casey v. Planned Parenthood, the landmark cases that once protected the right to an abortion in the United States.

Fisher contradicts himself. Casey upheld parental consent for minors, informed consent for women, waiting periods, and reasonable reporting requirements, all of which are current laws in Guam. Fisher himself says that all of these will go away:

If approved by voters, the Health Protection Act would supersede existing abortion laws on Guam, according to Fisher.

Fisher and Barnes do not want to codify Roe and Casey. They want absolute, unrestricted, and unaccountable freedom to abort. Given what Fisher and Barnes really want, they should be thankful for Dobbs which got rid of Roe and Casey and gave the ultimate power to abort to people like Fisher and Barnes. 

VI.

The Post reports:

He went on to discuss how the Dobbs decision may also put case law protecting interracial marriage in danger because it was founded in the Fourteenth Amendment, like abortion had been. 

Fisher is stretching the intelligence of his listeners here. But rather than refute Fisher, I'll let Justice Alito do it:

...the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment...has been held to guarantee some rights that are not mentioned in the Constitution, but any such right must be “deeply rooted in this Nation’s history and tradition” and “implicit in the concept of ordered liberty.”

The right to abortion does not fall within this category...The abortion right is also critically different from any other right that this Court has held to fall within the Fourteenth Amendment’s protection of “liberty.” Roe’s defenders characterize the abortion right as similar to the rights recognized in past decisions involving matters such as intimate sexual relations, contraception, and marriage, but abortion is fundamentally different, as both Roe and Casey acknowledged, because it destroys what those decisions called “fetal life” and what the law now before us describes as an “unborn human being.”


Friday, May 5, 2023

THIS IS AN IMPORTANT QUESTION

Can I Become a Priest, If I Have an Illegitimate Child?

And the answer goes well beyond the question, which makes the answer even more important. 

Here's part of the answer:

The question that a bishop or religious superior will have to ask is, is a prospective priest’s past life so problematic that it will create difficulties for him (and for the diocese or religious institute) if he becomes a priest? And will it cause scandal, or at least confusion, among the faithful to whom he is expected to minister?

FULL ARTICLE HERE


THE WAR ON FATHERS

The destruction of the family was the unapologetic aim of Karl Marx. 

Given that the family is the essential cell of society, Marx could never attain his Utopia so long as the family remained the center of society and not the state. 

Marx may be dead but his crusade isn't. In fact, it is probably more alive and mobilized today than ever. 

Many would agree that there is no question that the family is being attacked by abortion, the redefinition of marriage, no-fault divorce, etc., but few are aware of how our child support regimes are the real new home of Marxism in America. 

Marx knew that the shortest path to getting rid of the family was getting rid of fathers. And there is no more powerful and effective tool to destroy fathers than our child support laws...which are not about child "support" at all, but about removing fathers so "the village" can raise our children. 

I'll have more to say about this another time. Meanwhile, I'll share this from Stephen Baskerville's book:  TAKEN INTO CUSTODY: The War Against Fathers, Marriage, and the Family, pg. 112. 

+++++

...the new politics of child support is plagued by the same fundamental contradictions as child custody. Like custody, it is awarded ostensibly without reference to "fault," and yet disobedience brings swift and severe punishments. Contrary to popular belief (and centuries of common-law precedent), child support today has nothing to do with fathers abandoning their children, reneging on their marital vows, or even agreeing to a divorce. It is automatically assessed on non-custodial parents, even those divorced over their objections and who lose their children through no legal fault or agreement of their own. It is an entitlement, in other words, for all divorcing mothers and one coerced not from taxpayers (though they pay too) but directly from involuntarily divorced spouses. A legally unimpeachable parent minding his own business can lose not only his children but his property and earnings and can be incarcerated without trial through "no fault" of his own.

Like custody, in other words, child support has nothing to do with justice. On the other hand, it is a punitive measure, enforced with police, courts, and incarceration, plus a growing panoply of unusual punishments. It is Western society's most advanced measure yet to institutionalize the Marxist principle, "from each according to his ability, to each according to her need."

Thursday, May 4, 2023

THE FIRST SOUL AT RISK IS THE PASTOR'S

By Tim Rohr

The abortion issue is ramping up quickly in Guam. 

In addition to AG Moylan's efforts to lift the injunction on the 1990 "Belle's Law" and the ACLU suit over the in-person requirement relative to the law requiring informed consent for abortion, there are now two new bills aimed at radically legalizing abortion (Bills 106-37 and 111-37). 

And then on top of that, Lt. Governor Tenorio has just signed on to a national statement defending access to the chemical baby killer - Mifepristone. 

Note: News stories, including the one just referenced, refer to Mifepristone as "medication." Medication is stuff that supports life. Mifepristone is stuff that supports death. Calling a baby-killing drug "medication" is like the Nazi's telling six million Jews they were just going to take a shower.

Today, on the Ray Gibson show, towards the end somewhere, a woman caller protested the Lt. Gov's signing Guam onto the aforesaid statement. She argued that there are many Catholics and Christians who don't support abortion. I always cringe when I hear that argument because that's exactly what the pro-aborts want us to do: make it about religion. 

It ain't about religion. It's first about the demonstrable scientific fact that abortion kills an innocent, helpless, defenseless human being whose screams while being chopped to pieces we can't even hear. And second, it's about whether we, as a society, are just fine with that.

Ray challenged the caller with something to the effect that these religious groups better get off their $#!& and start doing something to stop the mounting avalanche of baby-killing moves by the people we elected. And doing the wave on Marine Corps Drive once a year is probably not what Ray had in mind.

Truth be told, I'm not optimistic that any church will stand up to the pro-aborts. The caller said something about how Catholics are against abortion. On paper, yes. But not in practice. For decades the majority of abortions were obtained by women (there, I said it) identifying their ethnicity as CHamoru (previously Chamorro). Historically, ethnically, culturally...whatever, that means the majority of abortions were procured by Catholics. 

Moreover, the most virulent pro-aborts are Catholics. And I don't mean just in Guam where the leading pro-aborts, LLG, Josh Tenorio, and Jayne Flores, are all Catholics (and apparently now Sen. Barnes given her sponsorship, if not authorship, of the meanest baby-killing legislation every seen in Guam - The Health Protection Act of 2023 *), I mean Joe Biden, Nancy Pelosi, John Kerry, Ted Kennedy, and the list goes on. And it's a long list. 

* The Health Protection Act of 2023 is set out in both the afore-referenced bills: 106-37 and 111-37.

What we don't know is if they'll go to hell or not. Of course we don't and it's not for us to know. But what we do know is that their pastors have a grave moral duty to confront them. Out of charity, the first confrontation should be private. However, should the offenders persist publicly in their baby-killing efforts, then pastors have a serious moral duty to the rest of us to call them out publicly. 

In short, the first soul at risk is the pastor's. 

Lest any Catholic pastor be unclear on the matter, they (and we) would do well to study what then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (later Pope Benedict XVI) wrote, personally, in English, and to the U.S. Catholic bishops in 2004 when the communion-going pro-abortion Catholic, John Kerry, was a presidential contender. 


Worthiness to Receive Holy Communion. General Principles

by Joseph Ratzinger

1. Presenting oneself to receive Holy Communion should be a conscious decision, based on a reasoned judgement regarding one's worthiness to do so, according to the Church's objective criteria, asking such questions as: "Am I in full communion with the Catholic Church? Am I guilty of grave sin? Have I incurred a penalty (e.g. excommunication, interdict) that forbids me to receive Holy Communion? Have I prepared myself by fasting for at least an hour?" The practice of indiscriminately presenting oneself to receive Holy Communion, merely as a consequence of being present at Mass, is an abuse that must be corrected (cf. Instruction "Redemptionis Sacramentum," nos. 81, 83).

2. The Church teaches that abortion or euthanasia is a grave sin. The Encyclical Letter Evangelium vitae, with reference to judicial decisions or civil laws that authorise or promote abortion or euthanasia, states that there is a "grave and clear obligation to oppose them by conscientious objection. [...] In the case of an intrinsically unjust law, such as a law permitting abortion or euthanasia, it is therefore never licit to obey it, or to 'take part in a propaganda campaign in favour of such a law or vote for it'" (no. 73). Christians have a "grave obligation of conscience not to cooperate formally in practices which, even if permitted by civil legislation, are contrary to God's law. Indeed, from the moral standpoint, it is never licit to cooperate formally in evil. [...] This cooperation can never be justified either by invoking respect for the freedom of others or by appealing to the fact that civil law permits it or requires it" (no. 74).

3. Not all moral issues have the same moral weight as abortion and euthanasia. For example, if a Catholic were to be at odds with the Holy Father on the application of capital punishment or on the decision to wage war, he would not for that reason be considered unworthy to present himself to receive Holy Communion. While the Church exhorts civil authorities to seek peace, not war, and to exercise discretion and mercy in imposing punishment on criminals, it may still be permissible to take up arms to repel an aggressor or to have recourse to capital punishment. There may be a legitimate diversity of opinion even among Catholics about waging war and applying the death penalty, but not however with regard to abortion and euthanasia.

4. Apart from an individuals's judgement about his worthiness to present himself to receive the Holy Eucharist, the minister of Holy Communion may find himself in the situation where he must refuse to distribute Holy Communion to someone, such as in cases of a declared excommunication, a declared interdict, or an obstinate persistence in manifest grave sin (cf. can. 915).

5. Regarding the grave sin of abortion or euthanasia, when a person's formal cooperation becomes manifest (understood, in the case of a Catholic politician, as his consistently campaigning and voting for permissive abortion and euthanasia laws), his Pastor should meet with him, instructing him about the Church's teaching, informing him that he is not to present himself for Holy Communion until he brings to an end the objective situation of sin, and warning him that he will otherwise be denied the Eucharist.

6. When "these precautionary measures have not had their effect or in which they were not possible," and the person in question, with obstinate persistence, still presents himself to receive the Holy Eucharist, "the minister of Holy Communion must refuse to distribute it" (cf. Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts Declaration "Holy Communion and Divorced, Civilly Remarried Catholics" [2000], nos. 3-4). This decision, properly speaking, is not a sanction or a penalty. Nor is the minister of Holy Communion passing judgement on the person's subjective guilt, but rather is reacting to the person's public unworthiness to receive Holy Communion due to an objective situation of sin.

[N.B. A Catholic would be guilty of formal cooperation in evil, and so unworthy to present himself for Holy Communion, if he were to deliberately vote for a candidate precisely because of the candidate's permissive stand on abortion and/or euthanasia. When a Catholic does not share a candidate's stand in favour of abortion and/or euthanasia, but votes for that candidate for other reasons, it is considered remote material cooperation, which can be permitted in the presence of proportionate reasons.]

SOURCE

Wednesday, May 3, 2023

I'M NOT "PRO-LIFE" SO F THAT

By Tim Rohr

Partial-Birth Abortion
Somewhere soon after Ray initiated his interview with Senator Tom Fisher this past Monday on the Ray Gibson show (about 1:49:00), Fisher brought up "Tim Rohr" and "JungleWatch." 

Ray immediately chimed in, saying that he knew me well and that I was "pro-life," or something like that. 

Thanks Ray. Yah. I am. But not really. And I want to qualify that. So thanks for the opportunity. 

I'm not "pro-life." 

Anti-war and anti-death penalty lib types are "pro-life." 

My position is that I just don't like bad guys, especially bad guys who hurt the innocent and helpless, be they puppies, full-grown dogs, three-year old children, helpless old people, Polish dissidents, or Anne Frank. 

In fact, I hate that lobsters and crabs, still living, are chopped up and cooked and burned to death on Teppanyaki grills while their eaters drool. 

F that. 

And I hate that "we" are okay with "children, still living, being chopped up and cooked" (see abortion by saline) and under such a name as Sens. Fisher and Barnes' HEALTH PROTECTION ACT OF 2023 - an f-ing euphemism only approximated by the Nazi's employment  of the "Final Solution."

Yah. F - Final Solution - that.

Your Friend, Tim

I AGREE WITH JAYNE. MEANWHILE, GET OUT THERE AND KILL THOSE BABIES!

By Tim Rohr

Geez. This is getting dangerous. 

A couple days ago I agreed with Atty. Vanessa Williams and now I have to agree with (next to the governor) the most virulent proponent of abortion in Guam, if not in the whole history of Guam, the Director of the Bureau of Women's Affairs, Jayne Flores. 

I mean, seriously, Jayne even went so far as get us to sue us. See: THE TELL-TALE TIMELINE & THE WIZARD BEHIND THE CURTAIN

But Jayne is right, at least in this:

"She adds the bill is unnecessary as abortion is legal under Guam law." - KUAM, May 1, 2023

She's absolutely right. Abortion is presently completely legal in Guam save for a few legal limitations that nobody enforces anyway: a partial-birth abortion ban, parental consent for minors, informed consent for women seeking to abort, and a reporting requirement.

So "nobody needed to do nothin'." So what's up with Fisher (and Barnes)?

In his defense, and probably not expecting to be attacked by "people with uteruses," especially the most virulent, aggressive, and public proponents of abortion in Guam (Vanessa and Jayne), the same KUAM story reports:

"But Fisher said the statute only provides for a limited right to abortion, arguing that his bill is essential."

Let's back up a bit. 

First, the whole ACLU lawsuit thing with the two doctors in Hawaii recruited by Jayne to sue us would be moot if we could just get one of the already very vocal pro-abort docs here in Guam to actually do the thing. 

The real story is not only that they (local pro-abort docs) won't do the thing, but WHY they won't do the thing. And no one seems to want to pursue the obvious. 

Fisher and his fellow pro-aborts argue that abortion is healthcare and that abortion is an essential service. However, abortion is already fully legal here - save for the few regulations already mentioned and which are never enforced anyway - so the real question is WHO is denying these poor women their "essential" healthcare services?

Fisher and his pro-abort cronies want us to believe that the villains (and the reason we need the Fisher-Barnes legislation) are a couple of old ladies with rosaries who stand on a sidewalk for a whole sixty minutes every weekend or so.

OH SO SCARY!

Fisher isn't alone. Dr. Ellen Bez and a few other pro-abort physicians, while publicly advocating for a woman's right to kill her child, have continually hidden their unwillingness to actually kill the child behind the laughable pretense of some sort of local anti-abortion stigma, i.e. "the Catholic Church." (References to Bez in this blog: here, here, and here.)

Okay, not all are ladies and not all are old. But Fisher et. al need said rosary-wielding "old ladies" as weaponized straw-women because they don't want to get to the bottom of the thing which is this: no one in Guam with an M.D. after his or her name wants to cut up little children and throw their body parts into waste buckets - like Drs. Freeman and Griley were happy to do for many years...and for a fee of course.

I specifically note Freeman and Griley, because for the better part of the last 30 years, and up until 2018, they were the only "doctors" who openly advertised for and engaged in that bloody business. And now that both have closed up shop, the local pro-abort docs and their political bedmates need someone and something else to hide behind. So it's old ladies with rosaries. 

Geez. 

Cowards. Get out there and kill those babies, even if most of them are CHamoru's. Jayne will help. 


See: ABORTION ON GUAM BY THE NUMBERS: 2008 - 2018


Note: It wasn't "old ladies." And it still isn't.


Anti-Baby-Killer-Protestors stand outside Dr. Griley's abortion clinic in Tamuning in 2012. Six years later there would be no abortions in Guam...until LLG and Jayne. 

SENATOR TOM FISHER ON THE RAY GIBSON SHOW - MAY 1, 2023

By Tim Rohr


On this past Monday's Ray Gibson show, Ray invited Sen. Tom Fisher into the studio to discuss Fisher's Bill 106-37 which calls for a referendum on new abortion legislation - also written by Fisher - "to allow health care providers to provide abortion services without limitations..." 

Ray's interview with Fisher begins at about 1:49:00 into the show and a few things caught my attention to which I shall respond.

+++++

FISHER: "I understand the abortion question….but that is not the question here today. We are going to fulfill our responsibility under Dobbs."

MY COMMENTS:

What "responsibility" is that?

Abortion is already fully legal in Guam save for a very few limitations: no partial-birth abortion, parental consent for minors, informed consent for women seeking to abort, and a reporting requirement. 

Fisher's bill seeks to remove these limitations, all of which were constitutionally compliant under Roe and Casey, and had nothing to do with Dobbs. 

Since Fisher laments Dobbs and celebrates Roe and Casey, then that's what we already have in Guam: the freedom to abort pursuant to Roe and Casey. There is no further "responsibility" under Dobbs, unless of course Fisher and Barnes (sponsors) want to drive a final death stake through a still beating heart. 

By the way, if Fisher doesn't like the current limitations on abortion, then his issue is with Casey, not Dobbs. It was Casey which opened the door for common sense limitations on abortion like parental and informed consent and abortion reporting:

Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pa. v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833 (1992)

Re parental consent for minors:

This conclusion is in no way inconsistent with our decisions upholding parental notification or consent requirements. ... Those enactments, and our judgment that they are constitutional, are based on the quite reasonable assumption that minors will benefit from consultation with their parents and that children will often not realize that their parents have their best interests at heart. 

Re Informed Consent for the woman seeking to abort:

We are left with the argument that the various aspects of the informed consent requirement are unconstitutional because they place barriers in the way of abortion on demand. Even the broadest reading of Roe, however, has not suggested that there is a constitutional right to abortion on demand. ... Rather, the right protected by Roe is a right to decide to terminate a pregnancy free of undue interference by the State. Because the informed consent requirement facilitates the wise exercise of that right, it cannot be classified as an interference with the right Roe protects. The informed consent requirement is not an undue burden on that right.

Re abortion reporting:

The collection of information with respect to actual patients is a vital element of medical research, and so it cannot be said that the requirements serve no purpose other than to make abortions more difficult. Nor do we find that the requirements impose a substantial obstacle to a woman's choice. At most they might increase the cost of some abortions by a slight amount. While at some point increased cost could become a substantial obstacle, there is no such showing on the record before us.


FISHER: "… this submission is not an unlimited right to an abortion. It’s up to fetal viability, of course it’s up to fetal viability because the state then has an obvious interest in that." 

MY COMMENTS:

Fisher, in an apparent effort to sound reasonable and credible, is using the language of Roe which emphasized the state's interest in protecting what Roe called "potential life" after the first trimester:

(b) For the stage subsequent to approximately the end of the first trimester, the State, in promoting its interest in the health of the mother, may, if it chooses, regulate the abortion procedure in ways that are reasonably related to maternal health.

(c) For the stage subsequent to viability, the State in promoting its interest in the potentiality of human life may, if it chooses, regulate, and even proscribe, abortion except where it is necessary, in appropriate medical judgment, for the preservation of the life or health of the mother.

Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973) at XI

However, Fisher misleads. Fisher makes no mention of the state's "obvious interest in that" in his bill. In fact, Fisher leaves the decision to abort the child "after viability" completely up to the "health care provider" who is being paid to deliver a dead child, not a live one:

91B] 04. Permitted Services.

(a) General Rule. A health care provider has a statutory right under this Actto provide abortion services, and may provide abortion services, and that provider's patient has a  corresponding right to receive such services, without any of the following limitations or requirements:

(9) A prohibition on abortion after fetal viability when, in the good-faith medical judgment of the treating health care provider, continuation of the pregnancy would pose a risk to the pregnant patient's life or health.

 

GUAM'S UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE ACT 

At about 1:53:00 Ray asks:  

"How would it be handled in a criminal case if somebody attacked a pregnant woman at which point in a situation like that would it be considered an attack on the woman and the baby?"

FISHER: "Unclear. Most jurisdictions that have faced the issue have actually addressed it. If a mother for example is quickening and she is killed and the fetus dies then some states have actual statutes that provide for an additional charge of murder manslaughter whatever that is." 

RAY: "We do here." 

FISHER: "We do? Well, okay, well that answers your question then, right?"

RAY: "I don’t know when the viability kicks in on that, it might be just a blanket she’s pregnant and you took two lives and that’s all there is to it." 

Ray may be excused for not knowing the particulars of Guam's UNBORN VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE ACT, but at least he knew the ACT exists. 

Apparently Senator Fisher did not. 

For the education of us all, said ACT does not address the moving target of viability. The ACT simply criminalizes any attack on the mother which harms or kills the "unborn child," who, according to the ACT is legally NOT a "fetus," as Fisher insists on calling the unborn child:

9 G.C.A. § 17.03. Definitions.

For the purposes of this Chapter, the following terms are defined to mean:

(b) unborn child shall mean a child in utero, and the term “child in utero” or “child, who is in utero” means a member of the species homo sapiens, at any stage of development, who is carried in the womb.

 

A PERSONAL NOTE

I don't know Senator Fisher. I never met him or interacted with him directly in any way. As a candidate, he presented himself as reasonable, knowledgeable, and credible. So I voted for him. Senator Fisher has every right to introduce whatever legislation he wants and to take any position he wants. I am tempted to advise him, though, not to mislead or lie. However, following such advice could be political suicide. Misleading and lying has worked so well for so many of his colleagues for so very long. In fact, even when they get caught and get voted out, they get voted in again the next time around. So carry on Mr. Fisher. Meanwhile, this referendum, if it becomes a referendum, will not be a referendum on abortion, it will be a referendum on the hearts and minds of the voters of Guam. 

Monday, May 1, 2023

HAPPY BIRTHDAY MICHELLE

Last year I shared this Happy Birthday story for my eldest daughter, Michelle, via Facebook. This year I'd like to share it here with JungleWatchers. 

I haven't seen Michelle in awhile and differences have crept up between us. But sometimes that's a good thing or else we parents will cling too long and hold our children back. At least I know I would have. So happy birthday Michelle. Here's my story. 

+++++

Michelle was our second child, a daughter after a son. And like many modern parents, my thinking at the time was “two is enough.” And since we had a boy and a girl, it seemed like Michelle was a perfect place to stop. As it turned out, God had other plans.

For the first several years of family life, things were smooth. Guam was in an economic boom and we were riding the wave like a lot of other people. So finding that we were expecting another child, and then another, and then another…all the way to number 7 in 1997 was not a big deal.

But in 1997, and with child number 7, things in Guam were in for a big change.

The Japanese investment bubble (late 80’s to early 90’s) had already burst and Guam had begun to feel the hit. At the same time President Clinton decided Guam didn't need all of our military bases and Guam really felt the negative economic impact with both base closures and major military downsizing.

As the bases closed and Guam's economy sank, our business sank along with it and we lost about 75% of our income between 1997 and 2001. And then 9/11 pretty much wiped us out altogether just as we birthed our 9th child (Dominic).

By then, many people in Guam had begun relocating to the states. But we stayed. I don’t remember why. We were in danger of losing everything and the future looked bleak for a long time to come. And by 2004 we were really in trouble.

My wife and I had been burning the candle at both ends to feed our family, which by then numbered 11 of us (parents and children) but things weren’t getting any better.

Meanwhile, we had lost our health insurance due to weird complications of my going back to work as a teacher for awhile. And then we found out we were expecting — once again.

I know, I know. Birth control and all that. But No. 10 turned out to be William. And what would I do without him today. William had trouble being born and his birth complications set us back nearly 100k and we had no insurance. It was an unbelievable time.

But this is when Michelle, at that time age 16, really showed herself to be a blessing to our family.

There is not the space to tell all she did. You’ll have to wait for the book for that. So I’ll just tell you the one thing that stands out most in my memory.

In order to survive, our family did many things. One of those things was to begin a business selling Catholic books. Many remember our days as a retail store in shopping malls and commercial spaces, but we began that business by selling books after Masses on Sunday at different parishes.

In order to have our tables and books set up before the first Mass on Sundays, we had to be ready by 6am.

Michelle was the only child really able to help me. (Timmy, our eldest, had a job working at the ship repair facility.) So I had to get Michelle out of bed at 4am, load hundreds of books into our vehicle, tie tables onto the top, and drive off before sunrise to whatever church was on schedule for that Sunday.

We worked like crazy to set up the displays before the first Mass let out. I was usually a stressed out mess, finding a location that would avoid the usual rain, making sure we had enough change in the cash box, seeing to the receipt books, making sure we had enough tarps to cover the tables when the rain came, etc.

Meanwhile, Michelle calmly took over, beautifully arranged the books, and most importantly, professionally engaged the customers in a way I never could. (All my children possessed a calm that I never had.) Sometimes we would stay all day in order to catch the Sunday night Masses. Making it a 16 hour day sometimes.

And then when we got home, we would have to spend another couple of hours, doing inventory and reconciling the receipts.

It was very hard. And I remember losing my temper a couple times - maybe many times - due to all that stress. But Michelle never lost her calm, even when she was clearly and rightly angry with me.

That little book business was the difference between us losing our home and keeping it. Later, when we began our retail outlet in the Agana Shopping Center, Michelle figured out all the displays and ran the register and customer service on most days.

She did much more than that, including running our cafe (The Basilica Cafe) at the Cathedral, but that would take even more space to write about. I think I have a picture of her taking a break. Here it is:

In short, Michelle gave her life for our family, especially after we found out we were expecting number 11 (Gianna), and Michelle, away at college in the states at the time, gave up her education to come home to help…once again.

Today, Michelle is one of the most successful people I know, even though, or maybe because, she always put herself second. 

Happy Birthday Michelle.

Sincerely, Dad.

NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS?

By Tim Rohr

We are constantly lectured by the pro-aborts that what a woman does with her body is "none of your business." 

Okay, fair enough. Never mind the scientific fact that there is another body in the woman's body, let's grant the pro-aborts their argument for now. 

The question then becomes: "Okay, at what point is that "other thing in your body" not your body?

According to our now-governor, even after that "other thing in your body" is no longer in your body but laying on a delivery table or in a waste bucket still alive and gasping for life, that "other thing that WAS in your body" is still "your body" and you have the right to kill "the thing," even if the thing is no longer in your body - and that's because you wanted the thing dead in the first place.  

(Listen to Tall Tales every Friday after the "half-time" show to hear or watch a recording of the now-governor arguing for the death of the living "thing" at a legislative public hearing.)

Okay, that's a bit extreme, so let's back up a bit. 

Let's say the thing is already mostly delivered except for the thing's head which is still inside your body. Is it still your body? If so, then is it okay with you to stick a knife into the back of the thing's head and scramble its brains before delivering the rest of the now-dead thing? 

Note: In case you don't know this is called partial-birth abortion, and Sens. Fisher and Barnes' new bill will remove the ban on this particular way of killing the thing.

Okay, that's still a bit extreme, I mean the thing's arms and legs flailing about at the moment the knife stabs into its brains (as described by nurse witnesses). So let's back up a little more. Let's back up to Roe, the pro-abort's monument upon which the "none of your business" mantra is built.

Pro-aborts will probably be surprised to learn that Roe never said "it's none of your business." In fact, it pretty much said it's none of the woman's business.  

Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973) at XI, the Court wrote:

(a) For the stage prior to approximately the end of the first trimester, the abortion decision and its effectuation must be left to the medical judgment of the pregnant woman's attending physician.

(b) For the stage subsequent to approximately the end of the first trimester, the State, in promoting its interest in the health of the mother, may, if it chooses, regulate the abortion procedure in ways that are reasonably related to maternal health.

(c) For the stage subsequent to viability, the State in promoting its interest in the potentiality of human life may, if it chooses, regulate, and even proscribe, abortion except where it is necessary, in appropriate medical judgment, for the preservation of the life or health of the mother.

Note that in (a) the decision is not the woman's but "the woman's attending physician." And note that in (b) and (c), the Court clearly makes a case for "it's the state's business." In fact, it could be said that the recent decision in Dobbs, giving the regulation of abortion back to the states, was just doing what Roe itself had already called for 50 years earlier, at least for the second and third trimesters. 

So, at least according to Roe re abortion in the second and third trimesters, a decision to "kill the thing" in your body IS "our business," because "who is the state" other than we, the people, who reside and vote there?

But back to where we started for a minute. Is it your business to care about a child who is demonstrably abused, neglected or abandoned? If so, at what point is that child "your business?" Still in the womb, partially delivered out of the womb, out of the womb altogether, 3 minutes old, 3 years old? Where's the line? 

At least Roe drew a line, even with conditions, at about 12 weeks gestation, or the end of the first trimester. And given that even during the first trimester the decision was never the woman's but the physician's (probably a man at the time), it could be said that the ultimate decision to abort was never the woman's. 

And since the pro-aborts cannot provide a line - even wanting the legal right to kill the thing already delivered and still alive  - we will. And our line is this: 

IT IS NEVER OKAY TO KILL A HELPLESS, INNOCENT, DEFENSELESS HUMAN BEING. NEVER. 

Sunday, April 30, 2023

I AGREE WITH VANESSA

By Tim Rohr

 

I agree with Vanessa Williams per the following highlighted portions of her remarks to the Guam Daily Post:

Attorney Vanessa Williams, who supports abortion rights, while not fully on board with an islandwide vote on abortion, agreed with the legislative intent of the bill that states "many of our citizens believe that abortion services are essential health care."

"Abortion is health care. It shouldn't take a referendum for Guam to protect health care for people who can get pregnant," Williams said.

But if lawmakers approve giving voters the power to decide the legality of abortion, Williams predicts the election will favor access to abortions.

There are some solid arguments, pro and con, against referendums. One of the "cons" is that referendums are a default to direct-democracy and an open door to "tyranny of the majority." 

Our nation's founders specifically sought to insulate the nation they intended to found from tyranny, of the majority or otherwise, by hammering out the parameters of a republican form of government which may be otherwise referred to as a representative democracy. 

The key word is "representative," and it's why we go through this crazy exercise every two years with signs and ads and signs and ads and signs and ads... We elect these people (our legislature) for a reason. We elect them AND PAY THEM to do the tough stuff of government, for better or worse, until the next election do we part. 

A referendum is a cop out, a real run and hide by the people we elect and pay - especially on this issue. In fact, it can be said that there has already been a referendum. That's what the legislative election is every two years. It is the people's referendum on who they trust to make and unmake laws. 

So, I agree with Vanessa. It shouldn't take a referendum. In fact, at this point not only is no referendum needed, but for the pro-aborts, no legislation of any sort is needed. 

Abortion is completely legal in Guam save for a very few limits: 1) you can't kill a mostly-born baby by sticking a knife into the back of her head as she comes down the birth canal (partial-birth abortion); 2) minors need parental consent (but not always); 3) women seeking abortion are required to be informed of the abortion's risks and alternatives; and 4) abortion stats must be reported. That's it. 

Oh, there's one more. You can't kill a baby who survives an abortion - even if the current governor says "do it." (Listen to Tall Tales every Friday after the half-time show to hear LLG's public testimony as to why these babies should be left to die...or ask her yourself the next time you see her receive communion at the Cathedral.)

So I agree with Vanessa on the referendum thing, but I also agree with her that "the election will favor abortion." I agree with her because CHamoru's - at least the majority - apparently have a self-extinction wish. And I don't know how to reverse it. 

Even though the CHamoru population in Guam has been grievously declining for years, the majority of CHamoru's twice elected as their governor the most ardent, vociferous, and vicious proponent of CHamoru self-extinction to ever run for office. 




DAVE SABLAN'S FULL COMMENTS TO THE POST

David Sablan, President of Concerned Catholics of Guam, is quoted in today's Guam Daily Post article "Advocates react to possible abortion vote."

 Mr. Sablan requests that JW publish his full comment to the Post as follows:

4/29/23


Hi Shane,


Thanks for your WhatsApp text message on the above subject matter.


I read Bill 106-37.


I do not agree with some of the findings and intent of this bill.  There

are mistakes and disinformation throughout the bill.


For example, the bill states that "many of our citizens believe that

abortion services are essential healthcare."  More correctly, there is

only a minority of Guam citizens who want abortion services, and most

certainly I would not classify abortion as "healthcare" when the murder of

a human life is involved in the process. Why do these abortion activists

never consider the developing baby in the mother's womb as a developing

human life.


Another point mentioned in the bill is, ". . . the US Supreme Court has

recognized the constitutional right to terminate a pregnancy before fetal

viability. . . and after fetal viability where it is necessary, in the

good-faith medical judgment of the treating health care professional, for

the preservation of life or health of the person who is pregnant."


Where's the concern for the preservation of the life or health of the

person in the mother's womb?  It is an evil act to abort a human being.

We have no right to play God and determine who lives or not.  PL 20-134

clearly brings this matter to light for both the mother and the person

performing the abortion, making it a misdemeanor and felony, respectively.


The US Supreme Court decided in the Dobbs case in June 2020 that abortion

is NOT a constitutional right.  In that same case, the US Supreme Court

moved the decision on abortion to the individual states and territories.


We should wait for Attorney General Doug Moylan's appeal to overturn the

decision of the district court, denying his motion to remove the

injunction on Guam's PL 20-134 that was passed in 1990--unanimously by the

21 senators of the Guam Legislature at the time and signed into law by

Governor Joseph Ada--which prevented abortion from inception.


Now that the Dobbs decision by the US Supreme Court overturned Roe v.

Wade, PL 20-134 is the law for Guam now.  I believe Attorney General Doug

Moylan is doing the right thing to get PL 20-134 codified into Guam law.


In PL 20-134, there is a provision for a referendum by the people of Guam.

That referendum can be put on the ballot, once PL 20-134's injunction is

lifted.


So, bill 106-37 is flawed with misinformation and disinformation, and not

necessary.


Sincerely,


/s/ David J. Sablan, President

CONCERNED CATHOLICS OF GUAM, INC.